DiscussionOpinion

Notes On Buying Card Collections After the Owner Has Passed Away

Chris Su, a baseball card dealer, reviews and reacts to 13 points about buying card collections from deceased owners' families. He agrees with most observations but provides nuanced pushback on several, emphasizing that condition, era, and proper documentation are critical factors in collection valuation.

Summary

Chris Su walks through a 13-point article by Owen Maxwell about acquiring baseball card collections from families after the original owner's death. Su agrees that older collectors typically possess significant knowledge but document little, leaving heirs in the dark about value. He disputes the claim that finding one pre-war card typically rewrites appraisals, noting most collectors don't organize this way but rather progress gradually up the value ladder. Su refines the point about 1990s cards being worthless, clarifying that 1980s and early-1990s cards are nearly always dead ends unless specifically targeted, while late-1990s collections may contain valuable inserts and parallels. He confirms sentimental cards rarely have resale value and recommends families keep these for memory value rather than selling them. Su emphasizes that families either significantly undervalue or overvalue collections, often by extreme margins, sometimes off by 10-20x the actual value. He strongly disagrees that worthless commons bins typically contain hidden treasure, calling this extremely uncommon since most collectors understand card values reasonably well. On grading ungraded cards, Su notes this requires expertise, capital, patience, and risk tolerance that inherited-collection families typically lack. He discusses how dealers separate collections into value-based piles and explains the importance of this process. Su pushes back against the rubber bands and tape being red flags, arguing they instead indicate an uneducated collector more likely to have hidden treasures mixed with commons due to poor organization. He acknowledges storage damage from humidity and cigarette smoke occasionally occurs but isn't prevalent. Su stresses that condition dramatically impacts value, particularly with vintage cards, and that newcomers consistently overestimate condition. Finally, he explains that card era is crucial context for setting expectations, with pre-war and vintage being highly valuable, 1980s-early-1990s being worthless, and modern-era collections being unpredictable.

Key Insights

  • Su recommends that collectors document their valuable cards minimally (identifying top 10 cards or best box) to guide heirs, as this simple step dramatically improves the likelihood that inheritors will recognize value and invest research time
  • Su disagrees with the article's claim that finding one pre-war card typically rewrites collection appraisals, arguing that most collectors progress gradually up the value ladder rather than having one exceptional card surrounded by worthless commons
  • Su argues that rubber bands and tape on older collections are actually positive indicators because they suggest an uneducated collector who didn't know proper storage, making hidden treasures more likely to be mixed in with commons
  • Su states that grading cards for upside requires significant expertise, capital investment, patience due to company backlogs, and risk tolerance that most families inheriting collections lack and shouldn't attempt without professional help
  • Su emphasizes that card era is a crucial initial data point—pre-war and 1950s-60s-70s are very valuable, 1980s-early-1990s have virtually no value, and modern/ultramodern are unpredictable, requiring additional research to set expectations

Topics

Collection valuation and appraisal methodsDocumentation and record-keeping for collectorsCondition assessment and gradingEra and vintage card significanceFamily inheritance and collection dispositionHidden treasures and rare card discoveryStorage and preservation issues

Transcript

[0:00] Chris Su here, baseball card collector, investor, dealer in that order. Welcome everyone. Uh, recently a viewer of the channel named Carl sent me a really interesting article that had been written online about what it looks like when sports card dealers buy a private collection from somebody who had passed away. So, like they're buying it from their family or something that had who had inherited it. And this is right up my alley. I buy private collections all the time. And I've bought, you know, many, many, many dozens of collections in this in this vein where the original owners passed away, somebody's inherited it, and now they're selling it to a dealer such as me in…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.