VSJ Ep 48
Tony D'Antonis Luca analyzes volatility markets in episode 48, finding that while conditions improved from the previous week's crisis, the market remains vulnerable with a flat VIX futures curve, negative variance risk premium, and elevated realized volatility suggesting underlying instability. He also examines Treasury markets and Fed policy positioning, concluding the Fed appears behind the curve as market rates continue climbing.
Summary
In this episode of the volatility markets analysis, host Tony D'Antonis Luca reviews multiple risk models and volatility indicators to assess current market health. The HRV (Heart Rate Variability) model recovered from deep red conditions to yellow, though the host cautions this recovery is partly illusory since it's rebounding from severely depressed levels. The Early Warning System model continues flashing warning signs due to elevated realized volatility in both the S&P 500 and VIX itself, as well as accelerating interest rate increases.
The VIX realized volatility is extraordinarily high at over 250% annualized, with average true range around 3 VIX points—indicating significant whipsaw volatility. Meanwhile, the S&P 500 realized volatility has finally increased above its year-long suppression below 15%, now elevated alongside VIX levels. Critically, the host identifies a negative variance risk premium—implied volatility (VIX) has dropped below realized volatility—meaning the options market is pricing for realized volatility to decline. This is unusual and creates unfavorable conditions for option sellers.
The VIX futures curve remains dangerously flat with very little slope, indicating market unease. A flat curve is vulnerable and easily reverts to backwardation. The host notes that improvement from 25.6 VIX (last Friday) to 19.3 (this Friday) was primarily driven by collapsing implied correlations and declining individual stock volatility post-earnings, rather than fundamental market stabilization.
Implied correlations dropped significantly but realized correlations remained sticky and elevated, creating a negative correlation risk premium. The options market is essentially betting that correlations will decline, but if this bet is wrong, higher realized correlations would pressurize index volatility higher. The host notes that while current correlation levels remain low historically (below 25), elevated implied-realized correlation spreads suggest vulnerability if correlations normalize upward toward the 25-35 range.
On Treasury markets, the 10-year rate reversed after five weeks of declines, moving sharply higher. However, the MOVE index remains within normal operating ranges (80-120), suggesting the Treasury market isn't in crisis mode. Inflation breakeven rates have cooled after trending higher. The host presents a novel chart tracking Fed rates versus market rates historically, observing that market rates have been climbing while the Fed raised rates only recently, suggesting the Fed is currently behind the market in the rate-hiking cycle.
The host concludes that while conditions improved from the previous week's low point, the market remains vulnerable. The flat VIX curve structure, negative variance risk premium, sticky realized volatility and correlation despite lower implied measures, and rising market rates all signal caution. He recommends waiting for markets to stabilize, realized volatility to decline toward implied levels, and the VIX curve to steepen before aggressively deploying capital.
Key Insights
- The VIX realized volatility is over 250% annualized, with the VIX moving in large candles and average true range exceeding 3 VIX points, indicating extreme intraday volatility swings even as the overall VIX level declined six points during the week
- Implied volatility (measured by VIX and VIX futures) has dropped below realized volatility, creating a negative variance risk premium—an unusual configuration that suggests the options market is positioned for realized volatility to decline
- The VIX futures curve has become very flat with minimal slope, making it vulnerable to reverting to backwardation, and a flat curve structure indicates market unease and vulnerability rather than stability despite the six-point VIX decline
- Implied correlations fell significantly this week while realized correlations remained sticky and elevated, creating a negative correlation risk premium where the options market is betting correlations will decline but faces execution risk if this fails
- Looking at historical Fed rates versus market rates, market rates are currently climbing while the Fed has only recently started hiking and remains relatively flat, suggesting the Fed is behind the curve and market rates will likely pressure the Fed to raise further
Topics
Transcript
[0:04] Hello and welcome to episode 48 of Wall Street Journal, your unscheduled but mostly weekly deep dive into the volatility markets. I'm your host Tony D'Antonis Luca and a lot has happened since I last recorded a video two weeks ago. So we're going to get right to it this week. We're going to run through the usual chart deck. We're going to look at all things volatility, VIX, VVIX, VIX futures with a stop off at volatility composition and we're going to end with a conversation about interest rates. We also going to zoom out to take a look at a kind of a wider lens look at interest rates including market rates and also what's been going…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Macro Ops
Wall Street Panicked on Friday and Then Changed Its Mind by the Close
Wall Street experienced severe intraday volatility on Friday with the market panicking during the final third of trading, causing the VIX to spike to nearly 24, before reversing sharply into the close. The volatility market is already elevated, making further moves more difficult to sustain, though multiple risk factors including rising realized volatility, correlations, and credit stress remain concerning.
The Selloff Is Real, but the Fear Never Showed Up
Despite real selling pressure in equities, particularly the NASDAQ, volatility markets have not panicked as severely as one might expect, with market rotational mechanics helping stabilize the index. The VIX futures curve is slightly inverted and flat, making it difficult to trade long volatility, while realized volatility remains surprisingly low relative to individual stock volatility and implied measures.
Stocks Fell All Day and the Fear Gauge Quietly Gave Up
On Friday, October 16th, markets experienced significant selling pressure that awakened the volatility complex, with spot VIX closing at 19.99 and inverting the VIX futures curve for the first time in weeks. While the move was characterized by strong over-VIXing and elevated implied volatility, it was driven primarily by individual stock volatility rather than correlation events, suggesting the market may need accelerating selling pressure to sustain further declines.
The Number Keeping This Market Calm Just Hit Zero
Market analysis episode examining why stock indices remain resilient despite external pressures, with focus on rotation mechanics between mega-cap stocks and sectors that keep volatility suppressed and correlations low. The VIX remains calm around 14-16 despite headline risks, indicating healthy market functioning.
Rates Are Rising and the Rest of the Market Hasn't Caught Up Yet
Tony Daltis Luke analyzes market volatility and correlations across equities, fixed income, and currencies, noting that while equity markets remain resilient with low realized correlations, rising Treasury rates and widening credit spreads signal emerging pressure in the system. Multiple correlation divergences between assets suggest potential market dislocation that warrant close monitoring.