CleanShot just got a big update (new video editor and studio mode)
CleanShot released a major update featuring a new video editor and studio mode, which the community largely received positively. However, discussions revealed mixed reactions, with some praising the addition as overdue while others noted it appears derivative of ScreenStudio and questioned how it differentiates from existing alternatives.
Summary
The original post announces CleanShot's significant update introducing video editing and studio mode capabilities, presented via a video demonstration. The post received modest engagement (40 upvotes, 100% ratio) with limited but substantive commentary.
Community reception was cautiously positive. Several commenters acknowledged the update as visually appealing and long-needed for the platform. However, a notable counterargument emerged regarding originality: u/maxanatsko criticized the implementation as a "complete copy off ScreenStudio," suggesting it lacks differentiation through features like camera layouts. This criticism prompted u/inquirermanredux's more dismissive take that ScreenStudio is now obsolete, indicating potential feature parity or superiority in at least some areas.
Technical questions dominated the secondary comments, reflecting user priorities: u/oleksii-s asked about overlay annotations and text capabilities, u/Nerve_Present questioned how it differs from QuickTime (suggesting uncertainty about competitive advantages), and u/AggravatingAd2438 inquired about pricing/free access. These questions suggest the community is evaluating practical utility and value proposition rather than accepting the update at face value. The sparse engagement and brief comment lengths indicate this discussion did not generate substantial debate despite touching on competitive positioning questions.
Key Insights
- u/maxanatsko noted the feature appears to replicate ScreenStudio's functionality without clear differentiation, specifically identifying missing camera layout options as a gap
- Multiple commenters (u/Nerve_Present, u/AggravatingAd2438) raised practical questions about how CleanShot's new tools differ from and compare to existing solutions like QuickTime, indicating the community requires clarity on competitive advantages before adoption
- u/inquirermanredux's dismissive reaction toward ScreenStudio suggests some users perceive CleanShot's update as achieving feature parity or superiority, though other commenters disagreed with this assessment
Topics
Transcript
[Original Post] (score: 40, upvote ratio: 100%, by u/magiera) Title: CleanShot just got a big update (new video editor and studio mode) Link: https://v.redd.it/qmsslwuqhxmh1 [Comment] (score: 3, u/skitchin70) Looks nice! [Comment] (score: 3, u/inquirermanredux) ScreenStudio can go die in a corner now. [Comment] (score: 1, u/Mstormer) Well overdue, too. [Comment] (score: 1, u/maxanatsko) That looks like complete copy off ScreenStudio. I just wish they went a step further and at least introduced camera layouts. [Comment] (score: 1, u/Nerve_Present) How it is different from quick time. [Comment] (score: 1, u/oleksii-s) Is it possible to add overlay annotations/ text? [Comment] (score: 1, u/AggravatingAd2438) Is it free?
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from r/macapps
[OS] Wisp — a tiny macOS scratchpad that opens with ⌥Space and gets out of the way
A developer shared Wisp, a free minimal macOS scratchpad app that opens with ⌥Space for quick note-taking without organizational friction. The community responded positively, with early users praising its responsiveness, though commenters noted it exists in a crowded space of similar tools like AntiNote, Stik, and Slidejot. Key feature requests included customizable shortcuts and an iOS companion app.
6 sticky note apps later and I'm starting to think the perfect one is a myth - HELP
A macOS user frustrated after trying six sticky note apps asks Reddit for recommendations, detailing specific requirements around floating visibility, rich text formatting, and a persistent toolbar. The community offered several app suggestions but largely acknowledged that no single app perfectly satisfies all the listed requirements, with some developers even reaching out to build a solution.