The Company That Runs the Hobby: The Untold Story of PSA
This documentary traces PSA's evolution from a coin-grading side project into a monopolistic force controlling the trading card market, detailing its near-bankruptcy, fraud scandals involving trimmed cards, explosive growth during the 2020 boom, and current dominance that has made it both indispensable and widely resented by collectors.
Summary
PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) began in 1991 as a side project of PCGS, a coin-grading company, applying the same plastic-slab authentication model to baseball cards. The parent company Collector's Universe went public in 1999 and expanded aggressively, but nearly collapsed twice—first during the dot-com bubble (2000-2003) losing $10.4 million and dropping 90% in stock value, and again after disastrous ventures into diamond and jewelry grading (2005-2009) that cost $34 million. For a decade afterward, PSA operated steadily if unspectacularly, grading about one million cards annually while competing evenly with Beckett, whose high subgrades sometimes commanded premiums over PSA 10s.
In 2019, the hobby discovered a massive fraud network: collectors on message boards identified serial-numbered cards that had been trimmed (edges shaved with a paper cutter to sharpen corners) and resubmitted to PSA for higher grades. The cards showed up in the same slabs at different grades and with visibly smaller dimensions. Approximately 93 modern cards and numerous vintage cards were implicated, many connected to PWC, a major auction house generating $60 million annually, and dealer Gary Moser. The FBI launched an investigation and subpoenaed hobby businesses at the 2019 National Sports Collectors Convention, but no charges were ever filed. Remarkably, instead of damaging PSA's reputation, the scandal preceded an unprecedented surge in submissions as collectors rushed to grade cards during the COVID-era stimulus boom.
In 2020, tech founder Nat Turner partnered with Steve Cohen's investment firm and D1 Capital to purchase PSA for $851 million, and within a year it was valued at $4.3 billion. New ownership opened the floodgates: submissions exploded, creating a 10 million-card backlog by 2021. PSA raised prices dramatically, shut down lower submission tiers, and began aggressively acquiring competitors—Genement (AI trimming detection), Golden (auction house), Card Ladder (price guide), SGC (vintage grader), and finally Beckett in December 2025. This consolidation triggered FTC investigation concerns about monopolistic practices, as PSA now grades approximately 19 million cards annually (90,000 per day) versus Beckett's 800,000, and controls grading services, price data, and marketplace infrastructure simultaneously.
The rapid expansion created widespread resentment. PSA implemented upcharges when cards exceeded their submission tier value, paused bulk submission tiers in May 2026, raised prices repeatedly, and maintained backlogs approaching 14 million cards. A December 2025 incident exposed quality control problems: a collector sold Pokémon cards graded PSA 9 through PSA's offers program, only to discover identical cards now graded as 10s in secondary sales. Despite public criticism, submissions continued climbing, with PSA reporting record submission days in 2026 even during organized "No PSA May" boycotts. The documentary concludes by noting that a Derek Jeter rookie worth $10,000 in PSA 9 grade commands over $300,000 in PSA 10—same card, one company's opinion—illustrating how PSA's dominance has made its grades the sole determinant of card value.
Key Insights
- Joe Orlando, PSA's CEO, stated that 'a lot of cards get graded in about 30 seconds,' yet PSA's graders are expected to catch sophisticated alterations like trimming, creating an impossible quality control standard.
- Forum sleuths discovered that the same serial-numbered cards sold at different grades showed visibly smaller dimensions when photos were overlaid, proving trimming had occurred inside PSA slabs from major dealers and auction houses.
- Despite PSA's acknowledgment of trimming fraud in 2019 and the revelation that its labels could be beaten with a paper cutter, submissions to PSA increased rather than decreased, suggesting collectors prioritize the PSA label over accuracy.
- After acquiring competitors including Beckett, SGC, and Card Ladder, PSA now controls grading services, price guides, marketplace data, and auction houses—a vertical integration that prompted congressional concerns about monopolistic practices.
- A December 2025 incident where identical Pokémon cards were graded as PSA 9 when sold through PSA's offers program but later appeared as PSA 10s in secondary sales revealed potential systematic quality control or grade manipulation issues within PSA's own resale operations.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] One company decides what your cards are worth. It almost went broke twice. The first card it ever graded trimmed. In 2019, the trimmers were back. Doctorred cards sitting in PSA slabs and the forum threads exposing them must TV. The FBI came asking questions. Then the floodgates open. A 10 million card backlog. In the middle of it all, the whole company was sold. $851 million. [0:31] A year later, investors valued it at $4.3 billion. It bought its competitors. It graded cards a nine. They got sold. Then they became 10. Same card, same, different grade. They raised prices and submissions hit a 4-year high. This is the story of PSA. This is a 1993 SP Derek…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Radio
He Put $10,000 Into Zion Cards. 6 Years Later…
A person invested $10,000 in 14 Zion Williamson trading cards at ~$800 each, expecting the price to exceed $1,500 if Zion made the playoffs. However, the Pelicans missed the playoffs, the card's peak value was $970 during Christmas, and it has since dropped to approximately $20.
The Card Hobby's Biggest Companies Took $15 Million in PPP Loans
Trading card industry companies received over $15 million in PPP loans during the COVID-19 pandemic, with most loans being forgiven despite the hobby experiencing unprecedented boom conditions by the time forgiveness occurred. Several major companies and individuals obtained these loans through questionable means, though none have been charged yet.
We Didn’t Sell the Channel. Here’s Why We’re Making AI Videos
Ryan from Sportscard Radio explains why they're using AI to create content and manage their card buying/selling business, clarifying they didn't sell their YouTube channel. He argues that AI saves time—the most valuable resource—and allows them to scale their singles trading business to six figures while criticizing the gambling-focused approach most collectors take.
Why the Hobby Questioned the Paul Skenes 1/1 Pull
A documentary-style video examines the controversial discovery of a rare 1/1 Paul Skenes rookie card pulled by an 11-year-old on Christmas 2024, which sparked widespread conspiracy theories questioning whether the pull was authentic or an elaborate marketing scheme by Fanatics/Topps.
The Dallas Card Show Heist: $2 Million in Cards, No Arrests
A $2 million theft of rare baseball cards at the Dallas Card Show remains unsolved over two years later, with no arrests made. The highly coordinated heist was captured on security footage, but subsequent conspiracy theories from an online account suggesting the dealer orchestrated the theft himself have muddied the investigation and divided the collecting community.