6 sticky note apps later and I'm starting to think the perfect one is a myth - HELP
A macOS user frustrated after trying six sticky note apps asks Reddit for recommendations, detailing specific requirements around floating visibility, rich text formatting, and a persistent toolbar. The community offered several app suggestions but largely acknowledged that no single app perfectly satisfies all the listed requirements, with some developers even reaching out to build a solution.
Summary
The original poster, u/Cultural-Earth-5198, laid out a detailed and self-aware request for a macOS sticky note app that floats above all windows, looks modern, supports rich text formatting (headers, bold, italic, bullets, checklists, and color highlighting), and offers a always-visible toolbar rather than relying on keyboard shortcuts. They had already ruled out six apps — native Apple Stickies (ugly, limited), Glassnote (plain text only), Tot (7-note cap, no headers), a third-party Stickies app (shortcut-heavy), Antinote (hidden toolbar, no font picker), and Raycast Notes (no color highlighting) — each failing on at least one key requirement.
The community responded with a mix of app suggestions, philosophical pushback, and developer interest. Several apps were recommended including Stickier, Noticky, Floaters, Lucid Notes, and Stik, with multiple developers showing up in the thread to promote their own tools or express willingness to build something better. Notably, u/isolume offered to build a free app tailored to these needs and invited collaboration, which drew interest from other community members as well.
Some commenters pushed back on the premise. u/Aritra7777 argued that the three most-wanted properties — always-on-top visibility, zero RAM overhead, and cross-device sync — are fundamentally incompatible and that users must pick two. u/audexdev similarly suggested the 'annoying answer' is to use two separate apps, since rich text editing and always-on-top floating tend to conflict in practice on macOS. One commenter suggested combining any preferred text editor with a floating utility like Floaty as a workaround.
The broader community largely sympathized with the original poster's frustrations, with several noting they shared the same unmet needs. The thread ended without a clear winning recommendation, underscoring a genuine gap in the macOS app ecosystem for a sticky note tool that combines aesthetics, formatting depth, and persistent desktop visibility.
Key Insights
- u/Aritra7777 argued that always-on-top visibility, zero RAM overhead, and cross-device sync are fundamentally incompatible, and that users realistically can only have two of the three — reframing the search as a prioritization problem rather than a product gap.
- u/audexdev suggested the rich text editing and always-on-top floating requirements inherently conflict on macOS, recommending two separate apps as the practical solution rather than searching for a single perfect tool.
- Multiple developers — including u/isolume, u/RicoSaas, u/mjdth, and u/SardorbekR — independently showed up in the thread to promote their own apps or offer to build something tailored to the poster's needs, signaling that this is a recognized and commercially interesting gap in the market.
- The original poster's specific dealbreaker with Antinote — that its toolbar hides unless hovered over — highlights how interaction design details like toolbar persistence can be as important as feature availability itself for certain workflows.
- u/miklosp proposed a workaround of pairing any preferred text editor with a floating utility like Floaty, illustrating a broader pattern where macOS power users solve app gaps by combining multiple single-purpose tools rather than finding an all-in-one solution.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access