Is Card Grading Daying? Not A Chance!
The speaker argues that PSA has significant leverage to maintain its market position through pricing flexibility, noting that the company has substantial profit margins and can reduce grading prices if needed to manage backlogs and attract volume. Historical grading prices at $7-10 per card demonstrate PSA's pricing power and room for adjustment.
Summary
The speaker discusses PSA's competitive position in the card grading market and argues that PSA should not be viewed as vulnerable despite current market pressures. The key argument centers on PSA's strategic flexibility through pricing. The speaker posits that if PSA's backlog were to decrease significantly (to 2 million cards or even down to 1 million), the company would have an effective tool to stimulate demand and market participation: reducing prices. This price reduction lever is presented as particularly powerful because the speaker believes PSA maintains healthy profit margins that would allow substantial price cuts while remaining profitable. To support this argument, the speaker references historical pricing data, noting that PSA offered grading services at much lower price points in the recent past—specifically mentioning $10 per card as a standard rate and noting that special promotions brought prices as low as $7 per card. This historical context establishes that current pricing is elevated compared to previous years, implying room for downward adjustment without approaching unprofitable levels.
Key Insights
- PSA possesses an ultimate strategic lever through price reduction that would allow them to manage backlogs and stimulate demand if cards coming in the door exceed available graders
- PSA historically offered grading services at $10 per card, indicating the company has significant room to reduce current prices while maintaining profitability
- PSA ran promotional specials at $7 per card in the recent past, demonstrating pricing flexibility and profit margin capacity
- The speaker believes PSA has ample profit margin from a financial perspective to support price reductions as a market management tool
- A potential scenario exists where PSA's backlog could decrease to 2 million or even 1 million cards, triggering the need for demand stimulation through pricing
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] I would not be worried if I was PSA, because they have the ultimate lever. And all of the sudden, if they say, "Oh my gosh, the backlog's down to 2 million cards,[] is down to a million cards, like we're going to have more graders than we have cards coming in the door soon here," then all they have to do is bring the price down. And I've got to think they've got plenty of room from a profit margin perspective in being able to bring the price down because it wasn't very many years ago that you could get PSA grading at like $10 a card. >> Some specials are $7 a card.
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Geoff Wilson Show
One Weekend of Cards Beat a Full Year of Ice Cream
A business owner compares the retail performance of his Metro Detroit Cards trading card store to his previous Ben & Jerry's ice cream franchise experience, revealing that one weekend of card sales exceeded his best-performing ice cream store's annual revenue. He strongly advises against opening ice cream stores based on this stark business comparison.
7 Surprising Things I Learned About Collectors This Weekend
Jeff Wilson shares seven surprising observations from the opening weekend of Cards HQ's new Detroit-area store, which exceeded expectations by breaking the Atlanta location's single-day sales record by 35% despite opening during the slowest season for card sales. Key learnings include the critical importance of value bins, team quality, localization, and providing liquidity through buying counters.
Jalen Rose Names His All-Time NBA Top 5
Jalen Rose presents his all-time NBA top 5 rankings, with Jordan at #1, Kareem at #2, Russell at #3, Magic at #4, and LeBron and Kobe tied for #5. The ranking criteria emphasizes accomplishments that exceeded expectations relative to contemporaries.
Is Now The Worst Time to Open a Card Shop??
Cards HQ opened a new card shop location in Detroit during November, acknowledged as potentially the worst time of year for such a launch. The shop uses a market-value pricing philosophy based on latest comparable sales, which creates challenges when card prices are declining during the November opening period.
We're Opening a HUGE Card Shop at the WORST Possible Time?
Cards HQ is opening a massive new location in Detroit this weekend amid challenging market conditions where card prices are declining in Q4. The team discusses the market timing risks of opening in November, construction challenges including a pallet of glass doors shattering, and hiring complexities, while emphasizing their pricing philosophy and long-term customer experience strategy.