StoryNews

The Shill Bidding List That Brought Down Bill Mastro

Sports Card Radio

This transcript documents the federal fraud case against Bill Mastro and his auction house for systematic shill bidding from 2001-2009, where fake bids were placed to artificially inflate prices. A 2016 court document revealed 2,463 fraudulent auction lots, implicating major figures in the sports collectibles hobby including graders, authenticators, and dealers, though only Mastro and three associates were convicted.

Summary

Bill Mastro rose to prominence in the baseball card collecting hobby by the 1970s-80s, becoming a major dealer and consultant for high-value collectibles by the 1990s. In 1995, he started Mastro Fine Sports Auctions in the Chicago area, which by 2000 was selling $32 million in material annually. From 2001 to early 2009, federal prosecutors discovered that Mastro Auctions systematically placed fake bids using accounts registered to employees, friends, family members, and prominent figures in the hobby—including a priest. The shill bidding operated through three mechanisms: bidding up the auction house's own inventory to protect investments, providing hidden reserves for favored consigners, and creating a safety net where fake winning bids could be cancelled without penalty. This gave the auction house an unfair advantage since they knew if their shill bid won, they could simply cancel the sale. The scheme also involved authentication fraud, including reselling items with questioned provenance like Elvis hair and a trophy ball with post-WWII paint. The FBI's Chicago office began investigating in 2007, and after the recession of 2008, Mastro Auctions closed in March 2009. A federal grand jury indicted Mastro, Doug Allen (company president), Mark Theodicos, and IT director Bill Bow in July 2012. In October 2013, Mastro pleaded guilty to mail fraud and admitted to trimming the famous Honus Wagner card—a separate fraud he had denied for 25 years. He received 20 months in prison, Allen received 57 months, Theodicos received one year and a day, and Bow received probation. In January 2016, a 103-page federal court document listing 2,463 shill-bid lots was posted online, revealing that fake bids were tied to major hobby figures: Dave Foreman (SGC owner), Ken Golden, Kevin Keading (PSA DNA authenticator), John Resnikov (PSA DNA consultant), Peter Calderon (Heritage), and Andrew Philippowski (investment firm owner). None of these individuals were ever charged. The transcript notes this was the first and only federal shill bidding case prosecuted. The problem persists in the hobby: eBay banned PWC in 2021 for shill bidding with 71,000 listings pulled, and in 2024-2025, Alt sued PWC for similar conduct while Rick Probstein's new auction site Snipe collapsed after a database leak allegedly showed coordinated shill bidding from accounts tied to Probstein himself.

Key Insights

  • Mastro Auctions placed fake bids using accounts registered to employees, friends, family members, and a priest over an eight-year period, with the indictment covering 2,463 fraudulent auction lots where the auction house could see every bidder's maximum bid ceiling.
  • The shill bidding scheme operated through three distinct methods: protecting the auction house's own inventory by bidding it up, providing hidden reserves for favored consigners while advertising 'no reserve' sales, and cancelling sales where shill bids won to eliminate risk.
  • The 2016 court document listing 2,463 shill-bid items implicated major hobby figures including Dave Foreman (SGC owner), Kevin Keading (PSA DNA authenticator), and John Resnikov (PSA DNA consultant), but none of these individuals were ever charged despite their accounts being used for fake bids.
  • FBI agent Ryan Brusokus stated that the Mastro case was 'the first federal shill bidding case ever done, and it's the only federal shill bidding case ever done' despite the practice continuing in the hobby.
  • Mastro admitted in a 2021 Instagram live interview that 'what I did was probably wrong' regarding shill bidding, 25 years after initially denying trimming the Honus Wagner card and the entire fraud scheme.

Topics

Shill bidding fraud in sports collectibles auctionsBill Mastro's criminal case and convictionHonus Wagner card trimming and authentication fraudImplicated figures in the hobby (graders, authenticators, dealers)Ongoing shill bidding in modern collectibles markets (PWC, Snipe)Federal investigation and prosecution methodology

Transcript

[0:00] On a Thursday morning in January 2016, a post went up on a baseball card forum. It had a link to a [music] court document, 103 pages. It came from a federal fraud case in Chicago. It covered 2463 auction lots where the government said it had found a shill bid. And beside each one, it had written down a name under a column it called shill bidder. The thread had a title. [music] The list of criminals is revealed. By [0:31] that afternoon, collectors were finding names they knew. Dealers, [music] authenticators, people who ran auction houses of their own. Some of them are still [music] the biggest names in the hobby today. To understand how those names…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.