DiscussionOpinion

David Chase Changes Lanes + The '90s Card Rabbit Hole

Sports Card Clubhouse

David Chase discusses his upcoming Toronto Expo trip, his new venture into 1990s sports card collecting (particularly modern hockey and basketball inserts), and his audiobook project of 'Pops and Comps.' Jeremy Lee shares his experience entering the 90s card market and they explore the nuances of collecting era-specific players and cards.

Summary

The episode opens with discussion of David Chase's preparation for the Toronto Expo, where he aims to find twelve cards for his personal collection ranging from $10 to $1,200 each, focusing primarily on modern hockey auto patches from the 2000s-2017 era rather than expensive recent career cards. He's bringing a double booth with Joshua Adams and friend Karen, and co-hosting a Thursday networking event with Grant Patterson sponsored by Upper Deck.

A significant portion of the conversation focuses on David Chase's new interest in 1990s sports card collecting, a departure from his traditional vintage focus. He describes his methodical approach: creating ranked lists of players by personal preference across baseball, basketball, and football from 1997-2000, researching comparable sales data, and building spreadsheets before making purchases. Jeremy Lee explains that he entered this space around 2017-2018 and has watched values evolve. David's strategy differs markedly from Jeremy's earlier impulsive $5,000 entry into the market—David is researching sets, comparing player valuations, and recognizing opportunities where iconic players like Roger Clemens are undervalued compared to Barry Bonds and Ken Griffey Jr.

The discussion explores collecting philosophies within the 90s market, including whether players should be collected in specific team uniforms (Griffey as an Athletic vs. Red, Peyton Manning as a Colt vs. Bronco, Randy Moss as a Viking vs. Patriot). David notes the value of defensive players and pitchers being underappreciated compared to offensive superstars. Jeremy emphasizes that the 90s era represents a unique collecting opportunity due to manufactured scarcity through limited print runs, creative card designs, and the vast number of iconic players available to collect. He argues that knowing 90s cards requires as much knowledge as understanding all sports cards from 1888-1992 combined.

Jeremy announces he's releasing a free audiobook version of 'Pops and Comps' across his YouTube and podcast channels starting November 8th, with six episodes covering nearly all of parts one and two. He's recorded himself reading the book in StreamYard rather than pursuing a formal audiobook production.

The episode also covers lighthearted commentary about Matt from Providence's repeated 'big timing' behavior—fabricating phone calls to escape conversations and sending fake positive testimonials about his Sports Cards Live appearance. They announce an upcoming episode on the Four Collectors channel filmed with Mike Petty and John 3D80s Kid, where Bob Bar substituted when Matt couldn't attend.

Key Insights

  • David Chase employs a systematic approach to entering the 1990s card market by ranking players by personal preference, researching comparable sales data in spreadsheets, and studying individual sets before making purchases—contrasting with Jeremy Lee's earlier impulsive $5,000 spending entry into the same market.
  • Jeremy Lee argues that understanding 1990s sports cards requires as much knowledge as understanding all sports cards produced from 1888 to 1992 combined, due to the complexity of numbered inserts, parallels, sets, and player availability.
  • Defensive players and pitchers in 1990s cards are significantly undervalued compared to offensive superstars—Roger Clemens cards cost thousands while Barry Bonds costs $100,000, despite Clemens arguably being equally accomplished, creating a collecting opportunity.
  • Jeremy Lee suggests that many valuable 1990s insert cards remain undiscovered in binders rather than destroyed, with potential for continual discovery over the next 20-30 years as estate collections surface, though population increases will likely occur slowly.
  • Jeremy Lee plans to release a free audiobook version of 'Pops and Comps' across YouTube and podcast channels as six consecutive daily episodes starting November 8th, reasoning that listeners may subsequently purchase physical copies as mementos or to get signed at card shows.

Topics

1990s Sports Card Market and Collecting StrategyToronto Expo Preparation and Collecting GoalsPlayer Selection Philosophy: Offensive vs Defensive PlayersCard Value and Rarity in Limited Print RunsTeam Uniform Preferences in Player CollectionsAudiobook Project for 'Pops and Comps'Matt from Providence and Show Participation

Transcript

[0:00] I got to big time you once in a while. >> Of course you are a big timer. We've been We've We've heard that before. >> Maybe we need some branded Sports Cars Live travel mugs. >> Yeah, we need another sponsor on Sports Cars Live. [laughter] >> You don't usually edit that. Well, >> I don't ever I don't ever do my own editing. That's why. >> That was a really good edit. >> Okay, thanks. >> Do I say let's do it or let's do this? What do I say? >> It Let's do it. >> Let's do it. Okay, >> let's do it. Are you ready to start this [0:32] show? >> Let's do it. [music]…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Clubhouse

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.