What Happens If China Dumps US Treasurys?
Ken Fisher argues that fears about China dumping US Treasurys are overblown, noting that China only owns 2% of total US debt. He draws parallels to similar unfounded fears about Japan in the 1990s and explains that Treasury selling is typically just countries switching preferences between different sovereign debts.
Summary
Ken Fisher addresses what he considers an irrational fear about China potentially selling US Treasury bonds, arguing this concern stems from broader 'China phobia' rather than economic reality. He provides historical context by comparing current fears to similar concerns about Japan in the 1990s, when Japan was buying significant amounts of US real estate and Treasurys during their economic bubble period. Fisher emphasizes that China currently holds only 2% of total US Treasurys, the same amount as Japan, and actually less than the eurozone or Britain - countries that don't generate similar fears. He explains that when countries sell one nation's treasury bonds, they typically do so to buy another country's bonds based on changing preferences rather than abandoning government securities altogether. This creates a 'musical chairs' effect where money circulates between different sovereign debts. Fisher argues that any real concern should focus on relative interest rate movements between countries rather than individual country sales. He concludes that it would be difficult for any country to completely avoid US Treasurys given their importance in the global treasury market and their role in meeting the needs of private sector owners, governments, and central banks.
Key Insights
- Fisher argues that China owns the same amount of US Treasurys as Japan (2% of total) and actually less than the eurozone or Britain, making fears about Chinese selling inconsistent
- Fisher claims that when countries sell treasury bonds, they typically do so to buy other countries' bonds based on preference changes, creating a 'musical chairs' effect where money circulates between sovereign debts
- Fisher contends that it's difficult to completely avoid US Treasurys because they represent such an important part of the global treasury market and serve essential needs for private sector owners, governments, and central banks
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access