Team Modi Has A Meltdown In Norway Over Single Question To PM | Freedom Of Press? | Akash Banerjee
Akash Banerjee critiques PM Modi's Norway visit, where a Norwegian journalist asked Modi why he wouldn't take questions from a free press, triggering a PR meltdown. The Indian MEA's 13-minute defensive monologue at a subsequent press briefing backfired badly, drawing international ridicule. Banerjee argues this incident exposed India's deteriorating press freedom and democratic hypocrisy on the world stage.
Summary
The video begins by noting that an Indian PM visited Norway for the first time in 43 years. Modi received Norway's highest civilian honor, the Grand Cross of the Royal Norwegian Order of Merit, and was celebrated by the Indian diaspora. However, the smooth PR visit was disrupted when Norwegian journalist Heli asked Modi point-blank why he wouldn't take questions from 'the freest press in the world,' and even followed him to the elevator attempting to get a response.
Banerjee contextualizes this within a pattern — in Sweden, Modi had used a large teleprompter that blocked his face from cameras, and had refused questions after joint communications there too. This created a building tension with Nordic journalists who operate under different standards of press freedom than India's. Banerjee argues that Modi could have turned the situation into a diplomatic win by granting Heli a 10-minute interview, but instead the IT cell mobilized and began doxxing her, spreading her phone number, and calling her a George Soros spy — with figures like Mohandas Pai amplifying these claims, forcing Heli to publicly clarify she was simply a journalist.
The MEA then compounded the problem by inviting Norwegian journalists to a hotel briefing, apparently expecting them to behave like compliant Indian press. Senior diplomat Siby George delivered a 13-minute near-uninterrupted monologue covering yoga, chess, India's 5000-year democratic history, and reading out the Indian Constitution's Preamble verbatim — while repeatedly refusing to address the actual questions about trust, human rights track record, and whether Modi would speak to critical Indian press. When journalists interrupted to ask him to address the actual questions, George became visibly agitated, accused them of reading NGO-funded reports, and implied they had no understanding of India's scale.
Banerjee draws a contrast with old Arnab Goswami footage aggressively questioning PM Manmohan Singh — arguing that such adversarial journalism was once celebrated in India but is now unthinkable with Modi. He also references the Sabrina Siddiqui incident (Wall Street Journal) where a journalist was similarly trolled for asking about minority rights. Banerjee connects the Norway visit to Rahul Gandhi's claim that it may have been linked to India's Adani connections with Norway's sovereign wealth fund, which had divested from Adani.
The video concludes with a broader argument: India ranks 157th in press freedom — below Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Nepal, and Bangladesh — and the government is systematically buying up media houses, shutting down independent outlets, and pursuing a Digital Broadcast Bill to control the last free digital space. Banerjee argues the Norway meltdown proved that this carefully manufactured propaganda architecture can be shattered by a single question, and that the disproportionate reaction reveals where the real problem lies.
Key Insights
- Banerjee argues that Modi could have scored a major diplomatic win by simply granting the Norwegian journalist a 10-minute interview after the elevator incident, which would have silenced critics about his inability to handle unscripted questions — but instead the IT cell was unleashed to dox and discredit her.
- Senior MEA diplomat Siby George's 13-minute monologue at the Norwegian press briefing — which covered yoga, chess, India's 5000-year history, and a verbatim recitation of the Indian Constitution's Preamble — is cited by Banerjee as a masterclass in what not to do diplomatically when facing press freedom scrutiny in a country ranked #1 for press freedom.
- Banerjee points out that Siby George, despite representing a government accused of undermining minority rights, told Norwegian journalists that India 'did not go for ethnic cleansing' and 'embraces diversity' — statements Banerjee notes would likely not be endorsed by the BJP's own IT cell.
- Banerjee uses old Arnab Goswami footage aggressively interrupting and questioning PM Manmohan Singh to argue that adversarial journalism toward the sitting PM was once considered normal and praiseworthy in India, but is now completely unimaginable under Modi's government.
- Banerjee cites a graph showing India and Kenya as the only two countries with an 'inverted freedom gap' — where more people believe press freedom exists than consider it important — arguing this perceptual distortion is what enables the government's propaganda architecture to keep functioning domestically even as it collapses internationally.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access