Ken Fisher: How Investors Know if a Recession is Coming
Ken Fisher argues that the stock market is the best recession predictor, with a perfect record when hitting new highs, followed by yield curve shifts as the second-best indicator. He challenges Paul Samuelson's famous criticism about the stock market's predictive failures.
Summary
Ken Fisher discusses the most reliable indicators for predicting recessions, challenging the conventional wisdom about market prediction accuracy. He references economist Paul Samuelson's famous 1960s quip that the stock market had 'predicted nine out of the last five recessions,' but argues this misses a crucial point about timing. Fisher contends that when the S&P 500 is hitting new highs and trending upward, it serves as an excellent timing indicator with a 'pretty much perfect record' - recessions don't begin until three to five months after such peaks. He identifies yield curve shifts as the second-best predictor, specifically changes in the relationship between short-term and long-term interest rates rather than their absolute levels. Fisher explains that yield curves are normally upward sloping but sometimes become inverted when short rates exceed long rates. These shifts serve as leading indicators because they predict banks' lending eagerness, which directly impacts economic activity. He dismisses the Conference Board's leading economic index series due to its 'wonky parts,' emphasizing that his two preferred indicators - stock market performance and yield curve shifts - provide the most reliable recession forecasting.
Key Insights
- Fisher argues the stock market has a perfect record as a timing indicator when the S&P 500 hits new highs, with recessions starting only 3-5 months after such peaks
- Fisher claims that critics miss the point about stock market prediction because they focus on false signals rather than the timing accuracy of upward trends
- Fisher identifies yield curve shifts, rather than absolute interest rate levels, as the second-best recession predictor
- Fisher explains that yield curve changes predict recession because they indicate banks' willingness to lend, which directly affects economic activity
- Fisher dismisses the Conference Board's leading economic index series as unreliable due to what he calls 'wonky parts' in its methodology
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access