OpinionResearch

Fisher Investments’ Founder, Ken Fisher, Debunks: “A Strong Dollar Is Super”

Fisher Investments

Ken Fisher argues that the common belief that a strong dollar is good for stock markets and a weak dollar is bad is statistically false. Historical data shows no predictive correlation between dollar strength and market performance across developed nations, with market movements occurring independently of currency fluctuations.

Summary

Ken Fisher, founder of Fisher Investments, debunks the widespread misconception that dollar strength predicts stock market performance. He begins by acknowledging this is a commonly held belief in America and explores why this conventional wisdom is incorrect.

Fisher employs a "four box analysis" to demonstrate the lack of correlation: examining all combinations of dollar strength/weakness paired with market strength/weakness over extended periods. He shows that these four scenarios occur with roughly equal frequency, indicating no predictive relationship. He cites specific examples: 2021 had a strong dollar and strong market performance, while the 2022-2024 period saw a weak dollar alongside strong market gains, demonstrating inconsistency in any supposed pattern.

The key to understanding why dollar movements don't predict market outcomes lies in how currencies are measured—against baskets of other currencies through trade-weighted indices. Since the U.S. stock market has very high correlation with other developed nation stock markets (0.7 and above), if a strong dollar implied weakness in other currencies and vice versa, we would expect opposite movements in foreign versus U.S. markets. However, historical data spanning back to the 19th century shows developed market indices move together, not oppositely.

Fisher uses an extended analogy comparing currency and financial instrument movements to water flowing down different topographies toward the ocean. Interest rates and currencies from different countries follow different paths based on local economic conditions, but ultimately all converge in liquid global markets driven by gravity-like forces. Over time, currency pairs return to similar trading levels despite decades of oscillation.

He emphasizes this analysis applies specifically to developed nations with stable currency systems. He acknowledges that less-developed nations can experience currency crises with real economic impact, but this dynamic doesn't apply to established developed-country currencies. The conclusion is that while individuals might speculate on currency movements and occasionally profit, the dollar's strength or weakness carries no predictive power for stock market performance.

Key Insights

  • Fisher demonstrates through four-box analysis that dollar strength paired with market performance occurs in four roughly equal combinations (strong dollar/up market, strong dollar/down market, weak dollar/up market, weak dollar/down market) with no predictive pattern
  • The U.S. stock market maintains very high positive correlation with other developed country stock markets (0.7 and above), which makes currency movements logically incompatible with the theory that strong dollars predict market strength
  • Currency pairs against other developed-nation currencies return to similar trading levels over decades despite oscillating up and down, functioning like water flowing toward the ocean through different topographies
  • Historical data reaching back to the 19th century shows developed markets maintain positive correlation with imperfect historical indexes, contradicting the theory that currency strength would cause inverse market movements
  • Fisher's analysis applies only to developed nations with stable currencies; less-developed countries can experience currency crises with genuine economic impact, but this dynamic does not apply to established developed-country currencies

Topics

Dollar strength and stock market correlationStatistical analysis of currency movementsDeveloped versus less-developed market economicsMyth debunking in investment philosophyGlobal capital flows and liquidity

Transcript

[0:00] In America, Americans tend to believe that a strong dollar is good for the stock market, and a weak dollar is bad for the stock market. This view is very common. This view is also wrong. Every month I go through one of these little micro chapters of my book on some piece of bunk that people conventionally believe is true that isn't true. And so this month, I'm doing [0:31] bunk number 27. This is: a strong dollar is super. Now, there is a general view that Americans have. And you can see this view in the reverse in a lot of foreign countries, which to them aren't foreign. That in America, Americans tend to believe that a…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Fisher Investments

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.