Signed by a Machine: The Dak Prescott Autopen Cards
In 2017, Dak Prescott's rookie autographed cards from Panini were flagged by Beckett Grading as potentially machine-signed, sparking a major controversy in the sports card collecting community. Panini recalled the cards and later had Prescott sign replacements, but questions about who originally signed the cards and how duplicates entered circulation remain unanswered.
Summary
In summer 2017, collectors discovered that Dak Prescott's highly sought-after 2016 Panini Prism rookie autograph cards exhibited suspicious characteristics suggesting machine signing. Beckett Grading's principal authenticator Steve Grad identified machine-like qualities in the signatures, including uniform starts and stops in the ink that natural handwriting wouldn't produce. When collectors overlaid scans of multiple cards, they discovered the jersey numbers, loops, and ink tremors appeared identical across different cards, further supporting the autopen theory.
Panini initially handled the situation quietly, calling back FedEx packages already in transit to collectors. However, the Blowout forums community quickly documented the anomalies, and the story exploded across major media outlets including ESPN, Pro Football Talk, The Washington Post, and Bleacher Report within 24 hours. Panini's initial statement was corrected to specify only 2016 Prism cards were affected, but the company never publicly identified who signed the original cards or authorized the machine signing.
Dak Prescott addressed the controversy at the ESPYs red carpet, claiming he didn't know how the cards returned to Panini and attributing the issue to lost cards during travel. He denied using an autopen. Panini subsequently organized supervised signing sessions with Prescott present and overseeing staff, adding hologram stickers to authenticated new cards. However, four years later, collectors discovered duplicate cards numbered to 10, with identical serial numbers but different authenticity statuses, suggesting cards were produced beyond the authorized quantity.
In 2020, authenticator Steve Grad claimed on social media that the Dallas Cowboys knowingly used autopen for multiple players including Dak Prescott, Roger Staubach, Troy Aikman, and Tony Romo. Despite these allegations, neither Panini nor Prescott publicly identified who actually signed the controversial original cards, and some cards remain unaccounted for and unauthenticated.
Key Insights
- Beckett Grading identified machine signatures by detecting starts and stops in ink that natural handwriting doesn't produce, suggesting autopen use rather than human signing
- Collectors discovered that overlaying scans of different Prescott cards showed identical jersey number positioning, loop spacing, and ink tremor patterns, indicating mechanical reproduction
- Panini's initial response was to quietly recall FedEx packages already in transit without public disclosure, only becoming public after ESPN received a leaked Blowout forum thread
- Panini's corrected statement claimed Prescott and his representatives didn't know how the autopen-signed cards reached them, but never publicly identified who actually signed the original cards
- Authenticator Steve Grad claimed in 2020 that the Dallas Cowboys knowingly used autopen for multiple players including Prescott, Staubach, Aikman, and Romo
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] In the summer of 2017, the most wanted rookie card in football came back from its signer with a signature that looked a little too perfect. Collectors caught it first. Within 2 days, it was on Sports Center. >> Dak Prescott being accused of using a machine to sign his autographs. What more can you tell us about this? So, the way this went down was there was a redemption card and uh and Dak uh actually signed these or was given these things to sign. Unfortunately, the folks at Beckett then came in and said, "Well, [0:31] we're going to refuse these because we don't think these are real. We think that these were done by a machine.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Radio
From Federal Prison to a $12.9M Card: Who Is Shyne150?
Matt Allen, known as Shyne150, was released from federal prison in 2018 after serving time for MDMA trafficking and marijuana/cocaine-related offenses. Since his release, he has become a prominent figure in high-end sports card collecting, leading a group that has spent approximately $250 million on rare cards including record-breaking purchases.
He Put $10,000 Into Zion Cards. 6 Years Later…
A person invested $10,000 in 14 Zion Williamson trading cards at ~$800 each, expecting the price to exceed $1,500 if Zion made the playoffs. However, the Pelicans missed the playoffs, the card's peak value was $970 during Christmas, and it has since dropped to approximately $20.
The Card Hobby's Biggest Companies Took $15 Million in PPP Loans
Trading card industry companies received over $15 million in PPP loans during the COVID-19 pandemic, with most loans being forgiven despite the hobby experiencing unprecedented boom conditions by the time forgiveness occurred. Several major companies and individuals obtained these loans through questionable means, though none have been charged yet.
We Didn’t Sell the Channel. Here’s Why We’re Making AI Videos
Ryan from Sportscard Radio explains why they're using AI to create content and manage their card buying/selling business, clarifying they didn't sell their YouTube channel. He argues that AI saves time—the most valuable resource—and allows them to scale their singles trading business to six figures while criticizing the gambling-focused approach most collectors take.
Why the Hobby Questioned the Paul Skenes 1/1 Pull
A documentary-style video examines the controversial discovery of a rare 1/1 Paul Skenes rookie card pulled by an 11-year-old on Christmas 2024, which sparked widespread conspiracy theories questioning whether the pull was authentic or an elaborate marketing scheme by Fanatics/Topps.