Why the Hobby Questioned the Paul Skenes 1/1 Pull
A documentary-style video examines the controversial discovery of a rare 1/1 Paul Skenes rookie card pulled by an 11-year-old on Christmas 2024, which sparked widespread conspiracy theories questioning whether the pull was authentic or an elaborate marketing scheme by Fanatics/Topps.
Summary
On January 21st, 2025, Topps announced that the most sought-after card of 2024—a Paul Skenes 1/1 rookie patch auto—had been found by an 11-year-old collector from Los Angeles. The card came from Skenes' first major league game jersey, and the Pirates had offered 30-year-long seats behind home plate as a prize. However, within minutes of the announcement, skepticism erupted online, with conspiracy theories suggesting the pull was fake, orchestrated by Fanatics/Topps as a publicity stunt, or completed by a breaker rather than a child.
According to the timeline, the child pulled the card on Christmas morning, the family contacted Fanatics on January 2nd, and the announcement came on January 21st. The family requested anonymity, providing no video or photos of the pull. Instead, Topps released three pages from the child's journal entries, which drew heavy criticism—people questioned the handwriting's authenticity, the sophisticated vocabulary ('infinite rage,' 'prices did not drop'), and the optics of Fanatics publishing a child's diary. Some speculated connections to Topps CEO Mike Mahan, though his own son's handwriting didn't appear to match.
Ken Goldin from Goldin Auctions openly claimed the fix was in, angry that his rival auction house wasn't given a chance to represent the family. He compared it to the 1919 World Series fix. The family ultimately turned down the Pirates' offer and went through Fanatics Collect for the auction, which some viewed as suspicious given Fanatics owns both Topps and Fanatics Collect. The card sold for over $1 million to Dick's Sporting Goods, whose executive chairman Ed Stack positioned it as growing the hobby. However, this sparked further questions about whether Dick's purchase was itself a marketing ploy, especially given their business relationship with Fanatics in apparel retail.
Nearly two years later, despite no evidence contradicting the official story, the conspiracy theories persist. The narrator concludes that what should have been a feel-good story about a young collector became marred by justifiable skepticism and unjustifiable conspiracy thinking, with the hobby unable to settle the matter.
Key Insights
- The speaker notes that once conspiracy thinking takes hold, any outcome becomes suspicious—'if you pull a card anywhere or don't pull it, it's a conspiracy, no matter what'—illustrating how the hobby's skepticism created unfalsifiable theories
- Topps' decision to publish three pages of the child's journal entries backfired, with critics noting the sophisticated vocabulary and handwriting style seemed inconsistent with an 11-year-old, suggesting this was 'the conspiracy buffet' laid out for hobbyists to attack
- Ken Goldin's primary complaint wasn't about whether the child was real, but that Fanatics never gave his rival auction house a chance to represent the family, making him compare the situation to the 1919 World Series fix
- The card's sale to Dick's Sporting Goods rather than the Pittsburgh Pirates or a collector raised questions about whether the purchase was a coordinated marketing attempt, especially given Dick's existing business relationship with Fanatics in apparel
- The speaker argues that Topps likely didn't fabricate the pull but 'embellished some things, and the marketing department worked overtime,' distinguishing between the core story being true and the presentation being overly polished
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] The other thing is, if it gets hit by a breaker, well, of course, it gets hit by one of the breakers. If it gets hit by a a nobody, well, they had to sprinkle that in to throw us off the trail. We could start to get to the point where it's like, if you pull a card anywhere or don't pull it, it's a conspiracy, no matter what. >> On January 21st, 2025, Topps announced that the most chased card of the year had finally been found. And the person who pulled it was 11 years old. >> How excited were you to find out it was an 11-year-old kid? >> Super. Super excited. >> What would…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Radio
From Federal Prison to a $12.9M Card: Who Is Shyne150?
Matt Allen, known as Shyne150, was released from federal prison in 2018 after serving time for MDMA trafficking and marijuana/cocaine-related offenses. Since his release, he has become a prominent figure in high-end sports card collecting, leading a group that has spent approximately $250 million on rare cards including record-breaking purchases.
He Put $10,000 Into Zion Cards. 6 Years Later…
A person invested $10,000 in 14 Zion Williamson trading cards at ~$800 each, expecting the price to exceed $1,500 if Zion made the playoffs. However, the Pelicans missed the playoffs, the card's peak value was $970 during Christmas, and it has since dropped to approximately $20.
The Card Hobby's Biggest Companies Took $15 Million in PPP Loans
Trading card industry companies received over $15 million in PPP loans during the COVID-19 pandemic, with most loans being forgiven despite the hobby experiencing unprecedented boom conditions by the time forgiveness occurred. Several major companies and individuals obtained these loans through questionable means, though none have been charged yet.
We Didn’t Sell the Channel. Here’s Why We’re Making AI Videos
Ryan from Sportscard Radio explains why they're using AI to create content and manage their card buying/selling business, clarifying they didn't sell their YouTube channel. He argues that AI saves time—the most valuable resource—and allows them to scale their singles trading business to six figures while criticizing the gambling-focused approach most collectors take.
The Dallas Card Show Heist: $2 Million in Cards, No Arrests
A $2 million theft of rare baseball cards at the Dallas Card Show remains unsolved over two years later, with no arrests made. The highly coordinated heist was captured on security footage, but subsequent conspiracy theories from an online account suggesting the dealer orchestrated the theft himself have muddied the investigation and divided the collecting community.