You Can See Everything
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes, exploring how the film presents her story through unconventional methods including reenactments with actress Amanda Seyfried. The panelists debate whether the film is genuinely a documentary, how it handles the truth about Holmes' crimes, and the ethical implications of Fielder's filmmaking approach.
Summary
The episode opens with discussion of "You Can See Everything," a three-hour documentary about Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and her partner Billy Evans, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. Holmes was incarcerated for defrauding investors of hundreds of millions of dollars through false claims about a blood-testing machine. The filmmakers connected with Holmes and Evans shortly before her imprisonment and initially filmed them at home with their children before Fielder moved in with the family.
In the first half of the film, panelist Bob Mondello praised it as unusual and wonderful, noting it felt less generic than other recent tech-mogul documentaries. Ronald Young Jr. appreciated how Fielder's questioning style—asking uncomfortable "why" questions—created an unsettling atmosphere that prompted genuine answers. However, Linda Holmes, an Elizabeth Holmes expert who has read extensively about the case, expressed concern that the documentary is misleading because it omits crucial context about specific fraudulent claims Holmes made (like military contracts), presenting her instead as "fascinatingly unknowable" rather than addressing documented falsehoods.
The panelists discussed a key scene where Holmes watches "Who's on First?" and doesn't understand the comedy bit. Fielder theorizes this suggests Holmes is extremely literal, potentially explaining her statements as misunderstandings rather than lies. Linda Holmes pushed back, arguing that extensive reporting already establishes whether Holmes lied, making Fielder's framing of her as unknowable incomplete and misleading.
The second half of the film becomes increasingly unconventional. After Holmes goes to prison, Fielder's relationship with Billy Evans becomes contentious as Evans appears controlling and potentially manipulative, wielding power of attorney over Holmes and interfering with filming. In a major departure from traditional documentary, Fielder collaborates with actress Amanda Seyfried to conduct reenactments and speculate about Holmes and Evans' relationship. The panelists debated whether these scenes were scripted, semi-scripted, or spontaneous, creating uncertainty about what constitutes the documentary's factual basis.
The panelists discussed whether the film qualifies as a documentary given its unconventional methods. They referenced other documentaries using reenactments (like "Four Daughters" and "The Act of Killing") but expressed discomfort with not understanding what rules Fielder applied to his work or what he explicitly claims is unscripted. Linda Holmes noted the film ends ambiguously, seemingly sympathetic to Holmes while suggesting Fielder may have developed feelings for her, ultimately shrugging about whether he's been too easy on her or discovered something true.
About this episode
About a month before Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes went to prison for defrauding her investors, she and her partner Billy Evans invited a film crew to document their lives at home with their kids. And they didn't make a deal with a conventional filmmaking team. They connected with Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. Fielder’s unusual nonfiction work blurs the lines between truth and artifice, so the resulting documentary, <em>You Can See Everything</em>, depicts Fielder's efforts to figure her out using some very unusual methods. <br /><br /><strong>Check out these episodes next:</strong><br /><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2026/09/25/nx-s1-5979909/primetime-sits-you-down-with-sleaze" target="_blank">‘Primetime’ sits you down with sleaze</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2022/08/23/1119071898/the-rehearsal-is-about-reality-and-surreality" target="_blank">'The Rehearsal' is about reality... and surreality</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2022/02/24/1082841597/the-dropout-finds-the-voice-of-elizabeth-holmes" target="_blank">'The Dropout' finds the voice of Elizabeth Holmes</a><br /><br />Connect with Pop Culture Happy Hour:<br /><a href="https://letterboxd.com/nprpopculture/" target="_blank">Letterboxd</a> / <a href="https://www.facebook.com/pchh" target="_blank">Facebook</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/newsletter/pop-culture" target="_blank">Our weekly newsletter</a><br />Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening. Learn more at <a href="http://plus.npr.org/" target="_blank">plus.npr.org</a>.<br /><br />See <a href="https://pcm.adswizz.com">pcm.adswizz.com</a> for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.<br /><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy">NPR Privacy Policy</a>
Key Insights
- Linda Holmes argues that by omitting extensive reporting about specific false claims Holmes made, the film misleadingly presents her as 'fascinatingly unknowable' when the facts about her dishonesty are already documented and knowable.
- Nathan Fielder theorizes that Holmes' misstatements may stem from extreme literalism rather than intentional lying, based on her not understanding a 'Who's on First?' comedy bit, but this explanation doesn't account for documented false claims about military contracts.
- The panelists expressed uncertainty about whether scenes involving actress Amanda Seyfried were scripted, semi-scripted, or spontaneous, creating fundamental confusion about what the documentary represents as factual.
- Bob Mondello notes that Fielder's work is persuasive in the moment but creates persistent questions afterward, making viewers doubt whether they can trust what they're seeing, which throws the documentary's credibility into question.
- Ronald Young Jr. argues that unlike other tech mogul documentaries that clearly take down their subjects, this film's ambiguity about Fielder's perspective on Holmes could allow her to claim she's being treated unfairly by the filmmakers.
Topics
Transcript
This podcast is supported by Carvana, who would like to share the idea that buying your next car can be as easy as ordering anything else online. Browse, finance, and buy, all on Carvana.com. About a month before, Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes went to prison for defrauding her investors, she and her partner, Billy Evans, invited a film crew to document their lives at home with their kids. And they didn't make a deal with a conventional documentarian. They connected with Nathan Fielder, whose unusual nonfiction work blurs the lines between truth and artifice. The resulting documentary, You Can See Everything, is a three-hour look at Holmes and Evans' relationship and at Fielder's efforts to figure her out using some…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Pop Culture Happy Hour
The Lowdown
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses the FX series "The Lowdown," a western noir comedy created by Sterling Harjo featuring Ethan Hawke as Lee, a Tulsa-based truth-seeking investigative reporter. The panelists praise the show's compelling serialized mystery, strong ensemble cast, gritty aesthetic, witty writing, and nuanced portrayal of Lee's relationship with his daughter.
Other Mommy
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour panel discusses the horror film "Other Mommy," debating whether it deserves its reputation as one of the year's worst movies. While panelists acknowledge effective horror set pieces and Jessica Chastain's performance, they criticize the film for lacking narrative direction, character development, and emotional investment.
Carrie
Glenn Weldon and Jordan Cruciola discuss Mike Flanagan's new Prime Video series adaptation of Stephen King's "Carrie," praising how it updates the classic story for the digital age with nuanced character development, standout performances from Summer H. Howell and Samantha Sloyan, and thoughtful exploration of contemporary themes like social media bullying and the parents' rights movement.
The Social Reckoning and What’s Making Us Happy
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Aaron Sorkin's film "The Social Reckoning," a companion piece to "The Social Network" about Facebook's societal harms as revealed through the Facebook Files. The panelists critique Sorkin's directorial choices, heavy-handed dialogue, problematic gender politics, and pedestrian storytelling, though they find entertainment in its unintentional comedy and earnestness.
East of Eden
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Netflix's adaptation of John Steinbeck's 'East of Eden,' praising its production quality and Florence Pugh's performance while critiquing the script's reliance on exposition over subtext. The panel explores how the show modernizes the classic novel while maintaining conservative moral stances on themes like sex work and gambling.