The violence we don’t see | Dr. Kaitlin Devaney | TEDxU Chicago Illinois
Dr. Kaitlin Devaney expands the definition of violence beyond direct physical harm to include structural violence (built into systems that disadvantage certain groups) and cultural violence (narratives that normalize inequality). She argues these three forms of violence operate together, and addressing harm requires examining systems and questioning deficit-based narratives rather than only punishing visible criminal acts.
Summary
Dr. Devaney challenges the common understanding of violence as individual criminal acts visible to police and courts. She presents Galtung's typology of violence, which consists of three interconnected forms that operate in a triangle: direct violence (visible, event-based harm like crime), structural violence (harm built into systems through policies and institutions that advantage some at the expense of others), and cultural violence (the stories and assumptions we use to justify inequality). Using the example of two children with different access to housing, food, and safe spaces, she demonstrates how structural violence creates measurable differences in life expectancy and health outcomes without requiring a single perpetrator. She explains that cultural violence operates through narratives—such as stereotypes about dangerous neighborhoods or claims that poverty results from individual laziness—that make inequality seem normal and acceptable. Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu's concept of conservation of violence, she illustrates how structural violence in communities (disinvestment, lack of resources) manifests as direct violence (homicide, crime). Maps of Chicago show that neighborhoods with highest homicide rates overlap with those experiencing poverty and food insecurity. Rather than asking "who is to blame," Bourdieu's lens prompts asking "how is harm produced?" She concludes with an action framework: learn to see systems beyond individual behavior, interrogate narratives by questioning who benefits and who tells the story, and make decisions with awareness of who gains access and who is excluded.
Key Insights
- The standard definition of violence as physical harm caused by individuals with intent is incomplete and reactive; criminal justice and healthcare systems respond after harm has already occurred rather than preventing it
- Structural violence causes measurable real harm—such as reduced life expectancy—without a single perpetrator by building inequality into systems through policies affecting housing, food access, and education
- Cultural violence consists of narratives and assumptions like 'poverty results from laziness' or 'certain neighborhoods are inherently dangerous' that make inequality feel normal and acceptable rather than problematic
- According to Pierre Bourdieu's conservation of violence, structural violence exerted through job loss and disinvestment in marginalized communities manifests as direct violence in the form of crime and interpersonal harm
- The most powerful step toward change is a change in perception—learning to identify forms of violence operating invisibly in systems—rather than only taking action against visible criminal behavior
Topics
Transcript
[0:03] violence, a scene like this pops up. This is actually the number one image that pops up when you Google violence. It's a picture of a scene we see police tape, we see an action, we see people responding to a crime. But what if I told you that this understanding is not all of the ways that we should understand violence? Today we're going to spend some time complicating this. And this understanding isn't just cultural, it's institutional. So this definition from the National [0:35] Research Council defines violence as behaviors by individuals that intentionally threaten, attempt, or inflict physical harm on others. So there are three important elements of this definition. We have individuals as the perpetrators.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from TEDx Talks
Literature, Meaning, and the Modern World | Raaz Ahtesham | TEDxFASTIslamabad
Raaz Ahtesham, a poet and software engineer, discusses meta-writing in post-modern literature and its relevance to contemporary society. He explores how literature reflects deeper truths through self-referential techniques and argues that Eastern societies must understand their own foundational issues rather than merely copying Western philosophical approaches.
Community in modern Malta | Sasha Vella | TEDxUniversityofMalta
Sasha Vella contrasts the strong community bonds she experienced in rural Gozo with the individualism-driven disconnection prevalent in modern Malta, arguing that while individualism has brought freedom and innovation, unchecked pursuit of personal success without community consciousness leads to isolation, loss of empathy, and societies that merely function rather than truly thrive.
The Price of War | Filip Dikmen | TEDxMalmö
Filip Dikmen examines the patriarchy as a system that demands violence and sacrifice from men rather than only oppressing women. He traces three historical grooming techniques—separation from the feminine, public humiliation, and sexual rewards—and explores how these patterns persist today, creating cycles of trauma that damage families and societies while serving the interests of those in power.
Community Filmmaking Leads to Empowerment | Zan Azlee | TEDxUTM
Zan Azlee, a journalist and documentary filmmaker, transitioned from parachute journalism covering war zones to community filmmaking with the Bajau people in Sabah. By teaching indigenous youth video production skills and empowering them to tell their own stories, he demonstrated how storytelling can create economic opportunities and social empowerment for marginalized communities.
Think Big | Arumugam Sakthivel | TEDxKids Club CBSE School
Arumugam Sakthivel shares his entrepreneurial journey from starting with 50,000 rupees to building a 1,500+ crore business group, emphasizing the importance of 'thinking big.' He discusses overcoming an 85-lakh debt crisis, expanding into exports, and leveraging his success to drive infrastructure and social development in Tiruppur through the Tiruppur Exporters Association.