On the Media: American Emergency
This Radiolab episode features excerpts and discussion from On The Media's four-part series 'American Emergency' about FEMA, exploring the agency's origins in Cold War civil defense, its troubled history of dysfunction and conspiracy theories, and its current existential threat under the Trump administration. Reporter Micah Lowinger traces how FEMA went from a well-intentioned disaster relief agency to one of America's most mistrusted government institutions. The episode culminates with the story of interim FEMA head Cameron Hamilton, who was fired after testifying against abolishing the agency, only to be renominated by Trump a year later.
Summary
The episode opens with a Radiolab fundraising appeal before transitioning to a discussion between host Latif Nasser and On The Media co-host Micah Lowinger about a four-part investigative series on FEMA. The series examines how an agency with a pure mission — helping Americans in crisis — became one of the most distrusted and conspiracy-laden institutions in the federal government.
The first major segment covers FEMA's origins, beginning with a 1974 plane crash that inadvertently revealed Mount Weather, a massive covert Cold War bunker designed to house the U.S. government during nuclear war. This secret facility was operated by FEMA's predecessor, the Federal Civil Defense Administration. The episode details how FEMA was formally created in 1979 under President Carter as a consolidation of five federal emergency agencies, born partly from frustration by state governors who needed a single federal point of contact during disasters.
Under Reagan, FEMA was captured by Cold War paranoia under director Louis Giaffrida, who secretly redirected most of the agency's budget toward nuclear civil defense rather than natural disaster relief. More darkly, Giaffrida had written a master's thesis about using military detention to suppress race riots, and worked with Oliver North on classified plans — Project 908 — for declaring martial law and operating a shadow government during national crises. These plans involved the FBI secretly scouting warehouses, Walmarts, and other facilities as potential detention centers. These revelations, partially exposed during the Iran-Contra hearings, seeded the FEMA camp conspiracy theories that persist to this day on the far right.
The episode traces how those conspiracy theories evolved from fringe militia movements in the 1990s — including Linda Thompson's documentary and later amplification by Alex Jones and Glenn Beck — into mainstream political discourse. Ironically, the series notes that while these theories were false for decades, the Trump administration actually used FEMA funds to help finance migrant detention facilities, including Florida's 'Alligator Alcatraz,' representing what Micah calls 'the most real FEMA camp ever built.'
The discussion then turns to FEMA's recent crisis under the second Trump administration. After Hurricane Helene in 2024, Trump spread misinformation about FEMA diverting funds to migrants, leading to violent threats against FEMA workers. This chaos culminated in Trump publicly suggesting abolishing FEMA just days after his inauguration. The episode features detailed reporting on interim FEMA head Cameron Hamilton — a Navy SEAL turned MAGA political operative with no traditional emergency management experience — who navigated an extraordinary period of internal dysfunction, including polygraph tests ordered by DHS for suspected leakers, pressure from Corey Lewandowski and Secretary Kristi Noem to draft abolishment plans, and ultimately his own firing after he testified before Congress that eliminating FEMA was not in the American people's interest. In a remarkable twist, Trump later nominated Hamilton to return as FEMA's permanent, Senate-confirmed administrator. The episode concludes with Micah observing that FEMA has historically been the agency where American leaders deposit their worst fears — nuclear war, terrorism, immigration — at the expense of its core natural disaster mission, and that a deep cultural distrust of government may be too large for the agency to overcome regardless of its actual performance.
About this episode
A little while back, our friends over at On the Media released a gripping and immersive reporting series about FEMA, the agency that is supposed to be there for all of us in the wake of disaster. In American Emergency, OTM investigates how the agency tasked with saving America became distrusted, despised… and defunded.Today we talk to On the Media co-host Micah Loewinger about how this project came out, what reporting went into making it happen, and play a couple of fun and truly surprising bits of the story that the OTM team uncovered. And it’s a story that highlights the ideal and promise of good government, right alongside the frustration with bureaucracy and mismanagement, and of course the undercurrent of profound mistrust in governmental power. As natural disasters are getting more extreme and less predictable, this series makes sense of that tangle, and provides a prescient peek into FEMA’s future. Special thanks to On the Media. To hear Micah in person, talking more about the complex history of FEMA, join him on June 24th at WNYC's The Greene Space (https://wnyc.org/events/otm-fema). Signup for our newsletter!! It includes short essays, recommendations, and details about other ways to interact with the show. Sign up (https://radiolab.org/newsletter)! Radiolab is supported by listeners like you. Support Radiolab by becoming a member of The Lab (https://members.radiolab.org/) today. Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @radiolab, and share your thoughts with us by emailing [email protected]. Leadership support for Radiolab’s science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
Key Insights
- Micah Lowinger argues that FEMA's conspiracy theory problem is not purely fabricated — it has a 'germ of truth' rooted in real classified programs like Project 908, where the FBI secretly scouted private businesses as potential post-nuclear detention facilities without the owners' knowledge.
