The Card Shop Social Media Mistake We Fixed
Cards HQ, a card shop in Atlanta, initially focused their social media on local Atlanta events, but realized their national following had little interest in location-specific content. They strategically shifted to posting universally appealing content that would engage their entire audience, not just local customers.
Summary
When Cards HQ first opened their card shop in Atlanta, their social media strategy centered on promoting local, in-store events like trade nights and TCG games happening at the physical Atlanta location. However, despite building a national following across their social media platforms, they discovered that posts about Atlanta-specific events generated minimal engagement. The team recognized a critical mismatch: their audience was geographically distributed across the country (including people in Seattle and elsewhere), yet the content was tailored only to the small portion of their following in Atlanta. This realization prompted a strategic pivot in their social media approach. Rather than continuing to focus on location-based events and announcements, Cards HQ decided to shift toward content that would be interesting and engaging to their entire national audience, regardless of geography. This meant creating posts that had universal appeal and would resonate with followers regardless of their location or connection to the physical store.
Key Insights
- Cards HQ built a national social media following despite being a physical retail store located only in Atlanta
- Location-specific posts about Atlanta events (trade nights, TCG games) generated very little engagement despite a large national following
- The majority of Cards HQ's social media audience is not based in Atlanta and therefore does not care about Atlanta-specific events
- Cards HQ strategically shifted to posting universally interesting content rather than Atlanta-focused content to better serve their national audience
- The fundamental issue was a mismatch between content strategy (local) and audience composition (national)
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Our social media when we originally opened this store was focused a lot on what's happening in the Atlanta store. We had built up a following that was a national following. When we posted about a trade night happening on Friday night or when we posted about a TCG game or whatever, we only got a very little bit of engagement. Even though we're in Atlanta physically, the Atlanta people is only a portion of our audience. We got >> Why does someone in Seattle care about your trade Atlanta? >> People in Seattle care. They don't care. So, we actually had to strategically shift our social media to say, you know what, even though Cards HQ is a…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Geoff Wilson Show
Is Card Grading Daying? Not A Chance!
The speaker argues that PSA has significant leverage to maintain its market position through pricing flexibility, noting that the company has substantial profit margins and can reduce grading prices if needed to manage backlogs and attract volume. Historical grading prices at $7-10 per card demonstrate PSA's pricing power and room for adjustment.
One Weekend of Cards Beat a Full Year of Ice Cream
A business owner compares the retail performance of his Metro Detroit Cards trading card store to his previous Ben & Jerry's ice cream franchise experience, revealing that one weekend of card sales exceeded his best-performing ice cream store's annual revenue. He strongly advises against opening ice cream stores based on this stark business comparison.
7 Surprising Things I Learned About Collectors This Weekend
Jeff Wilson shares seven surprising observations from the opening weekend of Cards HQ's new Detroit-area store, which exceeded expectations by breaking the Atlanta location's single-day sales record by 35% despite opening during the slowest season for card sales. Key learnings include the critical importance of value bins, team quality, localization, and providing liquidity through buying counters.
Jalen Rose Names His All-Time NBA Top 5
Jalen Rose presents his all-time NBA top 5 rankings, with Jordan at #1, Kareem at #2, Russell at #3, Magic at #4, and LeBron and Kobe tied for #5. The ranking criteria emphasizes accomplishments that exceeded expectations relative to contemporaries.
Is Now The Worst Time to Open a Card Shop??
Cards HQ opened a new card shop location in Detroit during November, acknowledged as potentially the worst time of year for such a launch. The shop uses a market-value pricing philosophy based on latest comparable sales, which creates challenges when card prices are declining during the November opening period.