The (Not So) Great Wealth Transfer
Chief Economist Wayne Best from Visa discusses economic forecasts for 2025-2028, highlighting resilience in consumer spending and business investment despite inflation and rising interest rates. The team also analyzes Visa's research on the generational wealth transfer, finding that while $93 trillion in assets will change hands over 20 years, only about $8 trillion will actually be spent, with most inheritances going to affluent heirs.
Summary
Mark Zandi hosts a discussion with co-hosts Marissa Dignitali and Chris DeReedes, joined by Wayne Best, Chief Economist at Visa. The conversation covers multiple economic topics. Best shares that Visa was named the top economic forecaster by the Wall Street Journal for 2025, crediting real-time spending data that showed recession probability never exceeded 35% despite 80% of economists expecting one. Real GDP growth is forecasted at 2.1% for 2025, with similar growth expected through 2028 at around 2.1-2.2%, reflecting potential growth rates.
Best frames the economic outlook using "three R's": resilience (strong consumer spending and business investment in AI), restraint (inflation accelerating and limiting purchasing power), and realignment (shifts in trade flows and AI integration). The team discusses concerning headwinds: real wage growth is essentially flat, saving rates are declining to near-record lows, and interest rates have risen 100-125 basis points, making refinancing impossible for homeowners with favorable mortgages. The 10-year Treasury yield has risen from below 4% to 5.2%, pushing mortgage rates above 7% and increasing credit card and auto loan rates.
The hosts debate consumer resilience. While Best argues the income proxy (wages plus hours worked plus employment) is up 4% year-over-year and flat historically, Zandi expresses skepticism that real incomes are stagnant, saving rates are collapsing, and rising interest rates aren't severely constraining spending. Dignitali worries specifically about lower-income consumers (bottom 40%) facing acute stress from higher gas, food, and utility prices. DeReedes adds concern about potential stock market corrections and non-AI business investment slowing due to higher interest rates, though he acknowledges AI investment appears resilient.
Best raises concerns about an AI bubble, expecting issues to emerge next year as circular dollar flows between hyperscalers continue. However, he notes that productivity improvements from AI are difficult to measure—knowledge worker productivity gains may manifest as better work rather than labor hour reductions. Small businesses subscribe to AI tools at 4-5 times the rate of consumers, suggesting genuine adoption.
The team plays a statistics game. Dignitali presents computer equipment new orders up 20.1% year-over-year (up 190% since 2022 vs. 121% for other goods). DeReedes shares that interest rates have risen rapidly (100+ basis points in 7 months) 16 times since 1970, and each instance preceded financial calamities. Best presents that AI-related imports now represent 23% of U.S. imports (up from 17% in 2024), with Taiwan as the largest source and Mexico surprisingly second due to HVAC systems needed for data centers.
The core research segment focuses on Visa's generational wealth transfer study. Starting from $93 trillion in assets held by older Americans, the analysis subtracts liabilities (mortgages, consumer debt, small business loans) to reach $88 trillion. Removing the top 1% (those with $19+ million net worth) leaves $60 trillion. After accounting for retirement spending (healthcare, long-term care), $44 trillion remains for heirs. After taxes, charity, and other transfers, approximately $36 trillion will be inherited. Crucially, 75% goes to the 90th-99th percentile (affluent heirs with lower marginal propensity to consume), and only about $8 trillion of the $36 trillion will actually be spent over 20 years—approximately 0.1% of projected total consumption of $407 trillion over that period.
Best notes that boomer attitudes toward wealth transfer are shifting: while the silent generation waited until death, two-thirds of boomers now spend wealth while alive, assisting with home down payments and taking grandchildren on trips (28% currently, 35% plan to within a year). Real net worth per capita shows Gen X and millennials accumulating wealth faster than boomers did at comparable ages, partly due to home appreciation and automatic 401k enrollment. The research uses government data sources including Federal Reserve, Treasury Department, and Department of Labor statistics.
About this episode
Wayne Best, Chief Economist at Visa and The Wall Street Journal’s Most Accurate Forecaster of 2025, joins the Inside Economics team to discuss the state of the economy with a focus on consumer spending. Despite a similar forecast for next year, Wayne is slightly more sanguine than the Inside Economics team about the durability of consumer spending. The discussion then leads to a surprising and fascinating look at Wayne’s recent research on the generational wealth transfer. Over the next 20 years, the Boomers will pass on trillions in wealth to their heirs, but it may not be the macroeconomic boon many are expecting.
Key Insights
- Visa's economic forecasting outperformed 80% of economists who predicted recession, using real-time spending data to maintain recession probability below 35% while consensus expected 80%.
- Real wage growth is flat to slightly negative when accounting for inflation (3% wage growth vs. slightly higher inflation), constraining consumer purchasing power despite headline employment figures.
- Interest rates have risen 100-125 basis points in recent months, with 10-year Treasury yields jumping from below 4% to 5.2%, creating a historical pattern where 16 similar rapid increases since 1970 preceded financial crises.
- The generational wealth transfer, while starting at $93 trillion, reduces to only $8 trillion in actual consumer spending over 20 years after accounting for liabilities, taxes, retirement expenses, and the low propensity to consume among affluent heirs.
- 75% of inheritances flow to the 90th-99th percentile income group, meaning wealth concentration increases rather than disperses, limiting macroeconomic stimulus from the transfer.
- Computer equipment and AI-related imports have grown 20.1% year-over-year and 190% since 2022, compared to 121% growth in other goods, reflecting concentrated investment in AI infrastructure.
- 40% of homeowners aged 65-79 now carry mortgages (up from 23% in 1989), and 30% of those 80+ have mortgages, creating unexpected liabilities that reduce net wealth available for transfer.
- Two-thirds of boomers now spend wealth while living rather than preserving it for heirs, with specific behaviors like family cruises and grandchild trips becoming increasingly common.
- Mexico has become the second-largest source of AI-related imports (after Taiwan) primarily due to HVAC manufacturing for data centers, accounting for 25% of AI import value.
- Measuring productivity gains from AI is difficult because knowledge workers may use time savings to produce better work rather than reduce labor hours, making traditional productivity statistics unreliable.
- Small businesses subscribe to large language models at 4-5 times the rate of consumers, suggesting genuine adoption intent despite consumer subscription skepticism.
- Real net worth per capita for Gen X and millennials is accumulating faster than boomers did at comparable ages, partly offsetting inheritance benefits through their own wealth building via home appreciation and retirement accounts.
Topics
Transcript
Mark O' Welcome to Inside Economics. I'm Mark Zandi, the Chief Economist at Moody's Analytics, and I'm joined by my two trusty co-hosts, Marisa Dignitali, Chris DeReedes. Hi, guys. Hi, Mark. You're looking dapper. Am I looking dapper? Yeah, you got a haircut. I got a haircut. That's what it is. I cut my three hairs. You're wearing a suit jacket, you know. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I've been going from one thing to the next. Marissa, you didn't say hello. I did say hello. I did. You did say hello? Yeah, yeah. Okay. I did. You did say hello? Yeah, yeah. Okay. She did. And you've had a busy week, I know. I've been following your travels around the country.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access