Other Mommy
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour panel discusses the horror film "Other Mommy," debating whether it deserves its reputation as one of the year's worst movies. While panelists acknowledge effective horror set pieces and Jessica Chastain's performance, they criticize the film for lacking narrative direction, character development, and emotional investment.
Summary
Stephen Thompson hosts NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour with guests Rihanna Cruz (freelance music and culture journalist) and Trayvon Anderson (journalist and Movie Review podcast host) to review "Other Mommy," directed by Rob Savage. The film stars Jessica Chastain as a mysterious entity resembling a young girl's frequently absent mother, alongside Jay Duplass as the father and Arabella Olivia Clark as the daughter Bella.
The panel identifies several effective horror elements: a creepy ball pit scene at a Chuck E. Cheese-type venue, paranormal investigator sequences at the grandmother's house, and Jessica Chastain's ability to contort her face for unsettling effects. However, all three panelists express frustration with the film's lack of coherence and commitment to a specific direction.
Rihanna Cruz highlights that the movie stumbles between tones, mixing genuine horror with jarring goofiness—citing an example where an intense possession scene is undercut by the demon exploding into a glitter bomb. She argues the film could have committed to a "hagsploitation" approach similar to the film "Ma" but instead delivers a half-baked experience. Trayvon Anderson criticizes the thin material given to Chastain despite her Oscar-winning credentials, and notes that the movie's biggest jump scare appears in the trailer. Stephen Thompson observes that nothing coheres into anything memorable or original.
Cruz introduces a crucial structural criticism: the film lacks skepticism among characters. Every character immediately believes in the demon's existence, eliminating the tension essential to possession films where disbelief traditionally drives conflict. This absence of character doubt undermines emotional investment in the larger themes about dark family secrets.
Anderson notes that watching the film made him think of superior horror movies (Hereditary, The Babadook, Ma, Smile, The Sixth Sense), suggesting the film fails to establish its own identity. He also critiques the child actor's performance, finding it lacks the nuance of comparable performances in similar films.
Thompson defends the child's performance as intentionally remote to maintain mystery, though he acknowledges the film's skeletal character development provides little to emotionally invest in. All panelists agree Jessica Chastain delivers the film's best work.
Anderson mentions that his theater audience applauded the ending, suggesting different audience demographics may have more favorable responses than critical viewers. He speculates that casual moviegoers unfamiliar with horror conventions might find the film more effective than critics would.
About this episode
The trailer for the movie <em>Other Mommy</em> went viral when it dropped a few months ago. It dominated the box office this weekend, but was panned by critics. But is it <em>really </em>one of the worst movies of the year? It’s about a 7-year-old girl who is visited by a mysterious entity who takes the form of her mother, played by Jessica Chastain. It’s a lean, intense horror film full of dark family secrets and grisly body horror.<br /><br /><strong>Looking for more horror films? Check out these episodes:</strong><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2026/09/01/nx-s1-5947939/it-ends-is-horror-as-hangout" target="_blank">‘It Ends’ is horror as hangout</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2026/06/01/nx-s1-5838026/backrooms-brings-youtube-horror-to-the-big-screen" target="_blank">'Backrooms' brings YouTube horror to the big screen</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/2026/05/15/nx-s1-5822305/in-obsession-love-hurts-it-really-really-really-hurts" target="_blank">In ‘Obsession,’ love hurts. It really, really, really hurts.</a><br /><br />Connect with Pop Culture Happy Hour:<br /><a href="https://letterboxd.com/nprpopculture/" target="_blank">Letterboxd</a> / <a href="https://www.facebook.com/pchh" target="_blank">Facebook</a><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/newsletter/pop-culture" target="_blank">Our weekly newsletter</a><br />Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening. Learn more at <a href="http://plus.npr.org/" target="_blank">plus.npr.org</a>.<br /><br />See <a href="https://pcm.adswizz.com">pcm.adswizz.com</a> for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.<br /><br /><a href="https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy">NPR Privacy Policy</a>
Key Insights
- The film fails to include skeptical characters who disbelieve the supernatural events, eliminating a crucial tension device essential to possession films where character doubt traditionally drives narrative conflict
- Rihanna Cruz argues the film undermines effective horror moments by immediately following them with tonal whiplash—mixing genuine scares with jarring goofiness like a demon exploding into a glitter bomb
- Trayvon Anderson contends that the movie's most impactful jump scare is revealed in the trailer and occurs early in the film, leaving insufficient payoff for the remainder of the runtime
- Stephen Thompson observes that despite Jessica Chastain's Oscar-winning credentials suggesting elevated horror filmmaking, the film fails to cohere into anything memorable or differentiated from existing possession films
- Trayvon Anderson notes that audience members in his theater applauded while he found it disappointing, suggesting casual moviegoers unfamiliar with horror film conventions experience the film more favorably than seasoned critics
Topics
Transcript
This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu. Want some excellent public media karma? Join NPR+. It's a fun way to support the newsroom that brings you pop culture happy hour while enjoying awesome perks for npr podcasts like bonus episodes and more no bad vibes just great audio explore npr plus at plus.npr.org i feel like the discourse that i've been seeing around the movie is that people are saying it's the worst movie of the year and listen i watch a lot of bad movies so okay you're a…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Pop Culture Happy Hour
You Can See Everything
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes, exploring how the film presents her story through unconventional methods including reenactments with actress Amanda Seyfried. The panelists debate whether the film is genuinely a documentary, how it handles the truth about Holmes' crimes, and the ethical implications of Fielder's filmmaking approach.
The Lowdown
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses the FX series "The Lowdown," a western noir comedy created by Sterling Harjo featuring Ethan Hawke as Lee, a Tulsa-based truth-seeking investigative reporter. The panelists praise the show's compelling serialized mystery, strong ensemble cast, gritty aesthetic, witty writing, and nuanced portrayal of Lee's relationship with his daughter.
Carrie
Glenn Weldon and Jordan Cruciola discuss Mike Flanagan's new Prime Video series adaptation of Stephen King's "Carrie," praising how it updates the classic story for the digital age with nuanced character development, standout performances from Summer H. Howell and Samantha Sloyan, and thoughtful exploration of contemporary themes like social media bullying and the parents' rights movement.
The Social Reckoning and What’s Making Us Happy
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Aaron Sorkin's film "The Social Reckoning," a companion piece to "The Social Network" about Facebook's societal harms as revealed through the Facebook Files. The panelists critique Sorkin's directorial choices, heavy-handed dialogue, problematic gender politics, and pedestrian storytelling, though they find entertainment in its unintentional comedy and earnestness.
East of Eden
NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour discusses Netflix's adaptation of John Steinbeck's 'East of Eden,' praising its production quality and Florence Pugh's performance while critiquing the script's reliance on exposition over subtext. The panel explores how the show modernizes the classic novel while maintaining conservative moral stances on themes like sex work and gambling.