The Post-Grail Dilemma + The Death of Set Collecting? + Hidden Hobby Legends
The hosts discuss post-grail collecting psychology, with David reflecting on how acquiring his Satchel Paige card has made him more selective about future purchases. The episode explores set collecting's viability in the hobby, featuring insights from Josh about building vintage sets, and highlights hidden legendary collectors like Dr. Jeffrey Griffith who maintain massive collections off social media.
Summary
The episode opens with a tribute to Tony from Southern Collector, who famously sold his 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle (his grail card) to purchase a rare Josh Gibson card that ultimately enabled his daughter's fertility treatment, resulting in a grandchild. This story exemplifies how cards transcend monetary value and can meaningfully impact collectors' lives.
David recently acquired his grail card—a 1948/49 Leaf Satchel Paige—three weeks prior to this episode. He discusses the emotional aftermath of achieving this pinnacle, noting that every subsequent card acquisition is compared against this peak experience. Rather than continuing aggressive collecting, David has become significantly more selective, consolidating his collection and vowing to only acquire cards he genuinely loves rather than merely likes. He identifies a sweet spot of 2,000-5,000 population cards as most meaningful to him, avoiding high-population commons that he could easily re-acquire later.
Jeremy contrasts this with his own experience acquiring a Joe Jackson card 18 months prior. He attempted to purchase the same Satchel Paige in a Fanatics auction but withdrew when bidding exceeded his threshold. Interestingly, he felt relief upon not winning, as it freed him from having to make difficult consolidation decisions. He notes that 80% of cards he's re-acquired since his consolidation are genuinely loved pieces, though he observes a creeping tendency to fall back into acquiring cards he merely likes as time passes.
A substantial portion addresses set collecting. A listener email describes rediscovering set collecting after achieving most of his player-specific grails, finding fulfillment in completing near-complete vintage sets like 1995 Ultra Gold Medallions and 1994 Upper Deck Electric Ice. This prompts discussion about whether set collecting is truly dead. Josh Adams, a major 1949 Leaf set builder focusing on short prints, argues set collecting remains vibrant but invisible on social media. He notes that set collectors—typically older, dedicated hobbyists with checklists at shows—don't document their collections online, creating a false perception of the hobby's composition.
David acknowledges set collectors derive genuine joy without fixating on value, though he critiques the economics: completing a set garners no premium when selling, as dealers inevitably break completed sets for maximum value. Josh counters that he doesn't expect premiums; instead, he views completed sets as trophy achievements representing years of hunting. He sold both his completed 1933 Goudey (minus Lajoie) and 1948 Leaf sets to REA, using proceeds for other grail acquisitions. Despite uniform grades being impossible (his set contained PSA, SGC, BGS, and raw cards), he treasures memories of where and when each card was acquired.
Josh emphasizes the hunt—not ownership—drives set collecting satisfaction. Once a set completes, motivation deflates because the challenge ends. He's already begun rebuilding his Leaf set despite recently finishing one.
As a consignment director for Slab Sharks, Josh advises against selling complete sets, recommending instead breaking them into individual auctions. Selling complete sets alienates buyers seeking only a few cards and typically results in lower total returns. Buyers prefer the hunt themselves rather than paying premiums for completed work.
The episode concludes with discussion of hidden hobby legends—collectors maintaining extraordinary collections without social media presence. Dr. Jeffrey Griffith recently joined Instagram after 25 years of collecting, having written the definitive book on Gretzky cards and holding top spots on multiple PSA set registry categories. Jeremy knew Griffith personally for years before recognizing him at shows. The hosts share anecdotes about anonymous longtime collectors—someone with comprehensive vintage Topps holdings on old message boards, another with extensive pre-NFL football memorabilia—demonstrating that Instagram's high-visibility collectors represent a tiny fraction of the hobby's actual depth and sophistication. Jeremy concludes by referencing Gary Cypres's Los Angeles-based museum collection featuring game-used Babe Ruth uniforms and complete T206 sets—arguably the world's finest sports memorabilia collection, yet virtually unknown to the social media-driven hobby community.
Key Insights
- David explains that after acquiring his grail Satchel Paige card, he realized he doesn't want to buy cards he merely likes anymore—only cards he genuinely loves—because he's learned through consolidation which cards he's willing to sacrifice versus keep forever.
- Jeremy observes that collectors don't actually replace cards they've given up during consolidation for grail acquisitions, contrary to the common rationalization that 'I can get that again someday,' suggesting this excuse masks deeper reluctance to complete the sacrifice.
- Josh argues that selling a complete set garners no premium and typically results in lower total value compared to breaking it up into individual auctions, because dealers will inevitably break any completed set to maximize profits.
- Josh identifies that set collectors derive primary satisfaction from the hunt and challenge of finding cards, not from ownership, which is why collectors experience letdown upon completing a set and immediately move to the next challenge or sell it.
- Jeremy describes that Dr. Jeffrey Griffith and other legendary collectors with museum-quality collections maintain virtually no social media presence, suggesting the Instagram hobby community represents only a tiny fraction of actual collecting depth and sophistication.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] No, Josh, I guess he hasn't shown up, so we have no Josh. Uh if you want to take you want to just get started and we'll we'll just go. >> Let's do it. [music] [music] [0:32] [music] >> Do do. What up, buddy? How are you? >> I'm doing well. You know what I just noticed is that Hoj is also in the car with us. He's never made appearance on the Hangover, right? >> I know. I can't redo that little video though. Like I could, but I don't know how. So, [clears throat] we're going to leave him there. He's a part of the team. He's a part of the Sports Cards Live team, Hoj, so…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Clubhouse
Getting Caught in a Bidding War! + Mantle vs. Jackie + The Price of Letting Go
Jeremy Lee, David Chase, and Joe Perau discuss Jeremy's emotional experience selling three iconic baseball cards (Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth), getting caught in a bidding war over a Sydney Crosby hockey card, and debate the comparative investment potential of the 52 Topps Jackie Robinson versus the 52 Topps Mickey Mantle.
How Our Card Collecting Has Recently CHANGED!!
Mike and Greg discuss how their card collecting habits have evolved over the past 3-5 years, moving away from complete player runs and graded sets toward more selective, passion-driven collecting. They then review seven items from Greg's eBay watchlist, ranking them by desirability and discussing what these choices reveal about their shifting collector identities.
Investigating The Future Of Sports Card Values- MidLife Card Chase
David Chase and Greg Miller discuss the card hobby through a tier-based framework, comparing player and set hierarchies across 1950s baseball, 1990s basketball inserts, and modern cards. They argue that understanding tier structures helps identify undervalued collecting opportunities and provides a systematic approach to entering new collecting lanes.
Selling "Identity Cards"
In this episode of Turn Back the Clock, Adam and Shane discuss the concept of 'identity cards'—cards that define a collector's identity—inspired by Jeremy Lee's recent episode about selling major cards at the Toronto Expo. They explore their own collections, sharing examples of irreplaceable cards like Shane's Josh Gibson Super Fractor and Adam's 2009 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor Mickey Mantle, and showcase recent acquisitions including vintage Disney cards, buyback rookies, and non-sports memorabilia.
Jeremy Sold Grails + Jeremy Needs Counselling + David Chase and Jackie Robinson to the Rescue
Jeremy Lee sold five major cards from his personal collection at the Toronto Sport Card Expo, including his prized 1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson, 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle, and 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth, for a combined sum that exceeded his asking prices. He subsequently acquired a 1952 Topps Jackie Robinson PSA 4 as a replacement vintage card and reflected deeply on how these transactions may have shifted his collector mentality from long-term holding to potential investor positioning.