Why the Tech Right Lost Big This Week
A Hard Fork episode analyzing why the tech right's massive political spending in the 2024 midterms failed spectacularly, with Elon Musk losing despite spending $450-500 million while AI and data center opposition animated voters against the industry's agenda.
Summary
The episode opens with hosts Max Reed, Aaron Griffith, and Ezra Klein examining the dramatic reversal of fortune for Silicon Valley's tech right, particularly Elon Musk and aligned figures like Marc Andreessen and David Sachs. Two years ago, this faction was considered the most powerful wing of the Trump coalition, but this week's elections produced a "national scolding" where their preferred candidates lost badly.
The hosts identify three distinct anti-tech sentiments driving the results: broad opposition to AI itself, specific anti-data center sentiment in states like Texas and Ohio, and general anti-billionaire/anti-oligarchy sentiment focused on Musk. Exit polling revealed 56% said AI and data centers were crucial factors in their vote, with 57% believing AI would hurt society versus 24% believing it would help, and 76% opposing data centers in their community.
Ezra Klein argues the core problem isn't messaging but that the tech industry hasn't convinced people they should want more AI. Instead, the basic pitch is "it might kill everyone, it will take your job, but you'll get cheaper energy"—an unconvincing value proposition. The tech right's strategy of simply not caring whether people trusted them or liked their plans has backfired spectacularly. Aaron Griffith reports that VCs he spoke with believed people's revealed preferences (using ChatGPT, Facebook, Amazon) meant sentiment didn't matter, but the election proved otherwise.
On data centers specifically, Tuesday night saw near-total rejection. Democratic candidates won in states with intensive data center buildout (Texas, Ohio, Georgia, Arizona) by making it a wedge issue. In Ohio specifically, candidates weaponized it against Republican incumbents like Vivek Ramaswamy and Senate candidates. The buildout slowdown threatens 10-15 gigawatts of the 45 gigawatts expected online next year, primarily from Texas.
The hosts discuss AI safety concerns articulated by younger politicians like Jon Ossoff and Bettie Elias, who cite lab employee concerns and understand technical concepts like distillation. Klein notes there's a difference between employees worried about existential risk and investors worried about regulation—the latter fear that slowdowns could hurt CapEx investments they're counting on.
Regarding billionaire influence broadly, anti-billionaire sentiment was constant, though a California wealth tax proposition unexpectedly failed despite the blue wave. Newsom's non-endorsement and concerns about billionaire flight to Texas seemed decisive. The hosts predict wealth taxes will return at the federal level in 2028 where they're more easily administered.
Vivek Ramaswamy's humiliation in Ohio—losing his gubernatorial race and resorting to grotesque final ads attacking opponent Amy Acton using her mother—illustrated how tech-aligned MAGA politicians fail when they lack Trump's instinctive feel for cruelty and messaging. Ezra Klein argues the tech right survives only as a factional player within a broader coalition where their inhuman views aren't dominant, and they fundamentally don't understand or like human beings, making them poor politicians.
The second segment on campaign finance with reporter Teddy Schleifer catalogs spending effectiveness. Reid Hoffman spent $17 million on Colin Allred's Texas race and won; Sergey Brin spent $100+ million through Building a Better California and successfully killed the wealth tax; but crypto's Fair Shake Super PAC spent $45 million against Sherrod Brown and lost, and Elon Musk's $450+ million produced essentially zero wins. Musk became a foil for Democrats rather than an asset, especially in Texas where James Tallarico used him in closing messaging.
Greg Brockman's $50 million pledge to the Leading the Future AI Super PAC was halved when it became politically toxic internally at OpenAI, suggesting employee pressure and reputational concerns are returning post-Trump. The hosts discuss likely 2028 scenarios, including Musk supporting J.D. Vance and AI safety-minded donors (potentially from Anthropic's upcoming IPO) becoming a Democratic funding source.
About this episode
“This felt like a decidedly anti-tech election.”
Key Insights
- Exit polling showed 56% of voters cited AI and data centers as crucial factors in their vote, with 57% believing AI would hurt society, demonstrating AI is genuinely salient to electorate rather than just a messaging problem.
- Elon Musk spent $450-500 million on the midterms and failed to win essentially any races he targeted, including Ken Paxton's Texas gubernatorial race, making him possibly the worst return on investment in the entire cycle.
- VCs interviewed by the hosts believed people's revealed preferences (high usage of AI products) meant voter sentiment against AI didn't matter politically, but the election proved this assumption fundamentally wrong.
