OpinionDiscussion

Why I'm STILL Grading My Cards With PSA

The speaker explains why they continue using PSA for card grading despite acknowledging its excessive market power and influence. They argue that alternative grading companies like TAG haven't yet proven themselves worthy of replacing the established providers, using an analogy to backup quarterbacks who underperform when given their chance.

Summary

The speaker addresses criticism about PSA's dominance in the card grading market, acknowledging the valid sentiment that PSA has become too powerful and that people rely on it despite having concerns about the company. However, they clarify an important point about industry consolidation: PSA, SGC, and Beckett are all owned by the same parent company, so choosing SGC as an alternative to PSA doesn't actually reduce corporate concentration in the grading market.

Regarding alternative grading companies like TAG, the speaker rejects the notion that they should actively promote or support these newer entrants. They argue this isn't their responsibility and that they've tried TAG a couple of times with adequate results, but the company hasn't demonstrated readiness to compete at the highest level. The speaker employs a sports analogy based on their experience as a 40-year Washington Commanders fan: just as backup quarterbacks often fail to perform better when finally given their starting opportunity, alternative grading companies haven't earned the right to be treated as equals to established providers. The speaker will only switch to alternative graders once those companies prove they've earned their position through demonstrated excellence and reliability.

Key Insights

  • PSA, SGC, and Beckett are all owned by the same parent company, so switching from PSA to SGC doesn't actually reduce the market power of a single corporate entity
  • The speaker has used TAG a couple of times with acceptable results but doesn't believe the company has demonstrated it's ready to compete at the professional level
  • The speaker applies a sports analogy from 40 years of being a Commanders fan to explain why they won't prematurely back alternative grading companies
  • The speaker argues it's not their responsibility to prop up competing grading companies; those companies must earn their position through proven excellence
  • Alternative grading companies have not yet demonstrated they've earned the starting position in the market despite having opportunities to prove themselves

Topics

PSA market dominance and criticismsCard grading industry consolidationAlternative grading companies (TAG, Beckett, SGC)Company ownership structuresStandards for switching service providers

Transcript

[0:00] But I understand the sentiment that like PSA is way too powerful and too big and we we talk about them too much and we all still use them even though we all have problems with them. Yeah, I I get that and I agree with it. SGC is owned by the exact same company as PSA. So if you feel that PSA is super big and corrupt, SGC is just a, you know, part of that as well. So is Becket. Those three companies are all owned by the same company. In terms of tag, I think you kind of have it backwards. Like it's not my job to prop up tag. You know, I've used them a…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.