- Lowinger contends that Trump effectively weaponized FEMA's distrust in a two-step process: spreading lies about FEMA during Hurricane Helene that caused workers to fear for their safety, then using the resulting worker misconduct (skipping Trump-supporting homes) as apparent proof of the original lie during Hurricane Milton.
- Retired FEMA official Leo Bosner argues that Cold War-era leadership at FEMA was so consumed by nuclear civil defense theater that natural disaster preparedness was effectively abandoned, with the result that the agency was dangerously underprepared for predictable domestic catastrophes.
- Journalist Garrett Graff argues that FEMA's inherent secrecy around classified continuity-of-government operations makes it structurally impossible for the agency to debunk conspiracy theories, because acknowledging the classified programs required to refute the theories would itself be a national security violation.
- Cameron Hamilton revealed that DHS Secretary Kristi Noem's primary interest in abolishing FEMA was rebranding rather than substantive reform — she enthusiastically embraced a name change to NOEM (National Office of Emergency Management) as a way to claim political credit for 'abolishing' FEMA without actually dismantling its functions.
- Hamilton described Noem and Lewandowski as having a 'general lack of understanding' of what FEMA actually does, which he said necessitated a basic briefing meeting about the agency's functions before any reform discussions could even begin.
- Lowinger argues that each presidential administration has effectively reprogrammed FEMA around its dominant national fear — nuclear war under Reagan, terrorism after 9/11, and immigration under Trump 2.0 — each time at the direct expense of the agency's natural disaster mission.
- The series found that Trump's use of FEMA funds to finance migrant detention centers like 'Alligator Alcatraz' represents an ironic historical inversion: the far-right conspiracy theories about FEMA camps were false for decades, but a right-wing government elected partly on those conspiracy theories actually implemented a version of them against immigrants.
Topics
Transcript
Hey friends, Lulu here. I have been working in public radio for over 20 years. I feel so lucky to get to do this job. And this is a moment unlike any other. Nearly a year ago, Congress eliminated our federal funding and so many of you stepped up to support Radiolab at that time. Thank you. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts. Thank you. But the truth is, we just aren't out of the woods yet. There's no sign of federal funding coming back. And New York Public Radio, our home station, is currently facing an ongoing shortfall of nearly $3 million. And so I'm coming to you to ask for support. We see you. We make…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Radiolab
Return of Alpha Gal
A RadioLab episode explores how Amy Pearl developed a sudden allergy to red meat after a tick bite, discovering the culprit is alpha-gal, a sugar found in non-primate mammals. The episode then updates listeners on how this discovery led to the creation of genetically modified GalSafe pigs that can provide organs for transplant and safe meat for alpha-gal allergy sufferers.
Neither Confirm Nor Deny
Radiolab explores the origins and consequences of the phrase "neither confirm nor deny," tracing it to a 1975 CIA response about a covert Cold War submarine recovery mission. The phrase has since become ubiquitous across government agencies and popular culture, creating legal and transparency challenges that can delay public accountability for years.
The Holy Shiver
Radiolab investigates goosebumps, exploring how this vestigial survival reflex evolved from a thermoregulation mechanism in mammals to trigger aesthetic chills in response to music, art, and emotionally meaningful experiences. Scientists Nico Regensi and Felix Schöller have developed methods to reliably induce chills in laboratory settings and are studying their potential therapeutic applications for depression.
Atomic Artifacts
Radiolab explores a secret Cold War-era government project to preserve artifacts that would survive nuclear apocalypse, then asks modern Americans what items should represent American identity in a post-catastrophic future. The episode examines what objects and values truly define America.
The Gondolier
This Radiolab episode tells the story of Alex Hay, a transgender man who became internationally known as the first female gondolier in Venice's 900-year history, only to later publicly transition and face severe discrimination. The episode explores how Alex's identity was hijacked by media narratives and feminist movements, leading to his eventual loss of livelihood and a six-year period of homelessness and depression before finding stability in Berlin.