The Selloff Is Real, but the Fear Never Showed Up
Despite real selling pressure in equities, particularly the NASDAQ, volatility markets have not panicked as severely as one might expect, with market rotational mechanics helping stabilize the index. The VIX futures curve is slightly inverted and flat, making it difficult to trade long volatility, while realized volatility remains surprisingly low relative to individual stock volatility and implied measures.
Summary
Tony Dundas Luka analyzes market conditions following a week of equity weakness led by NASDAQ declines, with Treasury rates falling but failing to support equities. Two proprietary models—the Market HRV (measuring market health through rotation and volatility mechanics) and an Early Warning System—both recovered to yellow zones this week after spiking higher the previous week, suggesting the market has stabilized somewhat despite ongoing weakness. The HRV model rates the market at a C+, indicating cautionary conditions without free-fall panic.
The volatility market shows key divergences: as the S&P 500 printed new lows on Friday (down to 7612), both the VIX and VVIX printed lower highs compared to the previous Friday, suggesting the volatility market is becoming less sensitive to incremental selling. However, VIX futures (particularly the November contract) are showing higher highs, creating mixed signals about implied volatility direction.
The VIX futures curve is problematic according to Dundas Luka. It closed Friday with November VIX at 19.61 and December at 19.50, creating slight backwardation (front-month inversion), with the front of the curve extremely flat—only about two volatility points from front to back. He argues this flat curve at relatively elevated levels (VIX near 20) makes it hard for volatility to push higher unless realized volatility spikes dramatically, as the market would need to sustain 1.5%+ daily S&P moves. If the market merely grinds lower without realized volatility spiking, implied volatilities will struggle to stay elevated.
Realized versus implied volatility analysis reveals a wide variance risk premium (VRP). The 21-day realized volatility of the S&P is below 10 (single digits), while VIX sits around 19.45, creating a 10-point spread—rarely seen but not unprecedented. This gap suggests the options market is pricing significant future volatility that hasn't materialized in recent price action.
A new analytical tool decomposing VIX composition shows that implied correlations have risen this week while individual stock volatility (VIX EQ) barely moved, yet overall VIX declined slightly. This unusual pattern highlights how the VIX EQ (individual stock volatility) has remained elevated while the broader index has stayed calm—a defining characteristic of the current market regime with historically low correlations. Over the past 10 years, the market is currently in a very unique period with exceptionally low realized and implied correlations, with only brief spikes during major dislocations like the 2020 crisis and early 2024.
A striking observation is that average stock volatility (top 50 stocks) remains significantly elevated compared to S&P 500 realized volatility, which has been trending sideways to lower. Individual names have experienced sharp moves in both directions while the index remained stable—a divergence Dundas Luka attributes to the low-correlation environment where market mechanics have rotated capital effectively into pockets of strength.
In the Treasury market, an interesting divergence has emerged: the 10-year rate has declined over the past three weeks, yet the MOVE Index (volatility measure for Treasuries) has climbed the past two weeks, reaching 103. Dundas Luka notes this correlation breakdown—rates down, volatility up—is worth monitoring, though he acknowledges it carries different implications when volatility is already this elevated compared to historical periods when MOVE was in the 50s-60s range.
Key Insights
- The VIX futures curve is inverted and extremely flat at elevated levels, with only about two volatility points from front to back, making it harder for volatility to push higher unless realized volatility spikes significantly because the market would need to sustain 1.5%+ daily S&P moves to justify current levels
- Market rotational mechanics—where capital rotates from pockets of danger to pockets of strength—have held up well enough to prevent panic despite S&P printing new lows, with only a handful of mega-cap stocks like Apple, Walmart, and Berkshire Hathaway holding up the index while most others decline
- A significant divergence exists where S&P 500 realized volatility remains in single digits while individual stock volatility (top 50 stocks) is substantially higher, indicating the current market is defined by an exceptionally low-correlation environment where market mechanics are effectively isolating weakness to specific sectors
- The variance risk premium is currently at 10 points—the spread between VIX around 19.45 and realized volatility below 10—which is rarely seen and indicates the options market is pricing significant future volatility that hasn't materialized in recent price action
- The MOVE Index (Treasury volatility) has climbed while the 10-year Treasury rate has declined over the past two weeks, a correlation breakdown that has precedent but carries different implications when volatility is already elevated at 103 compared to historical periods when it was in the 50s-60s range
Topics
Transcript
[0:05] Hello and welcome to episode 45 of Wall Street Journal, your unscheduled but mostly weekly deep dive into the volatility markets. I'm your host Tony Dundas Luka and we had ourselves another interesting week. We now have a VIX futures curve that is inverted at the front. Volatility markets in general are a little bit jumpy. Equities are weak being led by the NASDAQ to the downside. Rates are dropping but that is not helping equities so far. So yeah, there's a lot to cover this week. We're going to start by taking a look at some new charts that I've been building over the past couple weeks. After that, we're going to go to all things VIX, VVIX…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Macro Ops
VSJ Ep 48
Tony D'Antonis Luca analyzes volatility markets in episode 48, finding that while conditions improved from the previous week's crisis, the market remains vulnerable with a flat VIX futures curve, negative variance risk premium, and elevated realized volatility suggesting underlying instability. He also examines Treasury markets and Fed policy positioning, concluding the Fed appears behind the curve as market rates continue climbing.
Wall Street Panicked on Friday and Then Changed Its Mind by the Close
Wall Street experienced severe intraday volatility on Friday with the market panicking during the final third of trading, causing the VIX to spike to nearly 24, before reversing sharply into the close. The volatility market is already elevated, making further moves more difficult to sustain, though multiple risk factors including rising realized volatility, correlations, and credit stress remain concerning.
Stocks Fell All Day and the Fear Gauge Quietly Gave Up
On Friday, October 16th, markets experienced significant selling pressure that awakened the volatility complex, with spot VIX closing at 19.99 and inverting the VIX futures curve for the first time in weeks. While the move was characterized by strong over-VIXing and elevated implied volatility, it was driven primarily by individual stock volatility rather than correlation events, suggesting the market may need accelerating selling pressure to sustain further declines.
The Number Keeping This Market Calm Just Hit Zero
Market analysis episode examining why stock indices remain resilient despite external pressures, with focus on rotation mechanics between mega-cap stocks and sectors that keep volatility suppressed and correlations low. The VIX remains calm around 14-16 despite headline risks, indicating healthy market functioning.
Rates Are Rising and the Rest of the Market Hasn't Caught Up Yet
Tony Daltis Luke analyzes market volatility and correlations across equities, fixed income, and currencies, noting that while equity markets remain resilient with low realized correlations, rising Treasury rates and widening credit spreads signal emerging pressure in the system. Multiple correlation divergences between assets suggest potential market dislocation that warrant close monitoring.