How to Combat Pain
Pain is not simply a signal from damaged tissue but a complex experience constructed by the brain based on biological, psychological, and social factors. Understanding pain as a biopsychosocial phenomenon rather than purely biomedical opens new treatment possibilities that address emotional health, social connections, sleep, diet, and mindset alongside physical interventions.
Summary
Rachel Zofness, a pain psychologist at UCSF, explains that the conventional biomedical model of pain—which assumes pain is simply a signal from damaged tissue—is fundamentally incomplete. The episode opens with two construction worker case studies illustrating this: one experienced excruciating pain from a nail through his boot despite no tissue damage, while another had minimal pain despite a four-inch nail embedded in his face near his prefrontal cortex. Both cases demonstrate that pain is constructed by the brain as a danger alarm, not a direct readout of tissue damage.
The brain uses all available information—sensory data, memories, emotions, social context, and environmental cues—to decide whether to produce pain and how intense it should be. Phantom limb pain exemplifies this: people can experience severe pain in amputated limbs because the brain's sensory map (homunculus) hasn't updated to reflect the missing body part. A young patient named Mateo, who lost his hand in a firework explosion, experienced phantom pain that improved only when his brain's body map was rewired.
Zofness introduces the biopsychosocial model, represented as three overlapping circles: biological factors (genetics, tissue damage, diet, exercise, sleep), psychological factors (stress, anxiety, depression, trauma), and sociological factors (social support, isolation, race/ethnicity, environment). She emphasizes that medicine typically addresses only the biological domain, missing two-thirds of the pain problem.
The role of context is crucial: the same physical injury feels different depending on circumstances—stubbing a toe while being fired feels worse than the same injury at the beach. Trust in healthcare providers, distraction, and emotional state all modulate pain experience. Critically, negative emotions like stress and anxiety amplify the pain alarm, while positive emotions and social connection reduce it.
Treatment involves multiple strategies: addressing emotional health directly (since parts of the brain that produce emotions also produce pain), strengthening social connections (loneliness increases cortisol and suppresses immunity), improving sleep and diet, and identifying a personal 'pain recipe'—the combination of biological, psychological, and social ingredients that amplify pain. By mapping a high-pain recipe, patients can construct a corresponding low-pain recipe with opposite factors.
Zofness discusses 'pain voice'—negative predictions and catastrophic thoughts that accompany pain. While pain voice intends to protect, negative thoughts trigger physiological cascades affecting neurotransmitters and hormones, amplifying pain. Using 'detective questions' to test whether thoughts are facts (rather than pain voice's hyperboles) can reduce their impact. Studies show that 70% of research on pain and optimism demonstrates connections between hopeful thoughts and reduced pain intensity, frequency, and disability.
The episode concludes with case studies demonstrating recovery: Kai, with Fabry disease, experienced phantom pain relief through placebo gummies that then inspired him that psychological factors could help; Sam, a 17-year-old bedbound with chronic migraine and diffuse pain from 14 doctors and 40 medications, recovered through targeting all biopsychosocial ingredients—sleep hygiene, nutrition, gradual activity pacing, social engagement, and mood treatment—eventually graduating high school and attending college.
About this episode
Pain feels like a simple message from the body. If your elbow hurts, there must be something wrong with your elbow. If your back is painfully stiff, you need some work done on your back. But psychologist Rachel Zoffness says our minds play a much larger role in our experience of pain than many of us realize. This week, we look at what's really happening when we experience pain, and how a better understanding of this process can open up new possibilities for treatment and healing.
Key Insights
- Pain is constructed by the brain as a danger detection system that uses all available information (sensory data, memories, emotions, social context) to decide whether to produce pain, not simply a signal from damaged tissue.
- The brain's sensory map of the body (homunculus) can lag in updating after traumatic injury, causing phantom pain in missing limbs when the brain still perceives those body parts as being in danger.
- The biopsychosocial model recognizes that biological factors account for only one-third of pain; psychological factors (stress, anxiety, depression, trauma) and sociological factors (social support, isolation, environment) constitute the other two-thirds, yet medicine typically addresses only the biological domain.
- Context profoundly modulates pain experience—the same physical injury produces different pain depending on surrounding circumstances, who one is with, emotional state, and trust in one's environment and healthcare providers.
- Loneliness and social isolation trigger elevated cortisol production, which suppresses immune function and increases rates of morbidity and mortality, directly exacerbating both pain and disease susceptibility.
- Negative thoughts and catastrophic predictions ('pain voice') trigger physiological cascades affecting neurotransmitters and hormones throughout the body, amplifying pain signals, while research shows 70% of studies demonstrate hopeful thoughts reduce pain intensity, frequency, and disability.
- A patient's expectations and predictions about treatment can produce measurable physiological pain relief even with placebo interventions, demonstrating the brain's capacity to modulate pain based on psychological prediction.
- Comprehensive pain recovery typically requires simultaneous intervention across multiple biopsychosocial domains—sleep hygiene, nutrition, gradual activity pacing, social engagement, mood treatment, and cognitive reframing—rather than medication or procedures alone.
Topics
Transcript
This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. It happens in an instant. You move too fast and you feel a wrench in your back. That first sharp pain is followed by a persistent ache, bothersome enough to send you to the doctor. A scan reveals a problem. A specialist recommends surgery. You go under the knife, trusting that once the damaged tissue is repaired, the pain will disappear. The story makes intuitive sense. Diagnose the problem, fix the bone or ligament or tendon that is not working properly and you'll make the pain go away but for many of us that's not how pain on falls aches persist even when scans look normal or they vanish without any medical intervention…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Hidden Brain
Changing Our Mental Maps
This episode explores how our brains create mental maps to navigate the world efficiently, but these maps can become outdated or incorrect, trapping us in harmful patterns. Through neuroscience research and personal stories, the episode demonstrates how accepting reality and reconnecting with sensory experience can help us update our mental models and design more meaningful lives.
Waking Up Your Spiritual Brain: Part 2
This episode explores spirituality and life design through interviews with psychologist Lisa Miller on how spiritual practices strengthen the brain and improve well-being, and behavioral scientist Dave Evans on how to design meaningful lives by accepting constraints and focusing on intrinsic rather than extrinsic motivations.
Waking Up Your Spiritual Brain: Part 1
Psychologist Lisa Miller presents scientific research showing that spirituality is an innate human capacity with measurable neural correlates that protect against mental illness, depression, and suicide. She argues that sustained spiritual practice—prayer, meditation, service—literally thickens the cortex in brain regions associated with transcendent awareness and that spirituality and depression are two sides of the same coin.
Stepping Out of the Shadows
The episode explores the concept of negativity bias and disgust, emphasizing how our brains prioritize negative experiences over positive ones. Psychologist Allison Ledgerwood discusses how focusing on the negative shapes our perceptions and responses, while David Pizarro analyzes the nature of disgust and its cultural implications.
A Secret Source of Connection
This Hidden Brain episode explores the psychology of kindness and human connection, examining why people fail to extend help despite wanting to, and why feeling seen and valued is essential to human well-being. Psychologist Amit Kumar's research reveals that givers systematically underestimate the impact of their kind acts, while psychologist Gordon Flett explores how the human need to 'matter' affects physical and emotional health.