"Seth Meyers"
Seth Meyers joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his comedy career journey from Northwestern University through Second City, Saturday Night Live, and ultimately to hosting The Late Show. He reflects on how mentorship from Mike Shoemaker shaped his understanding of comedy writing and performing, and explains how his Update experience prepared him for late-night television.
Summary
Seth Meyers recounts his path to comedy, beginning at Northwestern where he discovered improv through the Meow troupe rather than pursuing his original film school goals. He worked as a server at the Twisted Lizard in Chicago while auditioning for Second City, eventually spending two transformative years at Boom Chicago in Amsterdam alongside future SNL writer/producer Peter Gross and Jason Sudeikis. This international experience provided crucial stage time and confidence before returning to audition for SNL.
Meyers describes struggling initially as an SNL cast member, feeling overshadowed by stronger performers like Will Ferrell, Tracy Morgan, and later Sudeikis and Hader. Mike Shoemaker, an SNL producer, provided pivotal career guidance: Meyers should focus on writing group sketches rather than solo vehicles, and should approach Update interviews with "patient and delighted" energy rather than frustration. When Tina Fey left to do 30 Rock and Amy Poehler was promoted to co-anchor Update, Meyers was reluctant to advocate for himself but did so when Lorne Michaels considered pairing him with another performer for his first solo Update, famously arguing that doing so would send the message that Michaels lacked confidence in him.
Meyers eventually became head writer of SNL, a position he describes as mostly delivering notes from Lorne to the writing staff while working alongside an exceptionally talented group of writers. He transitioned to The Late Show in 2014 after about three years away from SNL, poaching head writer Alex Bays from Weekend Update. Following Lorne's prediction that it would take 18 months to figure out his format, Meyers eventually abandoned the standing monologue in favor of starting the show at the desk—a decision that immediately felt correct.
Regarding current life, Meyers describes his relationship as going very well while acknowledging his learned reluctance to over-plan the future after experiencing many curveballs. He emphasizes the importance of laying a good foundation and surrounding himself with great people. During hiatus periods, he enjoys beach time with his three children (ages 10, 8, and nearly 5), and his father-in-law's motorboat. He watches substantial amounts of sports (primarily Steelers football, Red Sox baseball, and Liverpool FC) and recently finished the series Widow's Bay. The Late Show taping schedule at 4 PM allows significantly better work-life balance compared to SNL, with no post-mortems, just forward-looking focus on the next day's show. Meyers expresses genuine contentment with his work and confidence that avoiding boredom in his next career move will guide his path.
About this episode
Can I hear me? It’s the wonderful Seth Meyers. Irons in the fire, squirrel in parentheses, and accepting the cookies. “You can’t put a price on a smile,” … on an all-new SmartLess.
Key Insights
- Meyers argues that pursuing entertainment requires complete commitment without backup plans, as having a safety net prevents the desperation necessary to take any available job and build experience.
- Meyers credits Mike Shoemaker's advice to write group sketches where he could 'score a fifth of the laughs' rather than struggle carrying solo sketches, fundamentally shifting his SNL strategy from performer to writer.
- Meyers explains that his initial instinct to play Update segments with frustration toward incompetent guests was reframed by Shoemaker to instead play with patience and delight, which resonated better with audiences.
- Meyers describes that it took 18 months on The Late Show before discovering his format by eliminating the standing monologue and starting at the desk, at which point he immediately recognized 'this is it.'
- Meyers claims that his SNL head writer title is the accomplishment he's proudest of, despite the role primarily involving translating Lorne Michaels' notes to an already exceptional writing staff.
- Meyers contends that his daily late-night format is more sustainable for family life than SNL's weekly cycle, with 4 PM tapings and no post-mortems, forcing focus on future shows rather than ruminating on mistakes.
- Meyers states he no longer believes in detailed five-year plans after experiencing numerous career curveballs, preferring instead to focus on laying a foundation and handling whatever comes next.
- Meyers observes that international experience at Boom Chicago provided essential stage hours and confidence that domestic Chicago improv venues could not have offered during the same timeframe.
Topics
Transcript
This episode is brought to you by Hilton, the official hotel partner of the Big Ten. Every college football weekend, fired-up fans hit the road with their lucky shirts, pre-game rituals with family and friends, and oddly specific traditions. Good thing Hilton's unmatched hospitality and unrivaled service is ready for all your superstitions. hospitality, and unrivaled service is ready for all your superstitions. So, if you really want to swing the odds in your favor this season, make Hilton a part of your game day tradition. When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton for this day. With fall fast approaching, Whole Foods Market has you covered for…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from SmartLess
"Benny Blanco"
Benny Blanco joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his journey from a kid in Virginia cold-calling record labels to becoming one of pop music's most successful producers and songwriters. He credits his success to relentless hustle, networking, and a willingness to learn on the job while working with titans like Dr. Luke and Max Martin, ultimately landing hits for artists like Britney Spears, Rihanna, and Ed Sheeran.
"RE-RELEASE: Matthew Rhys"
Matthew Rhys, a Welsh actor known for The Americans and Perry Mason, joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his career trajectory from theater to television, his relationship with Kerry Russell, and his experience working with Robert Downey Jr. on the Perry Mason reboot. The conversation touches on his Welsh heritage, early theater experiences, and the challenges of balancing family life with demanding acting careers.
"Sharon Horgan"
Sharon Horgan joins the SmartLess podcast to discuss her career trajectory from working in employment services to becoming an acclaimed writer, producer, and performer. She shares insights about the creative process, challenges with auditioning, managing actors' interpretations of her writing, and her upcoming HBO series Youth premiering September 20th.
"Andrew Garfield"
Andrew Garfield joins the SmartLess podcast to discuss his acting career, upcoming projects including The Uprising and playing Sam Altman in an AI film, and shares deeply personal stories about his relationship with his father, grief, and the transformative power of theater and community in his life.
"Steve Zahn"
Steve Zahn joins the SmartLess podcast to discuss his career spanning theater, film, and television, his life on a farm in Kentucky, and his various projects including Chad Powers season 2 and the film She Dances. The hosts explore his path from Minnesota to success, his work with renowned directors, and his philosophy on acting and preparation.