The Staten Island Problem - Part 2: A New Map
This episode of Revisionist History explores Staten Island's secession movement of the 1980s-90s, tracing how the Supreme Court's ruling on the Board of Estimate—which stripped Staten Island of its disproportionate political power—triggered a grassroots movement led by activist Dan Singletary and others who felt their island had been exploited as New York City's dumping ground and were seeking independence.
Summary
Ben Affleck, host of Revisionist History, investigates the Staten Island secession movement by examining archival VHS tapes and interviewing key figures. He discovers Dan Singletary, a mustached artist-activist who became the voice of secession, initially known only as 'an artist who wanted Staten Island to secede' but revealed through the tapes to be deeply concerned about asbestos in schools, the Fresh Kills landfill, and the island's poor treatment by the city.
The Fresh Kills landfill serves as the central symbol of Staten Island's grievances—processing 11,000 tons of garbage daily (expected to double to 22,000 tons), creating mountains potentially 500 feet high by 2000, visible from outer space, with seagulls numbering in the thousands. Staten Islanders would roll up car windows passing the dump and sprint from parking lots to stores. The landfill represented what New Yorkers thought of Staten Island: a place to dispose of unwanted things.
Beyond the dump, Singletary articulates multiple grievances: mismanaged schools with asbestos violations, poor infrastructure, homeless shelters concentrated at the ferry terminal where commuters felt harassed, cramped development, and a pervasive sense of disrespect that Singletary describes as constant 'sandpapering' of sensitivities. John Markey, a beloved island lawmaker, proposes a secession pathway: first a vote to study secession and create a charter, then a 1993 vote on the plan itself. Against odds, the state approves it.
Singletary's dining room becomes a 'war room' where he and Alice organize signature collection for an official secession party, with women verifying signatures while drinking beer and coffee. They collect thousands and present boxes to the Board of Elections.
The legal foundation for secession emerges from a Supreme Court case challenging the Board of Estimate structure. Since New York City's 1898 consolidation, five boroughs theoretically equal despite vastly different populations (Brooklyn: 2.2 million; Staten Island: 352,000) each held one vote on the Board of Estimate, which controlled the city's budget, land, and operations. The New York Civil Liberties Union sued, arguing this violated the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause and 'one person, one vote.' The city's lawyer warned the court that striking it down would cause New York to 'disintegrate' and Staten Island to secede.
The Supreme Court agreed with the ACLU. The system was unconstitutional—population should determine representation. This ruling stripped Staten Island of its disproportionate power just as the secession movement was building.
Bobby Scamardella, a local attorney and debate advocate for secession, frames the movement differently than structural complaints: he emphasizes emotional loss. He describes pre-bridge Staten Island (before 1964) as 'idyllic' with wooded areas where he played, then the shock of the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge opening the island to suburban sprawl and garbage trucks. Scamardella argues secession is about freedom—having 'no say over what happens in your community' regarding schools, police, fire departments. To a skeptic, he counters that nothing changes practically (people can still visit Broadway, work on Wall Street, attend Yankee games), but one gains autonomy.
The deeper insight is that secession sentiment stems from resentment about what was taken away (pre-bridge pastoral life) rather than justice for current mistreatment. One Staten Islander supposedly said the first act of an independent Staten Island should be to 'tear down the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge and let us go back to life the way it used to be.'
About this episode
<p>After the Supreme Court takes a close look at New York City government, Staten Island comes out the loser. A local artist begins organizing for secession. We take a deep dive into the psychology of the island, which has a lot to do with the largest garbage dump in the world.</p><p>See <a href="https://omnystudio.com/listener">omnystudio.com/listener</a> for privacy information.</p>
Key Insights
- Dan Singletary framed Staten Island's treatment by New York City as constant 'sandpapering of sensitivities'—an accumulation of disrespect regarding asbestos in schools, homeless shelters at ferry terminals, and the Fresh Kills landfill, rather than any single egregious event.
- The Fresh Kills landfill became the central symbol of the secession movement because it physically represented New York City's relationship to Staten Island: a place where unwanted things are disposed of and kept out of sight, with garbage piled potentially 500 feet high.
- The Supreme Court's ruling that the Board of Estimate structure violated the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause stripped Staten Island of the disproportionate political power it had held since 1898, directly triggering the acceleration of the secession movement.
- The secession movement was driven less by political injustice grievances than by nostalgia and resentment over what was perceived as lost—the pre-1964 pastoral, wooded landscape destroyed by the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge's opening to suburban sprawl and garbage trucks.
- Bobby Scamardella argued that secession was fundamentally about freedom and local autonomy over schools, police, and fire departments, emphasizing that practical access to Manhattan amenities would remain unchanged, making the issue about dignity and self-determination rather than material deprivation.
Topics
Transcript
Hey, this is J.R. Martinez, host of Medal of Honor Stories of Courage. Navy Federal Credit Union is celebrating America's 250th anniversary with exclusive $250 offers for new members. After being approved for membership online, select the special cash rewards offer and earn a $50 bonus when you open a cash rewards credit card, plus an additional $250 when you spend $2,500 within 90 days of opening. And you can get another $250 when you refinance2,500 within 90 days of opening. And you can get another $250 when you refinance your auto loan from another lender. Learn more and join today at NavyFederal.org slash America250. Offer ends July 31st, 2026. Excludes cash rewards, secure credit cards, and applications submitted by…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Revisionist History
Brian Lehrer and Malcolm Gladwell Talk Policing and Guns
Malcolm Gladwell discusses his book 'The American Way of Killing,' arguing that America's gun violence epidemic is a created problem distinct from peer nations, and that the country needs more police resources and community intervention programs rather than focusing solely on gun control. He contends the national conversation about gun violence is fundamentally dishonest, overlooking international comparisons and conflating different types of violence.
The Invention of an Epidemic
Malcolm Gladwell explores the true origins of the Second Amendment, arguing it was written by James Madison primarily to protect the militia system that Southern slave owners relied upon to control enslaved populations, not to guarantee individual gun rights. Through linguistic analysis and historical examination of the Stono Rebellion and Virginia's ratifying convention, Gladwell demonstrates how the Supreme Court's 2008 Heller decision misread the Amendment's grammar and ignored its actual purpose.
President Barack Obama & Malcolm Gladwell: How Reconstruction Still Defines America
President Barack Obama and Malcolm Gladwell discuss Reconstruction as a pivotal but ultimately incomplete attempt to establish multiracial democracy in America, arguing that its failure to transform hearts and minds left unresolved tensions that continue to shape contemporary debates over voting rights, education, and racial inequality.
A Dollop Crossover | Ben Naddaff-Hafrey on Staten Island and the Revolutionary War
A crossover episode between The Dollop and Revisionist History explores the extraordinary story of Colonel Christopher Billup and Staten Island's fierce loyalism during the American Revolution. Despite being a key British stronghold with unprecedented occupation lasting seven years, Staten Island's residents ultimately betrayed the cause they initially fought to preserve, revealing how external pressure and abuse transformed political allegiance.
The Fines
The Fines tells the story of families fighting to have unidentified remains from 9/11—sifted into 360,000-480,000 tons of dust at Fresh Kills landfill—removed from the dump and given a more dignified burial place. Despite a medical examiner's promise to identify all remains and years of activism by families like the Hornings, a judge ruled the unidentifiable mass of dirt had no constitutional protection, leaving the remains at Fresh Kills as the landfill was converted into a park.