OpinionDiscussion

A Recent PSA Order With Predictions and Financials

A baseball card dealer reviews a 30-card vintage PSA grading order submitted in April at $25/card, comparing his predicted grades to actual results and analyzing the financial impact. He finds that half the cards graded lower than expected, yet the order still yielded a net positive value of $1,255, though this would be unprofitable at current $60/card grading fees.

Summary

Chris Will, a baseball card collector, investor, and dealer, presents a detailed analysis of a 30-card vintage baseball card grading order submitted to PSA in April before a price increase. He had predicted grades for each card in advance, creating a spreadsheet to test his hypothesis that PSA has become stricter with grading standards.

The order contained primarily 1950s and 1960s cards, including notable players like Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Roberto Clemente, and others. Card-by-card analysis reveals that Chris's predictions were frequently higher than actual grades received. Notable discrepancies include: a 1956 Topps Hank Aaron predicted as a 3 but graded as a 2 (which Chris considered harsh), and several high-end 1968 Topps cards (Mickey Mantle, Johnny Bench, and Hank Aaron) that he predicted at 5-6 but received grades of 2-3, which Chris found particularly puzzling and plans to verify in hand.

Chris notes recurring issues with PSA's use of qualifiers, particularly questioning why two cards (1959 Topps Sandy Koufax and Willie Mays) received 'MC' (miscut) designations when they clearly showed borders in all directions and should have been 'OC' (off-centered) instead.

Financially, Chris performed value-add calculations for all 30 cards, comparing raw sale prices to graded sale prices minus grading fees (calculated at approximately $28 per card including shipping and insurance). The analysis shows eight cards resulted in negative value, but most were only slightly negative. The three highest value-adds were the 1959 Topps Hank Aaron PSA 5, the 1959 Topps Clemente PSA 6, and the 1963 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 3. The total net value added across all 30 cards was $1,255.

Chris emphasizes that this positive result was only possible at the $25 grading fee level. He calculates that if this same order had been submitted at current PSA rates of $60 per card (or $63 with shipping), the $1,255 profit would drop to approximately break-even, making the investment not worthwhile given the six-month turnaround time. He expresses surprise that PSA continues to receive high submission volumes despite these economics, noting that many card categories—particularly vintage 1950s-60s key cards in low-to-mid grades—no longer make financial sense to submit at $60 per card. He concludes by noting he has had to significantly adjust his business model due to PSA's price increases and expresses hope for more reasonable grading fees in the future.

Key Insights

  • Chris's predictions were lower than actual grades in zero cases, with exactly half of the 30 cards grading lower than predicted and the other half meeting predictions, suggesting PSA grading has become stricter than his historical expectations
  • Three consecutive high-end 1968 Topps cards (Mantle PSA 3, Bench PSA 3, Aaron PSA 2) that Chris predicted at grades 5-6 came back significantly lower, which he found particularly puzzling and plans to verify in hand before drawing conclusions
  • The 30-card order generated $1,255 in net value at $25 per card grading fees, but would drop to approximately break-even if submitted at current $60 per card rates, making the investment not worthwhile given the six-month turnaround time
  • PSA applied 'MC' (miscut) qualifiers to cards like the 1959 Topps Koufax and Willie Mays that clearly displayed borders in all directions and should have received 'OC' (off-centered) designations instead
  • Despite PSA's $60 minimum grading fees making many vintage 1950s-60s key cards in low-to-mid grades financially unviable to submit, PSA continues receiving high submission volumes, which Chris finds surprising

Topics

PSA grading accuracy and strictness comparisonVintage baseball card grading predictions vs. actual resultsFinancial analysis of card grading ROIImpact of PSA price increases on dealer economicsGrading qualifier discrepancies (MC vs. OC designations)1950s-1960s baseball cards market value

Transcript

[0:00] Chris will here baseball card collector investor dealer in that order. Welcome everyone. I want to take a look at a PSA order I recently got back. Well, I actually haven't gotten it back in hand yet, but it's live on the website so you can see the grades. And this is a 30 card vintage order that I sent in back in I want to say April uh before the PSA price hike. So it was back when it was $25 per card. And I actually predicted back then what the grades would be of each card in anticipation of making a video about it. And this is the kind of thing I used to make videos on…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.