NewsStory

The PSA Middleman Who Couldn’t Pay: The Marx Cards Story

Sports Card Radio

Mark's Cards, a PSA group submitter run by Michael Minhares, collected millions from collectors by acting as a middleman to grade their cards, but collapsed in early 2022 after PSA shut down its cheapest service levels and the company couldn't pay its $800,000 bill. Thousands of customers' cards were stuck in limbo, and Minhares filed for personal bankruptcy while evading accountability.

Summary

Mark's Cards operated as a PSA group submitter between 2020 and 2022, functioning as a middleman that collected cards and payments from individual collectors and card shops, then shipped them in bulk to PSA for grading under its own dealer account. The business thrived during PSA's backlog crisis in 2020-2021, bringing in nearly $1 million in its first four months and handling over 30,000 submissions monthly by March 2021. Minhares leveraged the speediness of direct PSA access as a selling point and received endorsements from prominent hobby figures like Mojo Sports.

The business model relied on a critical timing advantage: collectors paid Mark's Cards upfront, but PSA only billed Mark's Cards after grading the cards, which could take months due to the backlog. This created a cash flow advantage that masked underlying problems. However, in March 2021, PSA shut down its cheapest service levels to manage its backlog, eliminating the revenue stream Mark's Cards depended on. Between November 2020 and March 2021, Mark's Cards had already sent PSA approximately 50,000 cards from customers who had paid upfront, but PSA hadn't yet billed Mark's Cards for grading.

With its primary business model destroyed and a massive outstanding bill approaching, Mark's Cards took out loans to stay afloat. By mid-August 2021, the company was essentially out of money. Publicly, Minhares maintained the appearance of normalcy, appearing at card shows, podcasts, and even claiming PSA was the best in the world and he'd run the business "until there's no tomorrow." Privately, the operation was disintegrating: the bookkeeper disappeared in November 2021, the banking partner walked away, and card shops like Gems Only stopped paying for their submitted cards.

On January 20, 2022, when confronted on a live call by Sports Cards Nonsense, Minhares denied running off with money and cards but dodged direct questions about owing PSA money. The next day, PSA announced it hadn't received payment from Mark's Cards and removed the company from its authorized dealers list. On February 7, 2022, Mark's Cards filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, listing $4.5 million in annual revenue but less than $90,000 in assets and over $1 million in debts—approximately $800,000 owed to PSA.

Minhares subsequently filed for personal bankruptcy, listing assets that included a Giannis jersey, fishing poles, a punching bag, and a few hundred dollars in Bitcoin. The entire operation had been run through Instagram as an informal contact business, and when Mark's Cards finally provided PSA with customer identification, it was a 62-page PDF of names and Instagram handles.

Approximately 50,000 cards from over 500 customers remained stuck at PSA. Direct PSA customers had their grading fees waived and only had to pay shipping, but customers whose cards went through unauthorized dealers like Gems Only faced worse outcomes: they either had to pay full March 2021 PSA prices to retrieve graded cards or take them back ungraded. Returns didn't begin until May 2022, over a year after initial submission. By January 2023, PSA still held approximately 4,800 cards. In response to the crisis, PSA changed its group submitter policies to require 50% payment upfront. A similar situation occurred in November 2022 when PSA cut ties with Lkins Collectibles (PSA UK) for non-payment, warning customers of 6-12 month delays. Minhares made no further public statements after the January call.

Key Insights

  • Mark's Cards' business model created a timing advantage where collectors paid upfront but PSA only billed after grading months later, which masked the company's inability to eventually pay the $800,000 bill for 50,000 cards.
  • PSA's March 2021 decision to shut down its cheapest service levels eliminated Mark's Cards' primary revenue stream overnight, transforming a growing business into a failing one almost immediately.
  • Minhares continued accepting cards and customer payments into early 2022 despite knowing by mid-August 2021 that the company was essentially out of money and couldn't pay PSA's bill.
  • When directly confronted on a live call about owing PSA money in January 2022, Minhares claimed to be shipping cards and denied running off with money while explicitly dodging the question about PSA debt.
  • Mark's Cards was effectively an informal Instagram-based contact business with no legitimate infrastructure, as evidenced by the bankruptcy filing's 62-page PDF of customer names and Instagram handles as its primary customer identification system.

Topics

Mark's Cards business model and middleman operationsPSA backlog crisis and service level changesCash flow collapse and financial insolvencyBankruptcy filings and customer impactFraud and accountability evasionCard industry risk and regulatory response

Transcript

[0:00] As you know, with me, it's uh it's all about the vibes. >> Found them on Instagram. The best graders in the world. Man, I wish I wouldn't have graded with anyone else. >> Trusting people with money is one thing, but trusting someone with Mark's cards is another. In 2021, a card shop in Camaro, California was sending tens of thousands of cards a month to PSA. They came from collectors all over the country and from other card shops. In January 2022, the cards stopped coming back. [0:31] >> Yeah, call him. I just want I just want to talk to him for just a second and just see. I I cannot imagine he's going to call.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.