Deciding Which Sports Cards To Sell...
David, Greg, and Joe discuss their processes for deciding which sports and vintage cards to sell in order to fund larger purchases. They emphasize that selling cards is a normal part of collecting, driven by the desire to hunt for new acquisitions and reshape collections rather than purely financial motivation. The hosts walk through specific cards David is selling, from duplicates to modern investments, explaining their reasoning for each.
Summary
The episode opens with hosts Greg Miller and David discussing the stigma around selling cards in the collecting community, with some people criticizing those who sell. They bring on guest Joe Perotta to discuss a topic they believe deserves more attention: when and how to decide which cards to sell. The discussion is prompted by commentary from collectors like Lou Rock and Dylan Double D about consolidation—selling cards to fund new purchases rather than just pursuing a specific trophy card.
The hosts explore different reasons for selling: raising capital for larger acquisitions, replacing inferior copies with better versions, reducing collection bloat, and managing investments that have grown to unrealistic prices. David shares his personal process of categorizing cards into groups based on how much he loves them: untouchable cards, cards he likes but can live without, and cards ready for sale. He organized his selling in phases of increasing difficulty.
The first phase involved selling duplicates and triplicates of cards David already owns multiple copies of, including a Nasty Nick Garbage Pail Kids card (PSA 8), an Abdul-Jabbar rookie, Willie Mays 1951 Bowman, Wilt Chamberlain 1961 Fleer, and Bob Gibson 1959 Topps. These were easier to part with despite loving the cards because he has superior or equivalent copies.
The second phase included 1948-49 Leaf cards. Although David loves the Leaf set and collects extensively, he realized he doesn't need every member to appreciate the set. He's keeping his favorite cards (Joe DiMaggio with multiple variations, Jackie Robinson, Stan Musial) while selling duplicates and cards that don't evoke as much emotion.
The third phase involved modern cards from the Stadium Club Beam Team series and Chrome sets featuring Shaquille O'Neal, LeBron James, and Kobe Bryant. David admits to having a small investment streak, buying undervalued modern cards that appreciated dramatically (some 13x their purchase price). However, he's concerned about their sustainability and feels they're now overpriced relative to his emotional attachment.
The fourth phase covered non-sports cards, particularly Marvel superhero and Batman cards that experienced explosive growth. David watched some cards grow 10x faster than Jackie Robinson cards, making him uncomfortable with their volatility despite liking them. He sold most of these after the market peaked.
The fifth phase included cards he genuinely loves but only owns one copy of: Magic Johnson and Larry Bird rookies, Abraham Lincoln from the Great Americans set, and various pre-war and vintage cards. These were harder to part with.
The sixth phase involved 1948 Leaf baseball cards with players like Ray Robinson, Joe Louis, Honus Wagner, Rogers Hornsby, Stan Musial, and Enos Slaughter. Though David loves Leaf cards and collects them extensively, he's rethinking his completionist approach and willing to pare down duplicates.
The seventh phase included Venezuelan Retro cards from the 1960s. David loves retro cards and believes in their long-term value, but questioned whether he needs 15 of them. He's keeping his three favorites (Jackie Robinson, Satchel Paige, Sandy Koufax) plus Babe Ruth while selling others, discovering that having fewer cards from a set makes each one feel more meaningful.
The final and most difficult card is the 1933 Gum Inc. Mickey Mouse card—the first color Mickey Mouse card. David bought it at a National convention, but it experienced explosive price growth after Gary Vee mentioned it on his podcast (growing 8-9x in 45 days). Despite loving it and being willing to pay double what he paid, the rapid appreciation scared him into selling. He only decided to part with it because he's acquiring an even more significant card.
Throughout the discussion, Joe emphasizes that the process helps maintain internal narratives about collecting. Greg notes that some people criticize rapid price growth as evidence of manipulation by influencers, though Joe and David suggest the prices reflect genuine rarity and quality. The hosts discuss how Jackie Robinson cards have dramatically increased in value (up 76% in a year), noting that younger collectors value Robinson's cultural significance differently than older collectors who prioritize Mantle.
