This “unconventional” fragrance brand is polarizing for a reason
Ingrid Nilsen and Erica Anderson, founders of The New Savant fragrance brand, discuss their transition from digital-first careers to building a deliberately unconventional, polarizing fragrance business that prioritizes creativity and personal meaning over mass-market appeal. They reflect on how leaving social media's constant scrutiny has allowed them to develop creative resilience and trust their instincts.
Summary
This interview features Ingrid Nilsen, a former YouTuber who created the "Vlogmas" tradition and pioneered coming-out video content, and Erica Anderson, an early Twitter employee who worked across tech and media companies, discussing their co-founded fragrance brand The New Savant, now in its sixth year with over 30,000 followers and 600+ repeat customers.
Both founders discuss their relationship with social media and how it changed upon launching The New Savant. Ingrid describes the exhaustion of being the product herself on YouTube, where even mundane activities like washing dishes became subject to how they'd be perceived online. She felt a loss of boundaries and control, constantly performing rather than living authentically. Erica similarly describes stepping back from a 24/7 digital-first life spanning 15 years at the intersection of technology and news media, where she felt compelled to present every post as intelligent commentary on current events under her "Erica America" moniker.
Both emphasize the importance of creative resilience—the ability to experiment, fail, and continue—as central to their business success. Ingrid credits her father, a lifelong creative, with instilling this skill in her from childhood. She acknowledges thinking about failure daily but frames this not as pessimism but as acceptance of uncertainty and focus on learning and execution rather than outcomes. She describes recent instances where multiple iterations were necessary and how trusting her instincts over trying to please multiple stakeholders ultimately led to the right creative decisions.
The founders discuss their deliberate strategy of making polarizing scents that challenge the fragrance industry's "white, eurocentric norms." Their bestseller, Pandan Spice Latte, references Ingrid's mother's South Asian homeland. They intentionally reject mass-market optimization, instead creating cerebral scents like "the joy that can spring from grief" or experiences tied to specific cultural moments. Ingrid emphasizes that this polarization is political and intentional—a feature, not a bug.
Regarding feedback and criticism online, Ingrid describes distinguishing between genuine feedback and meaningless online commentary. She notes that criticism stings most when directed at deeply personal scents or when it carries undertones of the ignorance and cruelty she heard toward Asian culture in childhood. However, she manages this by remembering her core mission isn't to please everyone but to create for people who need these specific scents.
On community engagement, the founders identify Instagram and email as their primary platforms, noting their customers are savvy online but prioritize offline life. They observe high engagement with longer-form, thoughtful content and see traffic spikes when mentioned on Substack, indicating their audience values substance over constant promotional content. They actively build community through sampling, guerilla marketing, in-person events, and retailer partnerships. Ingrid observes that people "smell with their eyes first"—preconceptions based on scent names and descriptions influence perception before actual olfactory experience, making hands-on sampling critical for surprising and converting customers.
About this episode
“I think about it failing every single day,” The New Savant cofounder, Ingrid Nilsen, says.
Key Insights
- Ingrid describes how constant social media documentation fundamentally altered her relationship with everyday activities, creating a secondary layer of performance anxiety that made even mundane tasks like washing dishes feel like content opportunities rather than lived experiences.
- The New Savant's founders intentionally embrace polarization as a political strategy to challenge the fragrance industry's eurocentric norms, meaning strong negative reactions to their products are actually indicators they're succeeding at their mission rather than signs of failure.
- Ingrid practices a form of creative resilience where she focuses on the learning process and quality of work output rather than guaranteed success, describing her daily practice as choosing to proceed with projects despite constant awareness of potential failure.
- The brand's customers demonstrate a preference for offline life and longer-form thoughtful content, evidenced by high email engagement and traffic spikes from Substack mentions, suggesting their audience actively rejects constant promotional noise.
- Ingrid observes that consumers form preconceived judgments about scent based on visual and textual cues before experiencing the actual product, making direct sampling essential because people are frequently surprised by what they end up enjoying once they smell it.
Topics
Transcript
Embedded is your essential guide to what’s good on the internet, written by Kate Lindsay and edited by Nick Catucci. This interview is part of a limited series on Embedded, brought to you by In Stock , Shopify’s Substack about the craft and culture of entrepreneurship. Thank you Shopify!!! —Kate New on ICYMI: Toxic “estranged parent” Facebook groups are making relationships worse. Head over here to subscribe to ICYMI wherever you listen to podcasts 🫶 A sample of The New Savant’s Instagram. One of the privileges of my job is I now have an inside joke with one of my favorite creators. I first interviewed former YouTuber Ingrid Nilsen in 2017 , about being the creator of the now-ubiquitous tradition…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Embedded
The Boomers Turned “Screenagers”
This podcast episode explores the overlooked phenomenon of elderly parents' social media addictions, challenging the common narrative that screen addiction is primarily a youth issue. Host Kate Lindsay interviews writer Jessica Lucas about her New York Magazine piece on how adult children are grappling with and attempting to manage their senior parents' excessive digital habits.
An Internet Boyfriend Just Made The Movie Of The Year
Nathan Fielding's documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos has sparked significant online debate. Despite extensive prior coverage of Holmes through books, documentaries, and TV adaptations, Fielding's project offers a fundamentally different exploration that extends beyond the subject matter itself.
The woman-ification of “women”
The essay explores how internet culture, particularly TikTok, has influenced the pronunciation of "women" to sound like "woman," examining this phenomenon through the lens of how technology shapes language evolution. The author analyzes two competing theories for this change: English spelling's inherent phonetic inconsistencies and spelling pronunciation, while acknowledging a third theory she finds harder to remain neutral about.
The “Tradwife” To Girlboss Pipeline
Internet personalities who built their brands around the "tradwife" aesthetic are publicly distancing themselves from the label and rebranding. Figures like Nara Smith and Hannah Neeleman are shifting focus toward business ventures and cookbooks, while the term itself risks losing meaning as its original associations fade.
Caro Claire Burke is beefing with The Atlantic
A media gossip newsletter covering social media trends around male celebrity bodies, event coverage from publishing industry parties, and recent controversies including backlash to Larry David's DSA satire and questions about The Ringer's pivot to Substack.