StoryOpinion

Yikes! Some of The Sports Card Sales I Wish I Could Take Back

Chris Soul, a baseball card collector and dealer, reviews 25+ sales from his PWCC account (2021-2023) that have significantly increased in value, showcasing regrettable early sales of cards like Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, and Shaquille O'Neal rookies and inserts that have appreciated 3-15x since sale. He acknowledges this is part of dealing in high volume, while also noting examples of cards that depreciated to balance the narrative.

Summary

Chris Soul presents a video analysis of his past sports card sales, primarily from 2021-2023, that he wishes he could take back due to substantial value appreciation. He emphasizes that while most cards from that period have remained relatively flat, a notable subset has dramatically increased in value.

The video walks through approximately 25 specific sales, starting with lower-value examples and progressively featuring more extreme cases. Early examples include an Ichiro/Ohtani rookie that sold for $160 but is now worth ~$600, a Steph Curry Prizm light blue die-cut PSA 10 that sold for $1,400 but now commands ~$3,700, and several 1987 Topps Tiffany rookie cards (Greg Maddux, Bo Jackson) that have appreciated 2-5x.

The most significant appreciation comes from 1990s basketball insert cards and modern basketball rookies. Notable examples include: a 1997 Topps Rock Stars Shaq refractor sold for $600 now worth $6,000 (10x); a 1992 Stadium Club Beam Team Jordan sold for $650 now worth $6,000+ (10x); a 1994 Emotion Intense Jordan sold for $650 now worth $5,000+; and most dramatically, a 1997 Metal Universe Kobe Bryant PSA 10 sold for $1,000 in 2022 now worth $15,000 (15x appreciation).

Other extreme examples include a 2007 Topps Chrome white refractor LeBron James that sold for $9,000 and now fetches $21,000, and a 2021 Donruss Road to Qatar Cristiano Ronaldo that sold for $1,850 and now reaches $9,200.

Soul addresses the counterbalance by noting cards that depreciated significantly, such as a 2017 Deshaun Watson rookie that sold for $175 now worth ~$10, and a 2019 Fernando Tatis Jr. rookie that sold for $700 now worth $50. He concludes by sharing three additional personal collection cards (1980 Bird-Magic-Erving rookie, 2001 Tiger Woods rookie, 1928 Lou Gehrig Ice Cream card) that either appreciated minimally or have no recorded subsequent sales.

Soul reframes the experience as an inevitable part of high-volume dealing, where some sales will always outperform expectations while others will underperform, making it impossible to avoid selling appreciating assets.

Key Insights

  • Chris Soul sold a 1997 Metal Universe Kobe Bryant PSA 10 for $1,000 in 2022 that recently sold for $15,000, representing a 15x multiplier increase—the most extreme example of value appreciation in his portfolio review
  • 1990s basketball insert cards in PSA 10 condition have 'exploded' in value, particularly for players like Jordan, Kobe, and Shaq, with multiple examples showing 10x appreciation over 2-4 years
  • High-volume card dealers inevitably sell appreciating assets because the math of dealing in quantity means some cards will always increase in value while others decrease, making it impossible to perfectly time all sales
  • A 2007 Topps Chrome white refractor LeBron James PSA 10 (pop 12) that Soul listed at $14,000 and sold for $9,000 in 2022 has since appreciated to $21,000, representing a $12,000 gain since the original sale
  • Cards that depreciated significantly since sale include a 2017 Deshaun Watson rookie that sold for $175 now worth approximately $10, and a 2019 Fernando Tatis Jr. rookie that sold for $700 now worth $50

Topics

Sports card sales and investmentBasketball inserts (1990s era)Michael Jordan cardsKobe Bryant cardsLeBron James cardsShaquille O'Neal cardsBaseball rookies (1980s-2010s)Card grading and condition sensitivityPWCC and Fanatics marketplaceHigh-volume dealer perspectiveMarket appreciation over time

Transcript

[0:00] Chris Soul here, baseball card collector, investor, dealer in that order. Welcome everyone. I recently went through some of my old sales from my old PWCC account, which has they've been since bought by Fanatics. But, I was going to just through going through some old sales from like 2021 and 2022 just looking over the list out of curiosity. And oh wow, there are some cards in there I really wish I had not sold back then. Now, to be clear, there were lots of cards that have gone down in value since then. And and the vast majority of cards actually have basically held you know, been kind of flat or gone up a little bit or…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.