What's happening in the sports card market?? NOT doom & gloom!
Mike and Teapot discuss contradictions in the sports card market: while $1.1 billion in sales were recorded in October, lower-budget collectors report drastically reduced spending, suggesting a split market where high-value sales are driving volume while grassroots participation has declined. They analyze trends in grading, unpaid auctions, player-specific market movements, and whether current valuations are sustainable.
Summary
The podcast episode opens with discussion of record-breaking sales volumes in the sports card market—$1.1 billion reported in October across major online marketplaces, nearly double the $500 million milestone hit in March. However, hosts Mike and Teapot identify a stark disconnect: while aggregate sales numbers appear robust, anecdotal evidence and user analytics suggest lower-spending collectors (those with budgets of a few hundred dollars monthly) have significantly reduced purchases. This creates what they describe as 'two hobbies'—a thriving high-end market and a stagnating grassroots market. Teapot notes that the Sports Card Investor app shows flattening monthly active users, daily active users, and website traffic, suggesting the October boom may be seasonal or driven by a small number of high-value transactions rather than broad-based enthusiasm.
The conversation turns to data inconsistencies and potential market manipulation. Teapot raises concerns about unpaid auctions—situations where high-value sales fail to clear, with consigners waiting weeks before learning their items went unpaid. He mentions seeing unusually high rates of being outbid on mid-range cards ($50-$300) only to see identical cards relisted shortly after, suggesting possible shill bidding or deliberate price manipulation. Mike observes a different pattern: cards appreciating dramatically (e.g., Tony Gwynn rookies rising from $300 to $1,000+) then being immediately repurchased and resold by dealers at even higher prices on non-auction listings, indicating dealer speculation and flipping rather than organic market movement.
Regarding market indices and trend analysis, Teapot presents data from Market Movers tracking: the SCI 500 (all-era sports cards index) has flattened over the last 30 days after months of growth, while the SCI Pokémon 500 has declined 14% in two weeks. More notably, Pokémon cards experienced a bizarre 10-14 day spike approximately one month prior where numerous cards jumped from $8,000-$15,000 ranges into six figures. Teapot expresses uncertainty about legitimacy, noting that Fanatics Collect auctions featured the top 50 sales as Pokémon cards during this period, then all corrected downward. They stress that price movement alone doesn't reveal true market health—volume change is equally important. Kevin Garnett cards are down 23% but volume up 15%; Amare Stoudemire is down 17% but volume up 109%, suggesting liquidation rather than heating.
The grading ecosystem receives significant scrutiny. PSA graded 2.75 million cards in October (CGC nearly 1 million), yet Teapot highlights a troubling metric: 122,100 graded cards sold for under $40 in a single week—below the current PSA submission cost. Breaking this further: 22,300 cards sold for $10 or less, 78,700 for $25 or less. Both hosts question whether this constitutes a 'junk slab era' where cards are graded not for appreciation but as speculative currency. They discuss whether these slabs are repeatedly cracked and resubmitted, but acknowledge data doesn't exist to confirm this. Conversely, they note that grading remains a 'foolproof profit engine' for collectors and box-openers because PSA 10s command multipliers of 3x-25x over raw versions, ensuring grading demand persists despite the junk slab phenomenon.
The hosts share personal collecting philosophies. Mike sold his PSA 10 Shohei Ohtani rookies (up ~500% from purchase price) but declined to downgrade to PSA 9s if the price difference remained significant—preferring to wait for better deals or pursue other interests like Pedro Martinez cards (accessed easily via Auctionwire). He also chose to hold his Steph Curry rookie (purchased at $800, appreciated to $3,800) rather than selling and downgrading, reasoning that future appreciation in high-grade cards historically outpaces lower grades. Teapot similarly advocates for holding premium-grade cards long-term when the alternative is spending months hunting for marginal downgrades. They reference collector Eric of Those Back Pages' philosophy about valuing one's time—sometimes holding is preferable to selling and searching.
