What Does A Marine Think About War With Iran?
A Marine veteran of three Iraq tours draws parallels between the current open conflict with Iran and the failures of the 2003 Iraq War. He argues that without clear objectives and a defined endgame, the U.S. risks repeating past mistakes of regime change without a viable nation-building plan. He contends that lasting change in Iran must come from within the country itself.
Summary
A Marine who served three tours in Iraq — including the invasion, Fallujah, and the Ramadi Corridor — reflects on the current state of open war with Iran. He notes that throughout his service, Iran's Quds Force was indirectly fighting American forces by arming Shia militias, meaning the U.S. has effectively been in a proxy conflict with Iran for two decades.
He warns that the current approach mirrors the flawed playbook used in the 2003 Iraq War, describing it as 'taking the playbook off the shelf, blowing the dust off, and playing the same hits.' His central criticism is the absence of clear objectives and a defined endgame — the same strategic vacuum that plagued the Iraq campaign, where forces raced to Baghdad, toppled the regime, and had no plan for what came next. He uses the vivid analogy of a dog catching a car to describe this phenomenon.
On the question of regime change in Iran, he argues that a free Iran cannot be manufactured from the outside. Drawing on the painful lessons of Iraq and Afghanistan, he emphasizes that externally imposed nation-building has repeatedly failed, costing enormous amounts of American blood and treasure for outcomes that the target countries 'couldn't or wouldn't' sustain themselves. He concludes that any genuine revolution in Iran must be born and driven from within.
Key Insights
- The veteran argues that the current U.S. approach to war with Iran is a near-identical repeat of the 2003 Iraq War playbook, warning that the same strategic mistakes are being made again.
- He points out that the U.S. has effectively been fighting Iran for two decades through proxies, as Iran's Quds Force was arming Shia militias that killed Marines throughout his tours in Iraq.
- He criticizes the lack of defined objectives in the current conflict with Iran, directly mirroring the Iraq War failure where forces toppled the regime but had no plan for what came next.
- Using the analogy of a dog catching a car, he argues that U.S. military campaigns consistently achieve their tactical goals but fail catastrophically at the strategic level due to the absence of post-victory planning.
- He contends that a free Iran cannot be imposed from the outside, arguing that any successful revolution must be born and sustained from within, citing Iraq and Afghanistan as evidence that externally driven nation-building fails.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Three tours in Iraq, the invasion, Fallujah, the Ramadi Corridor. The whole time Iran's Quds Force was arming the Shia militias killing Marines. You fought Iran through proxies for [music] two decades. Now we're openly at war with them. What are you saying that American people are not? I think that we have taken the playbook off the shelf from 2003, blown the dust off of it, and are playing the same hits. What if we did not have to commit thousands of troops to something that we don't really know what the end game is. What are the [0:30] objectives inside [music] of this? What were the objectives for Iraq? We raced to Baghdad, toppled the regime, and…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Shawn Ryan Show
He Hands Uber Drivers His Leg 😂
A person with one leg shares humorous observations about the social advantages of their disability, including using it as a conversation starter in bars and as a novelty prop during Uber rides.
Wynonna Judd's Husband Heard a Voice Telling Him to Die 😨
Wynonna Judd's husband describes a harrowing near-death experience where he heard a voice urging him to jump into a waterfall and surrender to death. He distinguishes between what he perceived as a divine struggle to survive and a demonic voice trying to convince him to let go, a battle that lasted through the night until morning.
Shawn Ryan Gives a Country Legend a SIG Rattler 300 Blackout 😳
Shawn Ryan presents a SIG Sauer Rattler in 300 Blackout to a country legend, explaining its specifications and comparing it to similar weapons that will be equipped by the sheriff's office where someone named Elijah works. The recipient expresses initial fear of the weapon but shows willingness to overcome that fear by shooting it.
The Hardest Goodbye Wynonna Judd Ever Had To Say 😔
Wynonna Judd recalls the devastating day she received news of her mother's death on April 30th. After being urgently summoned to her mother's house by their life coach, she arrived to find emergency services present and learned of the death from a hospital staff member who didn't realize she hadn't been informed yet.
Shawn Ryan Gives a Country Legend a SIG Rattler 300 Blackout 😳
Shawn Ryan presents a SIG Sauer Adler 300 Blackout rifle to a country music legend, explaining its features and comparing it to equipment being procured for a sheriff's department. The recipient expresses initial fear of firearms but shows willingness to overcome that hesitation.