A Candid Take on US-Canada Tariffs
Ken Fisher argues that US-Canada tariffs are counterproductive political theater that harm both nations without achieving their stated goals. He contends tariffs are fundamentally negative tools, citing evidence that trade deficits actually increased after tariff implementation, and suggests both leaders benefit politically while ordinary citizens suffer the consequences.
Summary
Ken Fisher presents a critical analysis of recent US-Canada tariff disputes, beginning with his stated bias against tariffs as economic policy tools. He characterizes the tariff announcements by President Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Carney as emotionally-driven rather than principle-based, advocating instead for a "First, do no harm" political philosophy.
Fisher examines Trump's April 2, 2025 global tariff announcement, which was justified by claims of trade deficits and foreign market manipulation. However, Fisher provides empirical evidence contradicting tariffs' effectiveness: in the four months before the tariffs were imposed, the trade deficit nearly doubled as importers rushed to beat the tariffs. Following the tariff implementation, the trade deficit subsequently grew by 25%, suggesting tariffs failed to achieve their stated objective.
Applying this logic to the US-Canada bilateral situation, Fisher notes the countries have maintained a free trade agreement despite running a trade deficit. He explains that trade deficits are influenced by multiple factors beyond tariffs, and that numerous legal and illegal workarounds exist to circumvent tariff restrictions—describing tariffs as ineffective as "pouring water through cloth."
Fisher identifies a political irony: both Trump and Carney gain domestic political popularity by criticizing each other, creating perverse incentives for escalation despite real harm to citizens. He emphasizes that while America can absorb economic damage better due to its size, both nations will experience pointless suffering. Fisher concludes this is a political tragedy that will likely resolve after midterm elections and could have been handled more civilly.
Key Insights
- The trade deficit doubled in the four months before tariffs were imposed as importers rushed inventory ahead of expected tariffs, then grew 25% after tariffs were implemented, demonstrating tariffs failed to reduce the stated target metric
- Tariffs are inherently ineffective because there are numerous legal and illegal methods to circumvent them, resulting in tariffs being collected at only a small percentage of their supposed charged rate
- Both President Trump and Prime Minister Carney gain domestic political popularity when criticizing each other, creating mutual incentives for escalation despite causing real economic harm to citizens
- Trade deficits with Canada cannot be singularly attributed to tariff issues, as multiple factors influence trade balances and substitution mechanisms exist to work around tariff restrictions
- Fisher predicts the US-Canada tariff conflict will likely resolve after midterm elections, suggesting it is driven by short-term political calculation rather than substantive economic policy objectives
Topics
Transcript
[0:04] Recent months, it's been a lot of hoopla. President Trump applying tariffs to Canada. Carney in Canada applying tariffs to the US. Hostilities expressed both ways. I'm just going to say that a lot of that stuff was shoot from the hip, emotions from politicians who would do better to be slow and operate off of a principle of "First, do no harm." [0:37] Now, I have a big bias. I'm biased against tariffs. I've always been biased against tariffs. I don't think tariffs are all in everything, but tariffs are a negative. They're not a positive. The fact of the matter is there's a lot of things you can say. Let me take you to the fecklessness of…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Fisher Investments
Ken Fisher Discusses South Korean Stocks, Software Stocks, AI Debt, ETFs and More
Ken Fisher addresses investor questions on foreign stocks, South Korean markets, software stocks, AI-backed securitized debt, and ETF investing. He emphasizes that while history rhymes rather than repeats, most bear market causes remain fundamentally similar, and that blanket statements about entire sectors like software are unhelpful without microanalysis.
3 Things You Need to Know This Week | Anthropic IPO, Fed Minutes, Europe Inflation (Nov. 16, 2026)
This market analysis video highlights three key developments for the week of November 16, 2026: Anthropic's NASDAQ IPO, Federal Reserve meeting minutes, and UK/Eurozone inflation data releases. The hosts advise investors to avoid rushing into IPOs, not to overanalyze Fed communications, and to monitor European inflation trends given differing central bank responses.
This Week in Review | Market Volatility, Q3 Earnings, US Inflation (Nov. 13, 2026)
This Week in Review discusses three major market developments from November 2026: recent market volatility driven by election results and earnings reports, strong Q3 corporate earnings across all S&P 500 sectors despite tech stock declines, and moderating US inflation with energy price deceleration despite slightly higher-than-expected CPI readings.
Why Long Yields Are Up in 2026
Ken Fisher explains that rising long-term interest rates in 2026 stem from multiple factors including excessive money growth, AI infrastructure borrowing concerns, fears of high government debt, and oil-related inflation pressures from geopolitical tensions. While rising rates have negative consumer impacts, Fisher notes they also have positive effects on bank lending that offset some downsides.
Ken Fisher: The Most Overblown Investor Fear in 2026
Ken Fisher argues that fears about AI are the most overblown investor concern in 2026, noting that while AI will create problems like all technological innovations, people disproportionately fear losses more than they appreciate comparable gains, causing cultural anxiety to outpace both the actual adoption rate and realistic risk assessment.