StoryInsightful

The Dirtiest Baseball Card Ever Made

Sports Card Radio

The 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken baseball card became a collectible sensation after an X-rated phrase was discovered written on the bat knob in the photo. Fleer attempted damage control by halting production and creating corrected versions, but the controversy and mystery surrounding how the card made it to print transformed an ordinary utility infielder's card into one of the most famous in hobby history.

Summary

In January 1989, Fleer released card number 616 featuring Baltimore Orioles utility infielder Billy Ripken. The card went unnoticed until someone examined it closely and discovered two X-rated words written in black marker on the knob of Ripken's bat. Billy later explained that he had written "F*** Face" on his batting practice bat at Fenway Park in June 1988 to easily identify it among other bats, and a Fleer photographer took his picture without noticing the words.

The card's discovery triggered a media frenzy and unprecedented demand. Dealers began selling copies for escalating prices—$10 initially, then $25, $50, and eventually up to $150 per card. During the peak of the Junk Wax era, the card became a chase card that nobody planned. Some dealers even required buyers to be 21 years old.

Billy Ripken initially blamed a teammate prank to reporters, claiming he was angry and disappointed. This explanation persisted for 20 years until he admitted in 2008 that he had written it himself. His father Cal Ripken Sr. was not happy about the incident, though Cal Jr. found it amusing. Billy later gave signed copies to his wedding groomsmen that winter.

Fleer's response involved halting production after the Baltimore Sun broke the story 16 days into distribution. Company president Vincent Murray acknowledged it as a proofreading miss. Fleer stopped the presses and blacked out the words on all subsequent printings, while also attempting to recall cases from distributors and offering to mail clean copies to anyone who sent in the dirty version. Few people took this offer.

Photographer Steve Babino defended Fleer, claiming the company didn't intentionally produce the card and that three-color blueprints made it difficult to notice the writing. However, Billy and his father have suggested Fleer saw it and enhanced or punched it up intentionally. Fleer's history of not returning phone calls and the timing—when Upper Deck was entering the market—fueled conspiracy theories.

Fleer was sold by the Mustin family in summer 1989 and eventually went under, with the brand eventually acquired by Upper Deck. Today, the original card isn't rare—PSA has graded over 25,000 copies—and raw copies sell for around $100. Various corrected versions exist with different values, with white-scribble and whited-out PSA 10 copies selling for thousands of dollars. In 2024, Topps paid tribute with a Jackson Holiday rookie card featuring the same reference.

Key Insights

  • Billy Ripken wrote the X-rated phrase himself on his batting practice bat at Fenway Park in June 1988 to identify it among other bats, yet initially blamed a teammate prank to reporters because he believed people would think he was 'the scum of the earth' for doing it
  • The card sold for escalating prices within days of discovery—$10, then $15, $25, and eventually $75 to $150 per card—turning a 5-cent common card of a utility infielder into an unprecedented chase card during the peak Junk Wax era
  • Fleer stopped printing immediately after the Baltimore Sun broke the story 16 days after cards hit shelves, and attempted to recall cases from distributors while offering to mail clean copies in exchange for the dirty ones, but almost no one took the offer
  • Billy Ripken and his father Cal Sr. have suggested Fleer intentionally saw the writing and enhanced or produced it for publicity during the competitive peak Junk Wax era, while Fleer and the photographer have maintained it was an undetected proofreading miss
  • In 2024, Topps released a tribute card of Orioles rookie Jackson Holiday with 'Fun Face' written on the bat knob wearing number seven, the same number Billy Ripken wore on the controversial 1989 card

Topics

1989 Fleer Billy Ripken baseball cardX-rated phrase on bat knobBaseball card market during Junk Wax eraFleer's quality control failure and damage control responseConspiracy theories about intentional productionCard value and collectibilityBilly Ripken's initial false explanation

Transcript

[0:00] to game boy. It's auto. >> But when Baltimore Orio Billy Ripken posed for his picture, there were two words written on the knob of his bat in black magic marker. And one of those words was X-rated. >> Well, the first day I became aware of it, they were selling it for $10. The next day it was 15. The next day it was 25. And then two days later I saw people selling it for $75. Some have even sold for as high as $150 [0:32] each. Not bad for a 5-cent card. January 1989, a 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken. Not a rookie card, not a Hall of Famer, just a utility infielder on the worst team…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Radio

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.