StoryOpinion

A Large Collection Out of Chicago I Bought From a Viewer of the Channel

Chris S, a baseball card collector and dealer, traveled to Chicago to purchase a large collection from a viewer named Scott. He paid $22,000 for the bulk collection and took 13 valuable Michael Jordan cards on consignment for grading, projecting over $6,000 profit after accounting for travel costs and seller fees.

Summary

Chris S opens the video by explaining his process for evaluating whether to travel for large card collection purchases, requiring both sufficient value and a reasonable seller. After email communication with Scott in the Chicago area, he decided the deal met both criteria. Chris flew to Chicago and rented a car to transport the collection back to Baltimore, a 12-hour drive.

The collection spanned from the 1960s to present day and included several highlights: a 1969 Topps baseball complete set featuring a Nolan Ryan rookie, a 1986 Fleer basketball complete set with two Michael Jordan cards, and numerous complete sets from the 1970s and early 1980s, including six or seven 1984 Donruss baseball sets. The collection also contained bulk material from the late 1980s and early 1990s, as well as ultramodern cards, with a heavy focus on Chicago players.

The most valuable items were Michael Jordan cards: a 1986 Fleer #57, a 1984 Star #101, and a 10-card set of 1986 Star Michael Jordans. Since none of the cards were graded, Chris and Scott agreed that the 13 Jordan cards requiring grading would be taken on consignment rather than purchased outright, as grading results could drastically affect value. Chris offered $20,000 initially, Scott countered at $25,000, and they settled at $22,000 for the main collection.

Chris documented parts of his trip via video, showing his packing strategy (putting clothes in empty two-row boxes to fit in his carry-on), his early morning drive to the airport, the car rental process, and the collection packed in the vehicle. After packing took longer than expected, he left Chicago around 6:00 PM, drove several hours, stopped for dinner, then continued driving before getting a hotel.

For financial projections, Chris estimates $35,000 in sales after piecing out the collection, applies a standard 15% seller fee for platform fees and supplies, resulting in approximately $30,000 in gross revenue. With $22,000 paid to Scott plus $1,400 in travel costs (flight, rental car, hotel, gas, tolls), he projects over $6,000 profit. The consignment deal on the Jordans could generate additional profit depending on their grades and sale prices.

Chris explains the consignment decision was necessary because the ungraded Jordans had enormous value ranges. For example, the 1986 Fleer could be a PSA 8 worth $16,000 or a PSA 1 worth $4,000 or even less if deemed altered. The 1984 Star had even more extreme variance—a PSA 5 at approximately $48,000 versus a PSA 6 at around $90,000. Such unpredictability made any fixed offer unfair to one party.

As of recording, all 13 cards have been sent for grading. The 1986 Fleer #57 graded PSA 7.5 (exceeding his prediction of 6-7), worth approximately $14,000-$15,000. The sticker version graded PSA 9 with a stain qualifier, also exceeding expectations and worth approximately $6,000. Both Fleer Jordans will be sold through the CIA auction in December run by Jeremy (the Texas Snowman), in which Chris is a small owner. He plans a follow-up video once the Star cards return from grading.

Key Insights

  • Chris uses a two-factor evaluation system for determining whether to travel for collection purchases: sufficient value in the collection and a reasonable seller willing to deal, both of which must be satisfied to justify the trip.
  • None of Scott's collection was graded, which meant the most valuable cards (particularly the Michael Jordans) required grading to be sold, creating extreme uncertainty in fair market value.
  • The 1984 Star Michael Jordan #101 had such a wide value range between PSA grades (PSA 5 at $48,000 versus PSA 6 at $90,000) that no fixed purchase price would be fair to either buyer or seller, making consignment the only viable option.
  • Chris applies a standard 15% seller fee across all deals to account for platform fees, supply costs, and show setup costs, using this as a blanket overhead calculation when projecting profits.
  • The 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 graded higher than predicted (PSA 7.5 instead of the anticipated PSA 6-7), worth approximately $14,000-$15,000, indicating the consignment approach delivered better-than-expected results.

Topics

Collection acquisition and travel logisticsCard valuation and condition assessmentGrading risk and uncertainty in card collectingConsignment versus outright purchase decisionsProfit calculation and business metricsMichael Jordan cards market valueVintage and modern card collecting

Transcript

[0:00] Chris S here, baseball card collector, investor, dealer in that order. Welcome everyone. A story time today from the files of adventures in card dealing. And I'm actually dealing with a little bit of a a sore throat, which you may hear, but I actually think it kind of makes me sound manly and grizzled. So, if any of my, you know, seven female followers wouldn't mind leaving in the comments if you agree with that. I would appreciate it. But yeah, the purchase I recently made was off a viewer of the channel. His name was Scott out in the Chicago area. And I flew out to Chicago and purchased his collection or the majority of his collection.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.