StoryNews

The Rise and Crash of Topps Project 2020

Sports Card Radio

Topps Project 2020 was a print-on-demand art card collaboration that launched in March 2020, creating a speculative bubble where cards sold for thousands above their $19.99 retail price before crashing within weeks. The project generated between $36-49 million in sales but ultimately demonstrated the dangers of investment-driven collecting driven by bulk flippers and social media hype.

Summary

In March 2020, during pandemic lockdowns and stimulus checks, Topps launched Project 2020, a year-long print-on-demand card series featuring 20 famous baseball cards reimagined by 20 artists. Two new cards dropped every weekday for 48 hours at $19.99 each, with print runs determined by order volume and bulk purchase discounts. Early print runs stayed between 1,000-3,000 cards, with initial reception on collector forums being negative. However, by late April, after Ben Baller's Mike Trout card featuring a $50,000 pendant sold nearly 35,000 copies in the first hour and crashed the Topps website, the project exploded in popularity. Secondary market prices skyrocketed, with early low-print cards reselling for hundreds to thousands of dollars. By mid-May, the Baller Trout reached $2,000-$4,000, equaling prices of original Mike Trout rookie cards in PSA 10. The most sought card, the Herzy Trout with 2,911 print run, became the centerpiece of investment speculation. However, the bubble's foundation was unstable because print-on-demand incentivized flippers and resellers to bulk-order new releases to drive print runs higher, which they would then attempt to resell before the next drop. This cycle accelerated dramatically on May 27th when the Ken Griffy Jr. card by Keith Shore printed 99,177 copies—nearly triple the previous record and representing a quarter of all Project 2020 sales to date. Prices began collapsing immediately as collectors realized the secondary market couldn't sustain such inflated valuations. Within two weeks, cards that sold for $4,000+ were back to retail or below. Investors who bought near the peak lost catastrophic sums; one collector described losing $42,000 from a $50,000 portfolio in 3-4 weeks. Despite the crash occurring only 100 cards into the 400-card set, Topps and the artists still benefited tremendously—artists earned royalties on all cards sold regardless of resale prices, and the project generated $36-49 million in revenue while reportedly helping restore jobs at Topps. The final card dropped December 23rd, 2020. Early buyers who sold before the Griffy crash made substantial profits, but most late-stage investors were decimated. Topps then launched Project 70 in February 2021 despite saying there would be no Project 2021, repeating the cycle.

Key Insights

  • The Baller Trout card sold nearly 35,000 copies in the first hour on April 29th, bringing in a wave of new buyers and causing eBay searches for Project 2020 to jump over 600% from April to May, transforming the project from niche to mainstream.
  • Because the print-on-demand model allowed flippers to bulk-order cards and resell them for profit, those same resellers were the ones driving up print runs by ordering in massive quantities, creating a self-defeating cycle where higher profits incentivized larger future print runs.
  • The Ken Griffy Jr. card printed 99,177 copies on May 27th, nearly triple the previous record, which represented about a quarter of all Project 2020 sales up to that point and directly triggered the market collapse despite some collectors believing prices could never fall below retail.
  • Artists benefited substantially from the bubble despite the crash because their royalties were paid on cards sold at retail, not resale prices, meaning they earned full compensation regardless of whether secondary market prices collapsed.
  • A forum member predicted in May 2024 that in retrospect, Project 2020 would be remembered like 1980s junk wax—as a speculative bubble era that defined an inflection point in collecting culture, paralleling 1991 Fleer as a market inflection event.

Topics

Print-on-demand business model and its economic incentivesSpeculative bubble formation driven by social media and FOMOFlipper culture and bulk buying as a driver of print runsSecondary market collapse and investor lossesArtist royalties and manufacturer benefits during bubble collapseOnline community sentiment and prediction accuracy

Transcript

[0:01] This card sold on eBay last month for $2. In May of 2020, more than 99,000 people paid $19.99 for it. And for a few weeks that spring, cards from the same set were selling for thousands. Just when I thought collectors couldn't be any dumber. They go ahead and spend $4,000 on a card that they could have bought for $20 a couple of weeks ago. 6 days after launch, a thread on blowout forums called it the worst product since [0:31] 1991 fleer. It turned into one of the biggest threads the forum has ever had. More than 4,000 pages and over a 100,000 posts. This is the story of Topps Project 2020. How a $20 art…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.