Frankenfood | The Mistakes Series
This Revisionist History episode explores how naming and communication shape consumer acceptance of new food technologies, using the cautionary tale of GMOs in the 1990s and applying lessons to the emerging cultivated meat industry. Barbara Stuckey from Mattson, a food science lab, advocates for the term "cultivated meat" instead of "lab-grown meat" to avoid repeating the GMO backlash that devastated the Flavr Savr tomato.
Summary
Host Malcolm Gladwell sends Ben Natathoff to Mattson, a food science R&D facility in the Bay Area, to investigate how language and messaging affect consumer adoption of new food technologies. The episode centers on two interconnected mistakes: the first from the 1990s-2000s involving genetically modified organisms (GMOs), and the second a potential future mistake with cultivated meat technology.
The first mistake concerns Zeneca's Flavr Savr tomato, a genetically modified crop designed to solve real agricultural problems—tomatoes are naturally delicate and difficult to harvest at optimal ripeness, forcing farmers to pick them green and gas them with ethylene before sale. Zeneca partnered with Mattson to research consumer acceptance. Steve Gundrum, Mattson's former CEO, describes how focus groups initially responded positively to the tomato's taste and quality. However, when the term "genetically modified organism" (GMO) was introduced, combined with the media-coined term "frankenfood," consumer resistance solidified dramatically. The cultural reference point of Jurassic Park (1993) amplified fears about "playing God" with science. Despite the tomato's superiority, the Flavr Savr lost market share significantly and became unavailable in supermarkets, demonstrating how naming and framing can override product quality.
The second mistake involves the cultivated meat industry emerging in 2018. Barbara Stuckey attended a conference on lab-grown meat and experienced alarm—she recognized the same pattern repeating. Terms like "lab-grown meat" and "cell-based meat" foreground the science and novelty in ways that trigger resistance similar to GMO backlash. She rallied stakeholders to brainstorm alternative names, generating options like "nano-pastured meat," "unbounded meat," "slaughter-free," and "minimalist meat." The group settled on "cultivated meat," which suggests sophistication and intentional development without explicitly highlighting the laboratory or artificial aspects.
Ben Natathoff visited Upside Foods in Emeryville, where cultivated chicken meat is being produced in large stainless steel tanks using cells from a chicken egg. He tasted both a butter chicken samosa and buttermilk fried chicken sandwich made from cultivated meat and found them indistinguishable from conventional chicken. Erin Santee from Upside Foods emphasizes that "tasting is believing" and plans to introduce the product through restaurants rather than packaged goods, allowing consumers to experience cultivated meat in a controlled context before broader market introduction. The strategy differs from GMOs partly in how the product will be communicated and introduced to the public.
About this episode
<p>Would a tomato by any other name taste as sweet? What about a steak? Malcolm sends Ben on a mission to investigate the cutting edge of food technology and two mistakes: one from the 1990s and one that’s unfolding as we speak.</p> <p> </p><p>See <a href="https://omnystudio.com/listener">omnystudio.com/listener</a> for privacy information.</p>
Key Insights
- The Flavr Savr tomato solved genuine agricultural problems by enabling farmers to pick tomatoes at optimal ripeness rather than green, yet was destroyed by market rejection despite superior taste and quality.
- The term 'genetically modified organism' combined with 'frankenfood' created a perception that the product was fundamentally unnatural and dangerous, regardless of the actual science or benefits.
- Consumer resistance to GMOs stemmed partly from cultural context—Jurassic Park (1993) provided a reference point where scientific hubris creates monsters, making 'frankenfood' resonate as a dystopian fear.
- Focus group testing revealed that consumers pushed back specifically when learning that scientists in laboratories were modifying seeds genetically, as opposed to traditional agricultural breeding methods like grafting apple trees.
- Barbara Stuckey recognized the identical pattern emerging with cultivated meat and proactively attempted to prevent repetition by advocating for 'cultivated meat' terminology instead of 'lab-grown meat' or 'cell-based meat.'
- The term 'cultivated meat' obscures the novelty and laboratory origins while suggesting sophistication and intentional development, similar to 'cultivated person,' without misrepresenting the product.
- Upside Foods found that cultivated chicken meat tastes indistinguishable from conventional chicken when prepared by a skilled chef, but plans restaurant introduction rather than packaged goods to control the narrative experience.
- Cultivated meat has become a political and religious issue in some areas, with correlations between anti-abortion and anti-cultivated meat positions, suggesting the science taps into deeper ideological anxieties beyond food safety.
Topics
Transcript
We spend hours deciding what to buy, but there's a split-second decision that can make or break a sale. Do you have the trust to hit buy now? Agentic Commerce is testing that moment more than ever. And that's where PayPal comes in. With 25 years of checkouts, 400 million consumer accounts globally, and the benefit of purchase and seller protection, all of which make sure wherever a purchase starts, it ends with trust. Built for payments, growth, and agentic. PayPal Open, built for all business. Visit paypalopen.com. Purchase and seller protections on eligible transactions only. Terms apply. See paypal.com slash risk dash management for details. This is Tony Ayo from The Real Report with Tony Ayo and Uncle Murda.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Revisionist History
Reconstruction: The Unfinished Promise
This is the first episode of 'Reconstruction: The Unfinished Promise,' an eight-part podcast hosted by Malcolm Gladwell in collaboration with Barack Obama. The episode traces the post-Civil War Reconstruction era through the stories of Frederick Douglass, Andrew Johnson, and Carl Schurz, examining the political battles over Black citizenship, voting rights, and the reunification of the United States. It argues that Reconstruction was a pivotal, largely overlooked period whose successes and failures shaped American society for the next 150 years.
Revisited: Ms. Buchanan’s Period of Adjustment
Malcolm Gladwell revisits his Revisionist History episode 'Miss Buchanan's Period of Adjustment,' which examines the overlooked consequences of the Brown v. Board of Education decision. The episode argues that while Brown is celebrated as a civil rights victory, it inadvertently led to the mass firing of approximately 40,000 Black teachers across the South. Gladwell contends that the Supreme Court's framing of the case around psychological damage rather than structural inequality set the stage for this tragic and largely forgotten outcome.
Introducing The News from Scene on Radio
This is the first episode of Season 8 of 'Scene on Radio,' titled 'The News,' which examines the deep crisis in American news media. Hosts John Bewin and Chenjerai Kumunika explore why Americans distrust the media, how political sorting and identity drive news consumption, and why the 'echo chamber' narrative may be more myth than reality. The episode features interviews with a North Carolina farmer and media scholar Danigal Young to illuminate how survival instincts and group identity shape how people process information.
The Great American Elevator Tragedy | The Mistakes Series
Malcolm Gladwell explores why the United States has fewer elevators per capita than almost any other high-income country, tracing the problem to expensive labor practices, oversized elevator requirements, and a pivotal 2003-2004 building code amendment by Glendale, Arizona fire inspector Gregory A. Victor. The episode argues that well-intentioned pursuit of perfection — making elevators larger to accommodate stretchers — made them so expensive that developers routinely skip them in smaller and affordable apartment buildings.