InsightfulOpinion

Empathy machines and why we need storytelling | David Mann | TEDxJohannesburg Salon

TEDx Talks

David Mann explores why storytelling is essential for maintaining humanity and empathy in an increasingly divisive world. He argues that stories function as 'empathy machines' that allow us to step into others' lives, make sense of complex realities, and connect meaningfully with one another through collective meaning-making.

Summary

David Mann opens by establishing the critical importance of storytelling in countering isolation and insularity in a world saturated with bad news and governed by pervasive power structures. He introduces the concept of stories as 'empathy machines'—tools that exercise our capacity for empathy by inviting us to temporarily inhabit others' lives with curiosity and kindness.

Mann traces his own awakening to the power of storytelling through a personal narrative. Growing up in a small Eastern Cape university town, he studied English literature, journalism, anthropology, and philosophy, but found these disciplines remained abstract until he attended a theater performance. This pivotal moment—sitting in worn red seats as the curtain rose—catalyzed his realization that storytelling is how he makes sense of the world and his place in it. This epiphany led him to become a journalist, art critic, and author.

He introduces Seamus Heaney's poem 'Digging' as a guiding philosophy, using the image of a pen as a digging tool to illustrate the choice between didactic storytelling and curious, questioning art that excavates deeper truths. He demonstrates this concept through examples of South African artists—Ivan Vladislavic, William Kentridge, and Smith and Tylle—all of whom use their work to excavate personal and historical truths.

Mann describes a crisis point in his career around 2021 when he became disillusioned with how the art world had become corrupted by commercial markets, forcing his writing and language into service of marketing rather than meaning-making. Rather than leaving the industry, he pursued a Master's in creative writing and began writing fiction, which provided a 'playful, exciting space' to explore narratives and questions that journalism couldn't accommodate. This led to his debut collection 'Once Removed,' a series of 13 interconnected stories about art world figures and ordinary people whose lives have been changed through engagement with art.

Mann concludes by emphasizing that storytelling is fundamentally collaborative and collective. He distinguishes between two epiphanies: the initial moment of entering a story, and the equally important moment outside the theater where community members discuss and make meaning together. He cites Zadie Smith's observation that 'the world does not deliver meaning to you, you have to make it meaningful,' arguing this is not a solitary act but an everyday, collective human endeavor. As long as we tell stories together, we remain in touch with our fundamental humanity.

Key Insights

  • Mann argues that engaging in stories and embracing storytelling keeps people curious and kind, functioning as a 'balm' against the desire to retreat into insularity and away from one another in times of difficulty.
  • Mann had an epiphanic realization in a theater that storytelling through performance is how he connects abstract learning from lectures and readings to meaningful understanding of the world around him.
  • Mann experienced a crisis where he realized his writing as an art critic was being corrupted by commercial market forces to sell and market art rather than to collectively navigate the world, forcing him to reconsider his entire practice.
  • Mann contends that fiction, unlike journalism, provides a 'playful, exciting space' to explore narratives and frustrations about the art world that have no natural home in criticism, allowing deeper excavation of complex questions.
  • Mann argues that storytelling is fundamentally collaborative and collective, and the second epiphany—discussing what you've experienced with others in community—is now more meaningful to him than the initial moment of entering a story.

Topics

Storytelling as empathy and connectionArt and storytelling as meaning-makingPersonal excavation through narrativeDisillusionment with commercial art worldCollaborative and collective nature of storytellingFiction versus journalismSouth African artists and cultural commentary

Transcript

[0:00] [music] >> Hello everyone. Um I'm David Mann and I tell stories. Um and what a what a huge honor and what a joy to be opening this part of the program today which features such extraordinary storytellers. Um So, why do we need stories? Why do stories matter? And what do we risk if we choose to live in the world without stories? [0:30] Um right now it feels like we're bombarded constantly with nothing but bad news. We live in a world that's increasingly excuse me, governed by fascist and pervasive world powers. Um and it becomes easier often to turn away, to turn away from bad news, um but also to turn away from one another…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from TEDx Talks

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.