StoryNews

The Rise and Fall of Upper Deck

Sports Card Radio

Upper Deck revolutionized the sports card industry in 1989 with tamperproof hologram technology and authentic autographs, becoming a billion-dollar company. However, under accountant Richard McWilliam's leadership, the company engaged in secret reprints, insider trading schemes, and eventually counterfeited Yu-Gi-Oh cards, leading to its downfall after losing exclusive licenses and facing numerous lawsuits.

Summary

Upper Deck was founded in 1989 by card dealer Bill Hemrich and printing salesman Paul Sumner to create counterfeit-proof baseball cards using hologram technology. The company's first card featured 19-year-old Ken Griffy Jr., and it quickly disrupted the market with high-quality cardstock and authentic autographs inserted into packs. Within two years, Upper Deck outsold industry leader Topps, generating massive profits.

Accountant Richard McWilliam, brought in to raise capital, gradually consolidated power and took over as president by 1991. Despite not even knowing who Reggie Jackson was, McWilliam became the company's dominant figure and friend to baseball celebrities. The company's 1991 sales reached $263 million with approximately 4 billion cards printed.

However, internal documents and plant manager testimony revealed systematic schemes to profit from card scarcity. In 1989, Upper Deck secretly reprinted the error Dale Murphy card worth $125. Most egregiously, in 1991, the company reprinted approximately 960 additional cases of the rare French hockey high series, with cases repacked and restamped with false dates to conceal the reprinting. Board members and executives profited enormously from this insider knowledge, with profits approaching $10 million. A similar scheme occurred with Michael Jordan baseball cards that were reprinted after prices hit $35.

Co-founder Paul Sumner was fired via telegram while on vacation in Tahiti in 1990, receiving no public acknowledgment of his departure. Co-founder Bill Hemrich sued in 1993 over the reprinting schemes but dropped the suit after 15 days for a $300,000 settlement. Lawyer Anthony Pasante, promised 3% ownership, was pushed out and later won a $33 million jury verdict in 1993, though an appeals court threw it out in 1997.

The company settled with relief pitcher Dwayne Bice for $17 million in 1992 after he sued for his promised stake. Ironically, Upper Deck's authenticated memorabilia division, launched with Kings owner Bruce McNall, became tainted when McNall was later convicted of defrauding banks out of $200 million, partly using sports cards as fraudulent loan collateral.

Upper Deck's downfall accelerated in 2008-2010. After counterfeit Yu-Gi-Oh cards were discovered in 2008, Konami terminated Upper Deck as distributor. A federal court ruled Upper Deck liable for counterfeiting approximately 610,000 fake cards printed in China in 2009. The company then lost its exclusive NBA license to Panini in January 2009, MLB license to Topps in August 2009, World of Warcraft license in February 2010, and NFL license in April 2010.

Meanwhile, Upper Deck faced additional legal and financial crises: a $2.4 million settlement with MLB in 2010, a disputed tax shelter scheme costing $80 million in back taxes and interest, and lawsuits from the Players Union for unpaid fees. In 2011, Upper Deck vacated its iconic Carlsbad headquarters after only 20 years. McWilliam faced multiple depositions and lawsuits, including one from his own European sister company. On January 5, 2013, McWilliam was found dead at age 59; an autopsy revealed death by alcohol poisoning.

Under new leadership by Jason Masher, Upper Deck survived by pivoting to hockey cards exclusively, securing an NHL license in 2014. The company remains privately held and zealously protects its athlete endorsement deals through litigation, including an antitrust case against Leaf Trading Cards. Today, Upper Deck is primarily known for hockey cards, particularly Young Guns rookie cards, and continues to guard its exclusive deals with athletes like Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods.

Key Insights

  • Richard McWilliam, an accountant who didn't follow baseball and once asked Reggie Jackson 'who's he?', completely took over Upper Deck by guaranteeing $2.4 million in August 1988, increasing his stake from 11% to 27% and ultimately becoming president in July 1989, displacing the original founders.
  • Upper Deck systematically reprinted rare cards after they increased in value, including reprinting the Dale Murphy error card worth $125 and secretly producing approximately 960 additional cases of the French hockey high series at $10,000 per case, worth nearly $10 million total, then distributing them to board members and executives for profit.
  • The reprinting practices constituted what industry experts called 'insider trading,' since collectors were paying for scarcity while the people deciding how scarce cards were the same ones selling them to insiders first.
  • Upper Deck became liable for counterfeiting approximately 610,000 Yu-Gi-Oh cards printed in China in 2008-2009, ironic given the company was founded specifically to create tamper-proof, uncounterfeiteable cards with a hologram technology.
  • Between December 2008 and April 2010, Upper Deck lost its exclusive licenses for Yu-Gi-Oh, the NBA, MLB, World of Warcraft, and the NFL in rapid succession, causing the company to collapse from a $1.2 billion industry player in 1991 to eventually surviving only through an exclusive NHL hockey card deal.

Topics

Upper Deck's founding and initial success with hologram technologyRichard McWilliam's rise to power and consolidation of controlSecret reprinting schemes and insider tradingFounder and executive departures and lawsuitsCounterfeiting of Yu-Gi-Oh cards and loss of licensesFinancial crises, tax issues, and legal battlesMcWilliam's death and company's transformation under new leadershipPivot to hockey card exclusivity and current business model

Transcript

[0:00] In 1989, a brand new company put a tiny silver hologram on the back of every baseball card it made. The pitch was simple. This card can't be faked. Counterfeit cards were everywhere in the 80s. Fake rookies, reprinted stars, cards that looked real until you held them under a light. Upper Deck promised to end all of that. And collectors believed it. They put a 19-year-old Ken Griffy Jr. on card number one. They put real autographs inside packs. In a single year, they printed around 4 [0:31] billion baseball cards. Within 2 years, the little company from Southern California was selling more sports cards than Topps. It made its owners millionaires, and it made one of them…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.