The episode closes with broader market philosophy. Teapot expresses simultaneous bullishness and skepticism: he sees huge money flowing through cards (sports betting, sneakers, fashion, general wealth distribution) and believes the hobby has barely scratched its penetration potential, yet remains perplexed by mathematics—how median household income and credit card debt levels support such volumes of $5,000-$10,000 Pokémon cards in PSA 10 form. Both acknowledge that recessions could dampen discretionary spending, though they note COVID-era stimulus created unusual conditions. Mike emphasizes they're discussing current state, not long-term outlook, and both maintain the hobby is fundamentally healthy despite short-term corrections.
Key Insights
- Over 122,100 graded cards sold for $40 or less in a single week—below the cost of PSA grading itself—raising questions about whether a 'junk slab era' exists where cards are graded for speculative purposes rather than genuine value appreciation.
- Pokémon cards experienced a mysterious 10-14 day period where numerous cards jumped from $8,000-$15,000 to six-figure prices, then corrected downward, with the legitimacy of these sales still unconfirmed despite outreach to Fanatics.
- Unpaid auctions appear to be underreported across major platforms—consigners wait 2-4 weeks to learn sales failed to clear, then must decide whether to relist, creating untracked relisting volume that distorts reported sales metrics.
- Volume change data reveals liquidation patterns: Kevin Garnett cards down 23% with volume up 15%, Amare Stoudemire down 17% with volume up 109%, indicating sellers are pushing inventory at lower prices rather than organic market appreciation.
- The $1.1 billion October sales figure likely masks a 'two hobbies' phenomenon—high-value transactions driving aggregate numbers while lower-spending collectors with budgets of a few hundred dollars monthly have substantially reduced purchases.
Topics
Transcript
[0:01] [music] >> This week in sports cards. [music] Hey everybody. It is Mike and this is this week in sports cards sponsored by auctionwire.ai. Auctionwire just this week announced they have 80 marketplaces and auction houses that they're searching through. I use them. They provide me with recommendations of cards based on my searches, my search history, [0:33] my watchlist, and it is amazing. I keep finding insane Pedro Martinez cards that I've never seen before out at auction houses I've never heard of before. Use code SCC for 60 days free on auctionwire.ai. Teapot, hey, welcome. How are you? >> Thank you. Happy to be back. Uh we had to miss the last one, but I'm back, baby.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Clubhouse
Getting Caught in a Bidding War! + Mantle vs. Jackie + The Price of Letting Go
Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and Joe Perau discuss Jeremy's emotional experience selling three iconic baseball cards (Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth), getting caught in a bidding war over a Sydney Crosby hockey card, and debate the comparative investment potential of the 52 Topps Jackie Robinson versus the 52 Topps Mickey Mantle.
How Our Card Collecting Has Recently CHANGED!!
Mike and Greg discuss how their card collecting habits have evolved over the past 3-5 years, moving away from complete player runs and graded sets toward more selective, passion-driven collecting. They then review seven items from Greg's eBay watchlist, ranking them by desirability and discussing what these choices reveal about their shifting collector identities.
Investigating The Future Of Sports Card Values- MidLife Card Chase
David Chase and Greg Miller discuss the card hobby through a tier-based framework, comparing player and set hierarchies across 1950s baseball, 1990s basketball inserts, and modern cards. They argue that understanding tier structures helps identify undervalued collecting opportunities and provides a systematic approach to entering new collecting lanes.
Selling "Identity Cards"
In this episode of Turn Back the Clock, Adam and Shane discuss the concept of 'identity cards'—cards that define a collector's identity—inspired by Jeremy Lee's recent episode about selling major cards at the Toronto Expo. They explore their own collections, sharing examples of irreplaceable cards like Shane's Josh Gibson Super Fractor and Adam's 2009 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor Mickey Mantle, and showcase recent acquisitions including vintage Disney cards, buyback rookies, and non-sports memorabilia.
Jeremy Sold Grails + Jeremy Needs Counselling + David Chase and Jackie Robinson to the Rescue
Jeremy Lee sold five major cards from his personal collection at the Toronto Sport Card Expo, including his prized 1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson, 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle, and 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth, for a combined sum that exceeded his asking prices. He subsequently acquired a 1952 Topps Jackie Robinson PSA 4 as a replacement vintage card and reflected deeply on how these transactions may have shifted his collector mentality from long-term holding to potential investor positioning.