Access Deep Places
A rabbi delivers a philosophical discourse on accessing deeper spiritual spaces within oneself, particularly addressing the tension between personal inner work and responsibility toward others. He uses examples from Torah study, emotions like jealousy and anger, and the concept of Arevut (collective responsibility) to argue that humans have an innate neshama (soul) designed to give and connect with others, not merely survive selfishly.
Summary
The speaker opens by discussing the subtlety of studying Torah, using jealousy as a primary example. He argues that merely shaming oneself for feeling jealous doesn't eliminate the emotion—it only creates denial. Instead, he proposes that there exists a deeper psychological and spiritual space within each person that transcends these surface emotions. He illustrates this with the concept that we are 'very big' internally and our jealousy or anger represents only 'little parts' of ourselves.
The rabbi then transitions to a fundamental question about human nature: are people inherently selfish or giving? He observes that some see the world as entirely selfish, interpreting even kindness as self-serving. However, he argues that humans are born with a neshama (soul) that is inherently godly and designed to give. He provides evidence through observation: young children start selfish, but as they mature and especially when they become parents, they naturally access deeper spaces of generosity and sacrifice.
A significant portion addresses the difference between therapy and Torah learning. Therapy validates who a person currently is; Torah study, through a Rebbe, should guide people toward deeper spaces within themselves that already exist. The speaker emphasizes this is a journey, not instant transformation—accessing faith and deeper spiritual spaces takes time.
The core teaching involves Parashat Nitzavim and the concept of Arevut (collective responsibility among Jews). He explains the halachic principle of Shemaya K'einah (hearing is like saying) in the context of Kiddush and other mitzvot, which leads to discussion about how we are deeply connected to one another. The speaker argues that ignoring other people is actually ignoring part of oneself.
Critically, the rabbi addresses a tension he previously held: early in his yeshiva's existence, he emphasized elder students' responsibility for younger ones, but he later backed away, fearing codependence. He now returns to this emphasis, clarifying the distinction. Codependence is when someone gives to others to avoid dealing with their own issues. Healthy giving comes from a genuine, deeper place—not forced obligation. He distinguishes between 'note to self' superficial changes and accessing authentic inner spaces (using gratitude as an example: real gratitude isn't remembering to say thank you, but tapping into an actual grateful place within).
The speaker uses the concept from Reb Chaim Volozhiner that humans were created to give to others, interpreting this not as negating self-care but as recognizing our fundamental nature. He argues that when people ignore their responsibility to others, they actually diminish themselves. He advocates for a balanced approach: individuals should do their own spiritual and psychological work while also naturally engaging with and caring for others in ways authentic to their personality.
The transcript ends with welcomes to new and returning students and the singing of spiritual songs, suggesting the beginning of a new academic year at a yeshiva.
About this episode
<p>Rabbi Kalish </p>
Key Insights
- The speaker argues that shaming oneself for negative emotions like jealousy creates denial rather than resolution; the actual solution is accessing a deeper psychological space within oneself that exists beyond the emotion.
- He claims that humans begin life as inherently selfish (observing young children fighting over possessions) but possess an innate neshama designed to give, which becomes accessible through maturity and circumstances like parenthood.
- The speaker distinguishes between therapy, which validates who a person currently is, and Torah learning with a Rebbe, which should guide individuals toward discovering deeper, more authentic spaces already existing within them.
- He argues that gratitude is not a behavioral practice of saying 'thank you' but rather accessing an actual deep space of appreciation within oneself, suggesting that genuine spiritual change involves discovering existing inner states rather than forcing external behaviors.
- The speaker contends that completely ignoring other people and their needs actually represents a form of self-destruction, claiming that according to Chazal (Jewish sages), a selfish person destroys their own neshama.
- He presents a nuanced view that codependence—giving to others while avoiding one's own issues—is unhealthy, but this does not negate the fundamental human design to give and connect with others authentically.
- The speaker argues that the world of Torah is fundamentally about accessing deeper places within oneself, and that a Rebbe's role differs from a therapist's in that the Rebbe should point toward these deeper spaces rather than merely validating current emotional states.
- He claims that people who refuse to engage with others or acknowledge connections (saying 'my father is irrelevant to my life' or 'God is irrelevant') are denying reality, not transcending it, similar to how saying 'I'm not angry' doesn't eliminate anger.
Topics
Transcript
I want to speak to the guys about a topic that I think is deep. I'm not like, oh, this is deep. I don't care if it's shallow, deep. I'm not like the raider. You could raid. It's not like a trick. I'm just asking. The only reason I'm saying it's deep, I'm asking you to listen. It's subtle is really what I want to say in the tunnel. Gabriel, I want guys guys if i could have if if a guy can't focus it's good to i like you anyway if a guy could try i'm telling you something subtle if you want if you'll hear it i want i want to learn something that i think is is…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Rabbi Daniel Kalish Shiurim - Waterbury Mesivta
Yimei Selichos - [Archives]
A Yimei Selichos sermon exploring the power of belief and intention in spiritual practice, the importance of blessings and genuine repentance, and the significance of good beginnings as we approach the High Holidays. The speaker emphasizes that faith gives spiritual concepts their power, that all Jews have the ability to bless others, and that authentic repentance comes from a place of genuine love for God rather than fear of punishment.
Impossible?? Or Simple??
A Rosh Yeshiva addresses the apparent paradox in Parashat Nitzavim where Moses says Torah is not impossible but easy, examining this unusual rhetorical formulation through the lens of accessing deeper spiritual spaces within the human soul, relating it to experiences of personal growth like parenthood and marriage.
The Deep Spaces of The Torah - Parshas Nitzavim Vayelech - Blue Ridge Mishmar
A Torah discussion on Parshas Nitzavim exploring how the mitzvah of Torah study reveals deep spiritual spaces within ourselves that connect us to God. The speaker argues that what initially seems distant or impossible becomes accessible through dedicated engagement with Torah, using examples of personal transformation, parenthood, and the struggle between selfishness and generosity.
Access Deep Places
A rabbi explores the concept of accessing deeper emotional and spiritual spaces within oneself, particularly regarding jealousy, selflessness, and communal responsibility. He emphasizes that learning Torah and genuine personal growth involve moving beyond surface-level denial of negative emotions to accessing profound places within where authentic giving and connection naturally emerge.
Hi, What’s your name again?
A yeshiva lecture exploring a complex Talmudic passage about standing for Torah scholars versus those performing the mitzvah of Bikurim, ultimately arguing that respecting people and knowing their names reflects valuing their inherent significance and dignity.