The episode concludes with card recommendations: David Chase suggests a 1947 Leaf Larry Dobie card as an underrated alternative to the expensive Mantle rookie, while Greg recommends his childhood 1981 Topps Larry Bird card, which he's owned for 35 years and graded as a PSA 8. Joe shares that he found the same Bird card among his late mother's possessions.
Key Insights
- Lou Rock argues that people consolidate card collections primarily to maintain liquidity and continue purchasing new cards, rather than to acquire one specific trophy card, challenging the common assumption about consolidation motivations.
- David discovered that after thinking in terms of rules (like collecting all Hall of Fame members from specific sets), he actually gets more enjoyment having fewer cards from a set, as each individual card feels more meaningful and stands out more.
- David experienced significant concern when non-sports Marvel and Batman cards grew 10 times faster than Jackie Robinson cards in value, viewing such rapid appreciation as a warning sign of an unhealthy market rather than validation of his investment.
- Joe articulates that approximately 20-25% of his purchases are speculative arbitrage plays based on perceived undervaluation, while the remaining 75-80% are genuinely driven by collecting passion, revealing a measured approach to speculation within the hobby.
- Greg observes that younger collectors and non-collectors value Jackie Robinson cards more highly than older traditional collectors who prioritize Mickey Mantle, suggesting collecting preferences are generationally determined by different cultural narratives and significance.
Topics
Transcript
[0:02] Sports Talk all day. Packages with cards, and we we are discussing. So connect and listen to the intro. You are from " Midlife Card Chase. How are you, David? Chase? This is another "Midlife" Card Chase. Yes, this is Greg Miller. Let's start this. I have everything. good. We are not with you. talked to several days. How are you? ? I'm fine. Uh, we also have today guest, so this fascinating. We already prepared it for backstage. [0:34] Uh, I, I prepared presentation with pictures. There are several video clips that worth showing. Uh-huh. This is a high-level show. today, Greg? This is what What do we have? I mean that I hope for an assessment. from…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Clubhouse
Investigating The Future Of Sports Card Values- MidLife Card Chase
David Chase and Greg Miller discuss the card hobby through a tier-based framework, comparing player and set hierarchies across 1950s baseball, 1990s basketball inserts, and modern cards. They argue that understanding tier structures helps identify undervalued collecting opportunities and provides a systematic approach to entering new collecting lanes.
Selling "Identity Cards"
In this episode of Turn Back the Clock, Adam and Shane discuss the concept of 'identity cards'—cards that define a collector's identity—inspired by Jeremy Lee's recent episode about selling major cards at the Toronto Expo. They explore their own collections, sharing examples of irreplaceable cards like Shane's Josh Gibson Super Fractor and Adam's 2009 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor Mickey Mantle, and showcase recent acquisitions including vintage Disney cards, buyback rookies, and non-sports memorabilia.
Jeremy Sold Grails + Jeremy Needs Counselling + David Chase and Jackie Robinson to the Rescue
Jeremy Lee sold five major cards from his personal collection at the Toronto Sport Card Expo, including his prized 1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson, 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle, and 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth, for a combined sum that exceeded his asking prices. He subsequently acquired a 1952 Topps Jackie Robinson PSA 4 as a replacement vintage card and reflected deeply on how these transactions may have shifted his collector mentality from long-term holding to potential investor positioning.
Would You Buy Your Grail Card At Half Off?
Mike and Greg discuss a hypothetical about buying a grail card at half price with the condition of never showing it, exploring how social sharing enhances collector joy. They also cover TTM autographs, recent card show experiences, and how market conditions are affecting their buying behavior.
What's happening in the sports card market?? NOT doom & gloom!
Mike and Teapot discuss contradictions in the sports card market: while $1.1 billion in sales were recorded in October, lower-budget collectors report drastically reduced spending, suggesting a split market where high-value sales are driving volume while grassroots participation has declined. They analyze trends in grading, unpaid auctions, player-specific market movements, and whether current valuations are sustainable.