- The tech industry pitch on AI essentially amounts to 'it might kill everyone, it will take your job, but you'll get cheaper energy'—an unconvincing value proposition that no messaging campaign can overcome.
- Data center opposition became an effective political wedge that didn't split normally along partisan lines, allowing Democratic candidates to persuade Republican voters in states like Texas, Ohio, and Georgia.
- Jon Ossoff's victory speech directly attacked Silicon Valley figures for bunker-building while creating AI that risks human extinction, indicating younger politicians are developing genuine technical expertise on AI rather than generic tech skepticism.
- Greg Brockman halved his planned $50 million pledge to the Leading the Future AI Super PAC after the first $25 million in 2025, with internal OpenAI concerns that his donations were becoming a distraction—suggesting employee pressure is returning to tech companies.
- The tech right as a political faction can only survive as a minor player within a broader coalition; when foregrounded as the primary force (as with Ramaswamy and Vance), their lack of understanding of human beings and their inhuman policy positions become electoral liabilities.
- Reid Hoffman succeeded by spending $17 million on Colin Allred's Texas campaign and won, while Sergio Brin succeeded by spending $100+ million to kill California's wealth tax, but both succeeded because they had clear policy targets rather than trying to reshape public opinion on broad tech issues.
- Fair Shake, the crypto Super PAC, spent $45 million against Senator Sherrod Brown and lost, piercing the narrative from 2024 that the crypto industry was politically invincible and that young voters would necessarily gravitate toward crypto-friendly politicians.
- Vivek Ramaswamy's final campaign ads—using Amy Acton's mother to call her a liar about stepfather abuse—illustrated how tech-aligned politicians lack Trump's instinctive feel for where the boundaries are, resulting in ads that are simply grotesque and horrifying rather than edgy.
- Much of the Democratic political giving now flows through dark money nonprofits rather than disclosed vehicles, partly due to Trump's threats to investigate progressive donors, making the actual landscape of Democratic funding substantially invisible despite attempts to track disclosed giving.
Topics
Transcript
Compute scales in an instant. Storage scales in an instant. So why does the network underneath them still get ordered months ahead, sized for a peak that may never come? With Lumen Intelligent Internet, businesses can add network capacity in minutes when demand shows up and dial it back when things quiet down. No guessing months ahead, just room to grow across more than 10 million U.S. business locations. Finally, a network that moves as fast as your ambition. Visit lumen.com slash ambition ready. Lumen, the trusted network for AI. What just happened to Elon Musk? Two years ago, the SpaceX founder and world's richest man was riding high. He and the rest of the tech right of Silicon Valley…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Hard Fork
Jensen Huang Is Out at Nvidia
Jensen Huang has resigned as CEO of NVIDIA following revelations of extramarital affairs, including one with an alleged Chinese spy and another with an NVIDIA executive. The resignation marks a dramatic fall from power for one of tech's most influential figures and raises significant questions about the future leadership of the company that dominates AI chip manufacturing, national security implications, and potential regulatory changes in Washington.
The Jensen Huang Affair
Stephen Witt, author of 'The Thinking Machine,' discusses the Jensen Huang scandal involving an alleged affair with a Chinese intelligence operative, illegal chip smuggling through Malaysian data centers, and the Trump administration's knowledge of the situation. The scandal raises questions about Huang's credibility on China policy and threatens NVIDIA's operations despite likely board support keeping him in place.
Are We in an A.I. Bubble? We're About to Find Out.
Hard Fork discusses Anthropic's IPO filing, revealing the company has $16.3 billion in first-half 2026 revenue with slowing growth in Q3, while raising questions about whether the AI boom is sustainable. The episode covers risks from AI vulnerabilities, the role of data centers in elections, and broader concerns about whether AI investments represent genuine value or speculative bubble.
What’s the Deal With Billy Evans? A Spoiler-Filled Guide to ‘You Can See Everything’
This Hard Fork podcast episode explores the documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos, featuring interviews with finance reporter Rob Copeland and tech writer Erin Griffin about Billy Evans (Holmes' partner), plus Q&A with investigative journalist John Carreyrou about the fraud and Holmes' culpability.
Why No One Can Look Away From Elizabeth Holmes
Hard Fork discusses the new Elizabeth Holmes documentary by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, examining Holmes' enduring cultural fascination and what the film reveals about her character. The episode also covers major tech news including an alleged Saudi spy arrested at OpenAI, Character AI's bankruptcy, Apple's new Home View device, and a Palantir executive's claim about AI researchers smoking to signal belief in AI's cancer-curing potential.