How To Trade The AI Productivity Boom | Weekly Roundup
A roundtable discussion on macro markets, Fed policy, the AI productivity boom, crypto's declining relevance, and the growing K-shaped economy. The hosts debate whether the Fed should hike rates, analyze vol mechanics driving equity markets, and express concern about widening wealth inequality being driven by deliberate policy choices favoring asset owners over Main Street.
Summary
The hosts open by discussing whether the Fed should be hiking rates, noting that Taylor Rule models suggest rates are too low given persistent above-target inflation for 60+ months. One host argues the Fed's stimulative measures — suppressing oil prices, yield management, currency manipulation — increase the risk of an energy price shock seeping into core inflation. Another host counters that hiking is unlikely given the massive federal deficit and debt rollover needs, arguing the implicit policy is to grow out of the debt with negative real rates.
The conversation shifts to the AI productivity boom and its market implications. The hosts note that while the AI theme appears real and is driving genuine earnings growth, it may be crowding out capital from other sectors including crypto — drawing a parallel to how tech growth in 2012 sucked capital out of gold miners. They discuss how crypto's most useful real-world applications (stablecoins, payment rails) generate no token value capture, and note that even longtime Ethereum bulls like David Hoffman are capitulating on ETH as an investable asset.
The hosts spend considerable time analyzing current vol mechanics, explaining how single-stock implied vol is being bid up by retail options buyers while quant funds short index vol, keeping the VIX suppressed. They note put skew is in the 4th percentile — extremely cheap protection — while call skew on semiconductors is in the 98th percentile, indicating extreme euphoria and poor risk/reward for new longs. One host shares charts on retail options flows and implied correlation to illustrate that systematic momentum strategies are amplifying the divergence between winning and losing stocks.
A significant portion of the discussion focuses on the K-shaped economy and deliberate policy choices that benefit asset owners at the expense of lower and middle-income households. The hosts argue that by propping up equity markets and suppressing vol through various mechanisms, policymakers are doing the exact opposite of what would help Main Street — which would require allowing market pain to slow inflation and then cutting rates to help small businesses and lower-income earners. They reference declining personal incomes, drawn-down SPR reserves, and falling savings rates as evidence that consumer buffers are eroding. One host warns that if the social contract breaks down, it creates conditions for more redistributive leftist political outcomes.
The discussion also covers Iran geopolitics as a key risk, with hosts arguing the U.S. has limited leverage and that Iran is incentivized to drag out negotiations while U.S. inventory buffers deplete. They expect Trump to eventually cut a deal, possibly worse than Obama's Iran deal, given midterm election pressure.
The hosts close with a discussion on trading psychology and portfolio management — emphasizing the value of patience, good entries in thematic trades, and mentally separating tactical short-term trades from long-term thematic positions. One host shares a framework from mentor Mark Hart involving 'concentric circles of adoption' (access, awareness, patina, TAM, collateral utility) as a way to evaluate thematic investment opportunities and when to enter or exit.
Key Insights
- One host argues that the Fed's non-rate stimulative measures — suppressing oil prices, yield curve control, currency manipulation — are collectively more stimulative than rate cuts would have been, and that removing these measures is more appropriate than hiking rates outright.
- The hosts argue that propping up equity markets deliberately harms Main Street because the correct policy sequence for lower-income relief would be to allow market pain, let inflation slow, and then cut rates to benefit small businesses — the exact opposite of current policy.
- One host draws a parallel between the current AI capital boom crowding out crypto investment and the 2012 tech productivity surge that sucked capital out of gold miners, suggesting structural capital rotation rather than just crypto-specific failure.
- The hosts identify that crypto's most adopted real-world use cases — stablecoins and payment rails — generate essentially zero value capture in crypto tokens, with even longtime Ethereum supporter David Hoffman publicly selling ETH while remaining bullish on the network.
- One host explains that the current VIX suppression is mechanically driven by retail investors buying single-stock calls (inflating single-stock vol) while quant funds short index volatility as a hedge — creating artificial calm that can unwind violently, similar to the 2024 carry trade unwind.
- One host argues that the shift from defined-benefit to defined-contribution pension plans mandated millions of workers to become passive ETF buyers with no duration management, creating massive structural inflows that have fundamentally distorted market rationality.
- One host presents Mark Hart's thematic investing framework of 'concentric circles of adoption' — evaluating access changes, awareness, patina, TAM, and collateral utility — as a superior method to fundamental earnings analysis for timing entries and exits in thematic trades.
- One host argues that political tolerance for the K-shaped economy is self-defeating because the more extreme the wealth divergence becomes without policy correction, the more likely the political outcome shifts toward redistributive leftist governance, citing AOC and Mamdani as examples of that trajectory.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access