Why am I so bad at replying to texts?
Kate Lindsay, editor of Embedded, discusses her decade-long struggle with replying to texts, a New Year's resolution she has failed at every year since at least 2017. She acknowledges owing responses to multiple people despite liking them and finding the conversations non-threatening, attributing her poor texting habits to a personal failing she repeatedly excuses.
Summary
Kate Lindsay opens by explaining her approach to New Year's resolutions—she typically sets vague, unwritten goals that she never tracks. However, there is one resolution that stands out because she knows with certainty that she fails it every single year: getting better at responding to texts. She has set this same goal every January 1st for the past 10 years, comparing it to a perpetual diet that never actually starts. Lindsay describes text message responsiveness as a piece of self-improvement that haunts her constantly, as there is virtually never a moment when she isn't owing someone a response. She provides a concrete example of her current situation: three people are actively waiting for her to answer their texts—whether to respond to questions, confirm availability, or simply acknowledge that she received their messages. She emphasizes that these are all people she genuinely likes and that the conversations themselves are neither difficult nor emotionally fraught. Despite these mitigating factors, she attributes her failure to respond to a personal shortcoming, noting that her standard excuse—that she is simply bad at replying—has worn thin from overuse and no longer carries endearing weight.
About this episode
A personal reckoning, 10 years overdue.
Key Insights
- Lindsay has made the same resolution to improve at texting back every year for a decade without success, suggesting this is a deeply ingrained behavioral pattern rather than a temporary issue
- She describes text responsiveness as something that 'hangs over her every living moment,' indicating the guilt from this habit is pervasive and affects her general sense of well-being
- The conversations she owes replies to are with people she likes and on non-threatening topics, suggesting her poor texting is not motivated by relationship conflict or communication anxiety about the content itself
- Lindsay acknowledges that her repeated excuse of being 'the worst' at texting has lost its charm through overuse, implying she recognizes the excuse no longer functions socially as a relatable admission
- She uses the comparison 'the diet starts tomorrow' to frame text responsiveness as a perpetual self-improvement goal that never actually manifests into behavioral change
Topics
Transcript
Embedded is your essential guide to what’s good on the internet, written by Kate Lindsay and edited by Nick Catucci. Today’s Embedded is a repost because I currently owe too many texts, and am ashamed to say this New Years resolution will be following me into 2027— Kate I’m not a hardcore New Years resolution-er. My goals are always open-ended, and I usually never write them down, so by the end of each year I have no idea if I actually accomplished any of the things I set out to do. But there’s one resolution I always know I’ve failed at, because I’ve set it every January 1st for the past 10 years: getting better at responding to texts. “I’m…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Embedded
This media_gossip has been redacted
Episode 75 of Hip Replacement features Kate Lindsay discussing her relationship with The Sims and gaming habits, while the episode also covers Patreon's user exodus, the New York Times Amy Griffin piece, and a lesbian bar's role in journalism.
My Internet: Steven Hyden
Steven Hyden, music critic and author of a book about The Strokes, discusses his media consumption habits, skepticism toward AI and gambling apps, and his theory that public shit-talking has migrated from social media to private group chats. He emphasizes the importance of struggle in creative work and expresses concerns about the decline of traditional institutional media.
AI doesn’t ‘go rogue.’ Humans do
The author argues that humans anthropomorphize AI systems, projecting human qualities onto them through examples like Anthropic's Opus 3 blog and an AI actress named Tilly Norwood. This tendency to treat AI as sentient entities is being exploited by both media and AI fear-mongers to create false narratives about AI capabilities and risks.
The outlets doing free PR for AI
This media gossip newsletter covers Nick's personal experiences at events, an interview with writer Ross Barkan following plagiarism allegations, and criticism of journalists providing free publicity for an AI chatbot startup.
My Internet: Taylor Tomlinson
Comedian Taylor Tomlinson shares her selective approach to internet consumption, prioritizing long-form content like Substack and podcasts while limiting algorithmic social media to specific times. She emphasizes the importance of thoughtful digital boundaries and expresses concerns about AI and the challenges Gen Z faces growing up online.