OpinionDiscussion

The WORST Sports Card Purchases of ALL Time

A video discussing catastrophic sports card investments, focusing on two notable examples: a 2018 Trey Young rookie card that sold for $444,000 despite Young not being a generational talent, and a 2020 Jason Dominguez prospect card that sold for $474,000 but has significantly depreciated as Dominguez remains unproven.

Summary

The video examines historically poor sports card purchases, starting with the 2018 Panini Prism Black Prism Trey Young rookie card graded BGS Mint 9. Despite Young's respectable career as a three-time NBA All-Star, the card sold for close to half a million dollars ($444,000) on PWC in 2021, driven by excessive hype during Young's rookie prospect phase when he was being marketed as a generational talent despite not meeting that standard.

The second major example is the 2020 Bowman Chrome Super Fractor Auto Jason Dominguez card, a PSA gem mint 10, which sold for $474,000 in early 2022. The speaker notes this card's value has plummeted dramatically in the subsequent two and a half years. While acknowledging that Dominguez is only 21 years old and could potentially become a generational talent in the future, the speaker emphasizes that the odds are heavily against this outcome, making the original investment a cautionary tale of speculating on unproven prospects.

Key Insights

  • Trey Young, despite being a three-time All-Star, is not a generational talent, yet his rookie card sold for $444,000 based on prospect hype at the beginning of his career
  • Jason Dominguez's 2020 Bowman Chrome Super Fractor Auto sold for $474,000 in early 2022, but has depreciated to a small fraction of that value over 2.5 years
  • Prospect cards are heavily driven by speculation about future potential rather than actual proven performance, making them inherently risky investments
  • The speaker acknowledges Dominguez is only 21 and could become a generational talent, but emphasizes the odds are heavily against this outcome
  • Card values during the prospect hype phase can be completely disconnected from realistic future earning potential or player trajectory

Topics

Sports card market volatilityProspect hype and overvaluationInvestment failures in collectiblesCard grading and rarityRisk in speculative card purchases

Transcript

[0:00] Today wanted to go over what I consider to be some of the worst sports card purchases of all time. 2018 Panini Prism Black Prism Trey Young rookie. It's great a BGS Mint 9. This card's one of one. Trey Young is a, you know, a very solid player in the league. Three-time all-star, but he's not a generational talent, and that's what his card prices were selling as back when he was an overhyped prospect at the very beginning of his career. This card sold for $444,000. Close to a half million on PWC back in 2021. Jason Dominguez here. This is 2020 [0:33] Bowman Chrome Super Fractor Auto. It's a 101 PSA gem antenna with a entry…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.