OpinionDiscussion

Thoughts on Cards as Investments, Dollar Boxes at Shows, PSA vs TAG, Unlicensed Cards, and More

Chris Soul addresses eight viewer questions about card collecting and investing, covering topics like card security, dollar boxes at shows, investment viability, grading companies, unlicensed cards, and potential labor stoppage impacts. He emphasizes that the vast majority of cards are poor investments and advocates for licensed cards over unlicensed alternatives.

Summary

Chris Soul, who identifies himself as a baseball card collector, investor, and dealer, responds to eight viewer-submitted questions about various aspects of the sports card hobby. Regarding security concerns about leaving cards in vehicles, he clarifies that he typically brings valuable cards to his hotel room but may leave bulk, lower-value cards in the car when the majority of value fits in a few boxes. He acknowledges theft risk is a concern but wasn't major in his specific situation.

On dollar boxes and quarter boxes at card shows, Soul admits he no longer frequents these boxes, primarily because he rarely attends card shows anymore. The Chantelli Show he used to set up at no longer exists, and his business model no longer relies on card shows for wheeling and dealing, though he would participate if he had spare time.

Regarding cards as investments, Soul strongly cautions that more than 99% of cards are poor long-term investments and warns against blanket statements that cards are investments. He identifies key rookie cards of Hall of Famers in high grades as the safest investment category, while naming baseball prospects and young active football quarterbacks as the worst investment categories, with the odds heavily against most prospects ever becoming valuable.

For Tyler's question about a rare 2026 Topps Series 1 Shohei Ohtani Spring Training Parallel numbered out of 10 graded PSA 10, Soul congratulates him and notes the lack of comps makes pricing difficult. He suggests using comparable cards as reference points and recommends either auctioning it quickly, selling on eBay for maximum value, or shopping it at shows. He personally would auction modern cards rather than hold them.

On Ron's question about unlicensed cards being undervalued, Soul expresses personal bias against them, comparing licensed cards to major league games and unlicensed cards to pick-up games by major leaguers—the same players but lacking the same cultural significance. He uses Jose Canseco oddball cards as a historical example showing that unlicensed cards underperformed their licensed counterparts, though he acknowledges the 50/50 aspect of Ohtani's Leaf card is interesting.

For the question about assessing mystery boxes of unsorted cards, Soul explains that most such boxes yield nothing because collectors typically remove good cards before selling. He uses time management and quick visual assessments to determine if a box warrants deeper investigation, moving on if initial indicators suggest no hidden treasures.

On potential baseball labor stoppages, Soul predicts short stoppages would have minimal impact on card values, with only temporary dips. However, extended lockouts or season cancellations could have major impacts similar to the 1994 strike, which caused significant frustration, hobby attrition, and value declines he witnessed firsthand.

Finally, addressing criticism about his continued use of PSA despite complaints, Soul counters that SGC and Beckett are owned by the same parent company as PSA, so switching doesn't solve the centralization problem. He argues it's not his job to prop up TAG or other competitors until they prove they're ready for the big leagues, comparing them to backup quarterbacks who haven't earned a starting position.

Key Insights

  • Soul claims that more than 99% of cards will not provide good returns if investment appreciation is the sole goal, making sports cards a dangerous blanket investment category
  • Soul argues that key rookie cards of established Hall of Famers in high grades (like PSA 9) represent the safest investment category, while raw or low-grade copies of the same cards do not fit investment criteria
  • Soul identifies baseball prospects as the ultimate worst investment category, noting that only about one player per year from hundreds of annual first Bowman cards and autos proves to be a good long-term investment
  • Soul contends that PSA, SGC, and Beckett are all owned by the same parent company, meaning switching between them doesn't address the centralization problem critics raise
  • Soul claims the 1994 baseball strike had a major impact on card values, causing significant frustration, hobby attrition, and noticeable value declines he witnessed firsthand

Topics

Card security and theft riskCard shows and dollar box huntingSports cards as investmentsHigh-grade key rookie card valuationsGrading company comparison (PSA vs TAG vs SGC)Unlicensed vs licensed cardsMystery box and unsorted collection assessmentBaseball labor stoppage market impactOhtani parallel card valuation strategyProspect cards as poor investments

Transcript

[0:00] Chris Soul here, baseball card collector, investor, dealer in that order. Welcome everyone. Got eight great questions from viewers and yeah, gonna run through them here. Hope everyone enjoys. First question comes from Darren who wrote, "I heard you say in your last Adventures and Card dealing video that you left the cards in your car overnight when you stayed at the hotel. Aren't you nervous that the cards will get stolen? Just the idea of that is terrifying to me, especially since you spent something like 20k on the cards. Just curious if that is a major concern to you." Yeah, thanks for the question. So, to be clear, I I generally do not leave the cards out…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.