Caro Claire Burke is beefing with The Atlantic
A media gossip newsletter covering social media trends around male celebrity bodies, event coverage from publishing industry parties, and recent controversies including backlash to Larry David's DSA satire and questions about The Ringer's pivot to Substack.
Summary
This is an excerpt from Embedded's weekly media gossip column. The newsletter opens with Nick's personal observation about the prevalence of male thirst traps and celebrity body commentary on social media feeds, comparing the phenomenon to pop culture references. The column includes a fashion recommendation about fall pants behind a paywall. The authors attended a Teen Vogue x Wattpad launch event at McNally Jackson Seaport, where Kate had an awkward conversation with Pitchfork's Head of Editorial Mano Sundaresan. Kate confidently suggested Pitchfork launch a subscription feature allowing readers to submit album scores displayed alongside official ratings, only to learn the publication had already implemented this feature nine months prior. The newsletter also reports on significant backlash to Larry David's DSA satire published in Air Mail, which garnered so much criticism that The New York Times wrote an article about the negative reception—which itself subsequently became the subject of widespread criticism. Finally, the piece references an unexplored theory about The Ringer's recent decision to pivot toward Substack, suggesting there are untold reasons behind this business decision that people are reluctant to discuss.
About this episode
Plus: Teen Vogue x Wattpad, the DSA vs Air Mail, and more on The Ringer’s pivot to Substack.
Key Insights
- Social media feeds have become saturated with male celebrity thirst traps and body-focused content, creating a widespread cultural phenomenon that mirrors decades-old entertainment tropes
- The New York Times amplified backlash to Larry David's Air Mail satire by publishing a critical piece about the negative reception, which then became itself subject to substantial criticism
- Pitchfork implemented a reader-submitted album scoring feature that displays alongside official ratings, but this feature remains relatively unknown even among media industry professionals
- The Ringer's pivot to Substack involves unexplained motivations that media insiders appear reluctant or unwilling to publicly discuss or analyze
- Media industry events serve as networking venues where professionals may inadvertently reveal gaps in their knowledge about competing publications' features and strategies
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to media_gossip, Embedded’s special weekly edition of … media gossip, sent every Friday. You’re getting this because you subscribe to Embedded, but you can opt out here . Nick’s Riff This Week Like Donald Trump, I am not gay, but I have recently been paying close attention to men’s bodies : “Like Smithers with the strippers, my feeds have recently been inundated with male thirst traps, celebrations of ‘fat’ Ryan Gosling, gotchas of fat Leonardo DiCaprio, and a guy with the handle ‘Perpetually Bulking’ (although now he’s going by ‘Glen Stefani’).” Plus: The only pants I’m wearing this fall (same post, past the paywall) Live shot of Nick and I realizing the place we had chosen to stand was…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Embedded
The Boomers Turned “Screenagers”
This podcast episode explores the overlooked phenomenon of elderly parents' social media addictions, challenging the common narrative that screen addiction is primarily a youth issue. Host Kate Lindsay interviews writer Jessica Lucas about her New York Magazine piece on how adult children are grappling with and attempting to manage their senior parents' excessive digital habits.
An Internet Boyfriend Just Made The Movie Of The Year
Nathan Fielding's documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos has sparked significant online debate. Despite extensive prior coverage of Holmes through books, documentaries, and TV adaptations, Fielding's project offers a fundamentally different exploration that extends beyond the subject matter itself.
The woman-ification of “women”
The essay explores how internet culture, particularly TikTok, has influenced the pronunciation of "women" to sound like "woman," examining this phenomenon through the lens of how technology shapes language evolution. The author analyzes two competing theories for this change: English spelling's inherent phonetic inconsistencies and spelling pronunciation, while acknowledging a third theory she finds harder to remain neutral about.
The “Tradwife” To Girlboss Pipeline
Internet personalities who built their brands around the "tradwife" aesthetic are publicly distancing themselves from the label and rebranding. Figures like Nara Smith and Hannah Neeleman are shifting focus toward business ventures and cookbooks, while the term itself risks losing meaning as its original associations fade.
This “unconventional” fragrance brand is polarizing for a reason
Ingrid Nilsen and Erica Anderson, founders of The New Savant fragrance brand, discuss their transition from digital-first careers to building a deliberately unconventional, polarizing fragrance business that prioritizes creativity and personal meaning over mass-market appeal. They reflect on how leaving social media's constant scrutiny has allowed them to develop creative resilience and trust their instincts.