NewsDiscussion

What’s the Deal With Billy Evans? A Spoiler-Filled Guide to ‘You Can See Everything’

Hard Fork59m 14s

This Hard Fork podcast episode explores the documentary "You Can See Everything" about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos, featuring interviews with finance reporter Rob Copeland and tech writer Erin Griffin about Billy Evans (Holmes' partner), plus Q&A with investigative journalist John Carreyrou about the fraud and Holmes' culpability.

Summary

The episode begins with Rob Copeland discussing his experience interviewing Billy Evans about his new startup, Humanthus, a blood-testing company for pets supposedly regulated at a lower threshold than human blood testing. Copeland was shocked to discover Billy had been filming a two-year documentary with the filmmakers while appearing to hide Elizabeth Holmes' involvement in the startup. The article Copeland published in May 2024 prompted resistance from Billy, who wanted to delay coverage, allegedly to preserve the documentary's reveal.

Copeland and Erin Griffin discuss the dynamics of Billy and Elizabeth's relationship, debating whether it's genuine or transactional. They note Billy's tendency to volunteer information before being asked and his PR-trained responses. Copeland observed that Billy has a pattern of saying "you can ask me anything" while not actually revealing information. They discuss whether their relationship parallels Holmes' previous relationship with Sonny Balwani, with both involving the same business model (blood testing) being attempted again.

The hosts explore Billy's Twitter activity, which he apparently manages on behalf of imprisoned Holmes, posting both inspirational quotes and politically charged content. Rob reports that even though Holmes is imprisoned, she likely has access to a phone, as the hosts note is common in prisons.

Rob Copeland then discusses CoreWeave, an AI infrastructure company facing financial strain despite massive growth. The company has $70 billion in liabilities across 51 data centers and is seeing its stock fall as debt servicing costs double. This is presented as a potential canary in the coal mine for broader AI infrastructure spending.

Erin Griffin reports on Elon Musk's consolidation of his empire through a potential SpaceX-Tesla merger, noting Musk's track record of successful controversial consolidations and his desire for greater control over Tesla.

Max Reed discusses Joel Kaplan leaving Meta after 15 years, noting Kaplan's role as a "conservative whisperer" who navigated Facebook through conservative criticism and censorship allegations. Reed speculates Kaplan may land in the Trump administration.

John Carreyrou then answers audience questions about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos. He emphasizes that Holmes demonstrably lied to investors about the Edison machine's capabilities—it could only do 12 tests (all of which had to be voided due to errors), not the hundreds she claimed. Carreyrou discusses Tyler Schultz, a key whistleblower and grandson of George Schultz, whose life became difficult after Theranos attempted intimidation and legal threats. Holmes even appealed to Rupert Murdoch (Theranos' largest investor) to kill Carreyrou's Wall Street Journal story.

Carreyrou argues that while Holmes may have initially believed in her vision, the fraud became systematic in fall 2013 when Theranos went live with blood tests at Walgreens despite machines that couldn't perform reliably. They hacked Siemens machines and pre-diluted samples, compromising accuracy. Regarding Billy as mark or opportunist, Carreyrou sees him as both—genuinely caring but also seeking to capitalize on Holmes' notoriety. On whether Holmes understands she lied, Carreyrou argues she does know but continues to perform innocence. He notes she has never shown genuine contrition or responsibility for patient harm, employee impact, or investor losses.

About this episode

“You shouldn’t overbeat scrambled eggs.”

Key Insights

  • Rob Copeland's May 2024 article about Humanthus unknowingly disrupted the documentary's planned reveal of Theranos 2.0, forcing the filmmakers to accelerate their release timeline.
  • Billy Evans demonstrates a pattern of claiming complete transparency ("you can ask me anything") while strategically withholding substantive information, a behavior Copeland associates with B-list corporate PR training.
  • The Edison machine could only reliably perform 12 blood tests, all of which had to be voided due to errors, contradicting Holmes' public claims that it could perform hundreds of tests from a single drop.
  • Holmes appealed directly to Rupert Murdoch, Theranos' largest investor ($125 million), in fall 2015 to kill Carreyrou's Wall Street Journal investigation story.
  • Theranos systematized fraud in fall 2013 when going live at Walgreens by hacking Siemens machines and pre-diluting blood samples, which compromised accuracy rather than using their own technology.
  • Tyler Schultz, a key whistleblower, was ambushed by Theranos lawyers at his grandfather's home and spent summer 2015 sleeping with a knife under his pillow due to intimidation from the company.
  • CoreWeave's $70 billion in liabilities across 51 data centers and declining stock suggests potential systemic problems in AI infrastructure spending that may affect the broader sector.
  • Holmes has never shown genuine contrition or accepted responsibility for harm to patients, employees, or investors despite multiple opportunities to do so during trial and sentencing.

Topics

Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos fraud documentaryBilly Evans and Humanthus startupInvestigative journalism and sources protectionAI infrastructure investment and CoreWeaveElon Musk's business consolidation strategyHolmes' prison communications and social mediaWhistleblower retaliation tacticsCriminal responsibility and contrition

Transcript

Support for this podcast comes from Dell Technologies. It's time to put AI to work. Is your business ready? The challenge isn't getting started with AI. It's scaling beyond pilots while maintaining control of your data, governance, infrastructure, and costs. Dell AI Factory provides the integrated foundation you need to scale AI securely and efficiently with one trusted partner. Dell, AI on your terms. From idea to impact. Learn more at dell.com slash yourwaytoai. That's dell.com slash yourwaytoai. It's been a week since I've seen You Can See Everything, the new documentary about Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes, and I still want to talk about it. And from what I'm hearing, most of you want to talk about it too. from…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Hard Fork

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.