NewsResearch

Who’s Buying These? The Craziest Sports Card Sales This Week

Sports Card Radio

This sports card market report covers major sales including an $8.2 million Cooper Flagg rookie card, analyzes World Series player card performance, examines Victor Wanyama's stagnant market value, and reviews recent auction results with concerns about potential market manipulation.

Summary

The episode opens with the biggest basketball card sale ever: a one-of-one Cooper Flagg rookie patch sold for $8.2 million to Price Picks, a fantasy sports gambling app. This purchase, along with Dylan Harper and Cade Cunningham one-of-ones, sparked controversy in the hobby community, with commentators debating whether such premium cards belong in repacks rather than collections. The discussion highlights inconsistency among critics who previously endorsed similar high-value purchases.

Flagg himself suffered a left shoulder sprain and is sidelined for at least a week, which may impact his card values. His PSA 10 base Topps Chrome rookie has averaged around $300 recently.

The show tested $10 instant rips on Fanatics, purchasing 59 packs for $590. After selling 35 cards back for $430 and valuing the remaining 24 at approximately $250, they project breaking nearly even or making close to $100, demonstrating that low-dollar repacks typically aren't profitable.

For World Series players, Jackson Chourio's 2022 Bowman Chrome rookie dropped from $58 to $49, leaving early buyers underwater. Pitcher Edward Lodolo ("The Miz") saw his 2022 Bowman Draft Chrome surge from $70 to $500-700. Junior Camero's 2023 Bowman Chrome prospect climbed from the mid-$20s to $63-95. The only significant Milwaukee hype belongs to Victor Wanyama in his fourth year, whose offensive inconsistencies continue to plague his market. His silver Prism rookie PSA 10 remains flat at around $3,000.

In football, Justin Herbert faces uncertainty with trade rumors and poor team performance after being a preseason MVP candidate. The quarterback market remains wide open with young talents like Drake May and Caleb Williams splitting games.

The auction recap reveals several notable sales: a 2018 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Shohei Ohtani rookie auto sold for $90,000, down from $132,000 in May but up 50% from $60,000 a year ago. A 2025 Topps Chrome update gold LeBron James numbered to 50 sold for $60,000 PSA 10, which the hosts consider insane pricing compared to vintage LeBron cards like his 2003 SP Signature triple auto (LeBron, Jordan, McGrady) at $50,400 or his 2003 SP Authentic rookie auto at $33,000. The hosts express skepticism about Fanatics potentially engaging in shill bidding given that Fanatics both manufactures and auctions the card.

Other notable sales include a 2012 Prism Silver Tom Brady PSA 10 for $43,200 and a 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan rookie PSA 9 for $48,000. A Lionel Messi one-of-one green kaboom sold for $99,000, prompting former Leaf CEO Brian Gray to call it the worst sale since his own $516 Webby sale and offer $110,000 to the buyer.

The news segment reports that 22 hobby shops may have been cut off by Fanatics for selling allocation through DealerNetX without approval. PSA's grading backlog has improved from 12.4 million cards in July to 7.2 million, though cheaper value tiers remain paused with standard grading at $60 per card.

Key Insights

  • Price Picks, a fantasy sports gambling app, purchased three one-of-one cards including Cooper Flagg's $8.2 million rookie patch specifically for use in repacks rather than for collection purposes
  • Darren Rall criticized Price Picks' card purchases as 'not natural,' despite previously endorsing similar million-dollar patch purchases for Dick's Sporting Goods over individual collectors
  • A test of 59 Fanatics $10 instant rip packs netted $430 in immediate resales plus $250 in remaining inventory value, totaling approximately $100 profit or break-even, demonstrating low-dollar repacks rarely generate significant returns
  • Victor Wanyama's fourth-year card market remains flat at $3,000 despite playoff appearance, with Gilbert Arenas criticizing his offensive versatility and inability to develop consistent positioning on the court
  • A 2025 Topps Chrome update gold LeBron James numbered to 50 sold for $60,000 PSA 10, exceeding the price of his 2003 SP Signature triple auto featuring LeBron, Michael Jordan, and Tracy McGrady for $50,400, prompting suspicions about potential Fanatics shill bidding since they both manufacture and auction the card

Topics

Sports card market sales and valuationsCooper Flagg record-breaking $8.2 million salePlayer performance impact on card valuesRepack profitability analysisAuction house sales and potential market concernsWorld Series player card performance trackingQuarterback market uncertaintyPSA grading backlog improvementsHobby shop distribution issues

Transcript

[0:00] $8.2 million [music] for one card. World Series cards. Who actually moved? Victor Wimanyama. Is the offense ever going to catch up? The quarterback market a mess. And the biggest sales from last night's auction. This is the Monday market on [music] sports card radio. Now, one of the biggest stories in the hobby. A oneofone Cooper flag rookie patch sold for 8.2 [music] million, the most ever for a basketball card. the buyer price picks. They call it a [0:31] fantasy sports app. It's basically a gambling app. They also grabbed the Dylan Harper and Coninipple one of ones. All headed for repacks. And the hobby had plenty to say about it. Darren Rall called the sales not…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.