Oil’s Inflation Impact Isn’t What You Think
The speaker explains that oil price increases alone don't cause inflation - only central banks creating new money faster than economic growth does. When oil prices rise, people reallocate spending from substitutable goods to essential items like fuel, rearranging rather than increasing overall GDP.
Summary
The speaker challenges the common assumption that rising oil prices automatically lead to inflation, particularly in the context of recent Iran-related tensions. They explain that inflation is fundamentally caused by central banks creating new money at a rate exceeding the growth of goods and services, not by individual price increases. Using a mathematical example, they illustrate that if global economic growth is 3% and central banks target 2% inflation, money supply should grow at 5% to maintain this balance. The speaker introduces the concept of demand elasticity to explain how different goods respond to price changes. Items like bubblegum have elastic demand (easily substitutable), while oil has inelastic demand (difficult to replace). When oil prices rise and money supply growth remains constant, consumers are forced to reallocate their spending - driving less slightly but still maintaining essential transportation, while cutting back on substitutable items like expensive coffee or dining out. This reallocation might involve selling expensive cars for cheaper ones or moving to less expensive homes, but it doesn't change overall GDP levels, just rearranges production and consumption patterns. The speaker emphasizes that inflation only occurs if central banks 'accommodate' higher oil prices by increasing money supply growth, typically by incentivizing banks to lend more. They conclude by noting that this perspective contradicts popular belief but can be verified through monetary data available from sources like the Federal Reserve of St. Louis.
Key Insights
- The speaker argues that inflation is caused exclusively by central banks creating new money faster than the growth of goods and services, not by individual price increases
- The speaker explains that central banks targeting 2% inflation with 3% economic growth should maintain 5% money supply growth to achieve this balance
- The speaker distinguishes between elastic demand goods like bubblegum that are easily substitutable and inelastic demand goods like oil that are difficult to replace
- The speaker claims that when oil prices rise with constant money supply, consumers reallocate spending from substitutable items to essential fuel needs, rearranging rather than changing overall GDP
- The speaker states that oil price increases only become inflationary if central banks accommodate higher prices by increasing money supply growth through incentivizing bank lending
Topics
Transcript
[0:05] So, with all that's been going on recently relative to the Iran war and oil, you got a lot of people saying, and it's easy to understand why, that this will cause a jump in inflation. Not necessarily. Maybe. Let me show you the distinguishing features. The price of something going up because of features that relate uniquely to it, [0:35] whether it's a good or a service, is in and of itself, never inflationary. The price of oil going up by itself is not inflationary. The thing that causes inflation is central banks of the world creating new money. What most people call printing money, but there's no printing to it. Creating new money at a faster rate…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Fisher Investments
3 Things You Need to Know This Week | Consumer Credit, US Trade, Charitable Giving (Oct. 5, 2026)
This financial market briefing covers three key economic topics: US consumer credit data showing households in relatively strong financial shape despite rising debt, trade balance figures that can indicate economic strength rather than weakness, and charitable giving strategies including QCDs and donor-advised funds available as year-end approaches.
This Week in Review | Q3 Recap, US Jobs, US-China Trade (Oct. 2, 2026)
This Week in Review covers Q3 2026 market performance showing stocks up ~12% year-to-date despite geopolitical risks, discusses September's slower job growth and the flawed assumption that labor market expansion automatically triggers wage-driven inflation, and highlights a US-China tariff reduction agreement on $60 billion in goods as a positive step reducing trade uncertainty.
How Fisher Investments Helps Clients During Uncertain Markets
Fisher Investments advises investors to resist panic-driven decisions during market downturns, emphasizing that emotional reactions often harm long-term outcomes. The firm positions itself as a partner that provides education, communication, and perspective to help clients stay focused on their goals despite market volatility.
Curious About Fisher Investments? Start With a Conversation Built Around You.
Fisher Investments emphasizes a personalized, client-centered approach to wealth management that begins with understanding your goals and life circumstances rather than selling products. The firm offers comprehensive financial planning services aligned with your timeline, from pre-retirement accumulation through legacy planning, with fiduciary obligations and fee-based compensation that aligns their interests with clients.
How Fisher Investments’ Simple, Transparent Fee Structure Helps Clients
Fisher Investments emphasizes its simple, fee-only structure where advisers charge one straightforward portfolio-based fee with no commissions or transaction-based earnings, ensuring their interests align with clients' interests and fiduciary obligations are built into how the firm operates.